Supreme Pizza of Westerly

Delicious pizza And THE BEST CRUST OF ALL WESTERLY PIZZERIAS! Highly recommended!!! I order from here a lot and my family loves it!

I can’t find a better pizza place in Westerly! They are always fast, fresh ingredients, and great pleasant people!

I’ve only had the pizza, but their pizza is the best in town hands down. It’s always consistent. The delivery is timely. Support a local business and give them a try.

Supreme pizza is a great place to get good pizza at a good price. Always very please with the flavor of anything that my family orders. Sometimes we find ourselves eating here twice a week.

Not a single complaint from me about Supreme Pizza.
Online ordering is easy and intuitive.
Delivery time estimated is almost always within 2 minutes.
Ingredients are fresh and food is never greasy.
Between my friends and I we had Chili Cheese Hot Dogs, Fenway Sausage Grinder, Roast Beef Grinder, and a large fry. Each of us said we would order our food again, but with such a large menu why limit yourself?
If you’re local or just visiting, make Supreme your first call on takeout night!
Edit: 2^nd order was just as good and they sent a free drink for either loyalty or my review or maybe just to be nice. I upgraded to 5 stars for their quality and customer service. This isn’t a 5 star gourmet restaurant but it sure is a 5 star local Italian/​Pizza place for when you’re in the mood for that!

I discovered this little pizza place this past summer. The food is simple, yet quite tasty. They offer a number of different topings for your pizza, or if pizza is not your cup of tea, you can get a variety of burgers, sandwiches, salads, etc. The staff is very kind, and brings the food out to your table. They also clean up after you are finished as would a restaurant… without the typical restaurant prices. I walked out with two slices of pizza and a drink for about six dollars and fifty cents. They also have televisions and free wifi for their guests. Looking forward to coming back again soon!

One of my favorites in town, the pizza is tasty, good sized and they offer many varieties. The subs are also really good. If you’re in the mood for a burger, I highly recommend the Texan burger. The staff are very friendly and accommodating.
I’ve never had anything delivered so I can’t speak on that but if it’s consistent with the rest of the operation I’m sure it’s top notch.

We tried Supreme a while back and had a horrible experience, as did many of our friends. We were urged to try it again a few months back and we were blown away! Every time we order, the food is great and consistent, it’s delivered quickly, and the drivers are awesome. Good prices to boot. I hope they don’t change what they’re doing… this is our new go-​to pizza place in the westerly area. Give the white pizza/​Texas calzone a try… they’re favorites. Keep it up!

My wife suggested grinders for dinner and I quickly did a search thru Unilocal for something close by. Supreme popped up at the beginning of the list and I chose them because of their easy online ordering. I was suprised that our food was delivered in about 20 minutes! It was delicious! I had the chicken parm, my wife had the chicken cutlet and my son ordered a meatball grinder. Scrumptious bread and cheese and sauce! Great prices with quick and easy ordering online, I’m hooked.

We LOVE supreme pizza! We have lived in many states over the past few years (Military family) and we always come back home, looking for «good pizza».
Supreme has been a favorite since we discovered it a few visits ago back home to Westerly.
We have ordered many different items off the menu, and have never been let down. We just moved back and haven’t even been here a week, already ordered 3 times.

Very nice place, clean, good food, their staff is very respectful and attentive. Great customer service and good time on deliveries. I would highly recommend them. I order very often since I work long hours and so far, so good. Keep up the great job.

My sister, her husband and their two kids were staying at my mom’s place. Before their long trek back to Jersey, they wanted to pick up something quick and easy for the kids. They asked me if there was anywhere in Westerly that had «pizza by the slice» so I sent them to Vetrano’s but since their recent remodeling, it looked too classy to sell «pizza by the slice». So they thought I was mistaken and meant to send them to Supreme’s.
After learning that Supreme’s didn’t have «pizza by the slice» they inquired about their small pizzas. They were told it had 6 slices. So they went ahead and ordered.
It took over 30 minutes and the pizza was tiny. It was like equal to 1 ½ slices of NY pizza. They ate the pizza at my house and I wondered how’d they get a box for a frozen pizza. Seriously it was slightly bigger than those $ 1 microwave pizzas. Yeah. And cut into 6 slices. Picture this. It was like 6 of those half pint Poland Spring water bottles all lined up like synchronized swimmers. That’s how big the slices were. It’s great for crust lovers. Cuz you only have to take two bites before you can chow down on the crust.
That’s a first time I’ve seen an 8 year old and a 6 year old finish a pizza all on their own. Pretty impressive… Add a star for them at least finishing it.

Stopped by here on a whim.

For starters, we tried a stuffed cherry pepper. They were fabulous. Mildly spicy and stuffed with a yummy egg plant filling.
Next I had the Italian Wedding Soup. Mrs had the Mediterranean Eggplant soup which was AMAZING. My soup was also good, but as good as my wife’s soup.
Mrs and I shared the stuffed peppers & gluten free pasta. Mrs is a self proclaimed expert of stuffed peppers, and she said these were very very authentic. For me, they tasted just yummy! Highly recommend.
Our boys shared a small pizza. I took a bite and it was pretty good.
If you are in the area, be sure to stop by. Looks like they also have some decent lunch specials.

Love their pizza… Favorite in Westerly, love their prices… And they are very friendly! Great onion rings too.

I got the menu in the mail on Monday and decided to go there to try it out. The food was really good and the price was really good, especially for average people. I didnt smell no smoke both times I went there and the staff was very polite and friendly. I dont like Pizza, but I enjoy the variety of items they have. I can go there and get many different styles of foods. Westerly has a lot of Pizza places but these guys are unique at what they do. Its family owned and you always see them working their best. I really think you should try various things because Im sure you will find something you like.

Nothing great there. I asked if they had fresh basil for the pizza and they said no. I ordered a small pizza, fried chicken dinner, fries and a gyro. Only thing good was the gyro. Nothing authentic there.

Heard it was good, decided to try. Ordered 2 pizzas for takeout. Pizza was warm, not hot. Very little sauce, very bland. Pepperoni pizza, and Veggie «Gourmet» pizza. People at take-​out counter seemed nice, but wouldn’t go again. Pizza wasn’t that good. Very disappointed.

Let me start by saying, i HATE pan pizza. Supreme’s pizza was pretty good could use more sauce, the ratio of sauce to cheese, the cheese definitely outweighed the sauce. The menu is so broad from stuffed shells to chili cheese dogs, hamburgers to pizza, what are you going for, a pizza place, like in your name or just a different approach to five guys with pizza and a couple italian dishes on the menu? The service was good, but I feel like westerly has too many pan pizza places, maybe its just a rhode island thing. I hope they do well, so that some of these other pan pizza places will just get out of town, but when I think of pizza, i dont think of a PAN i like my crust crunchy, dough cooked right on the brick like pizza is supposed to be made. To sum it all up, it looks like this place is trying too hard to please people, stick to what you’re good at, if its pizza, hotdogs and hamburgers,
I dont like places that serve pizza and hamburgers its just a weird concept if you ask me. There are alot of italian places in westerly so maybe thats why they went that route and maybe it will work… that space has been vacant for sooooo long so hopefully they can turn it into a profitable place. Overall if you like RI pizza, not talking NY style or New Haven which are cooked right on the brick, but a pan pizza, you might enjoy this, but my personal opinion once youve had one pan pizza youve had them ALL! I hope the best for them, only being open a month or so they will have no problem competing with the other places 50 ft away!

I come to Westerly often for business and I’ve even at pretty much all the lunch spots in the area. Supreme Pizza offers a wide range of food choices at a reasonable price without sacrificing quality. Their service is exceptional and is a place I can see myself going often.

This is my new favorite pizza place in Westerly! I love the pizza here, including the crust. My favorite pizza place closed several years ago. I kept trying to order the same pizza (that I loved from the old place) at different restaurants & no one ever came close. Supreme Pizza nailed it! What’s my all time favorite pizza? White pizza with fresh tomato slices. Friendly staff, extensive menu, great food, what more could you want? Had a Greek Burger today. Cooked perfectly & so tasty. So far — after 4 times — I haven’t been disappointed in anything I’ve gotten here.