Nancy’s Pizza

NAST-​Y. My husband ordered a large cheese and sausage, well done. Cheese was still pretty much white and he did not like the taste. Ate two pieces and we threw it out. I got an Italian beef and an order of fries. The beef was not bad but nothing special. The fries. They charge $ 1.95 for an order. I got home and I had this HUGE paper bag that had about 10 fries in it. I called and they said that they pre-​weight. I told him that was fine but you are overcharging for it and I think that’s horrible and I would not order from them again. He said «ok» and hung up. Guess they could care less about happy customers.

We were in Westmont for a funeral and had Nancys deliver to our hotel. The 2 sandwiches were tasty and hot. The thin crust cheese pizza was excellent. Food arrived faster than predicted. Will order again when in area.

Absolutely in love with Nancy’s pizza! Quick and affordable. Love that there’s always coupons!

I look forward to getting Nancy’s Pizza every trip I take the the Chicago burbs.
The super thick Chicago style crust, sauce and toppings are so good.
Keep it simple with 1 – 2 toppings!

I thought I should share the experience I just had here. My sister and I ordered a pizza online (stuffed, pepperoni, jalapenos). We got there when it said it would be ready. They had just received the printout and hadn’t even put the order in yet. I understand that mistakes happen, but we waited another 30 minutes before it was ready. I was half hoping they would offer to discount the order, but they did not. But I didn’t care enough to ask. So we got it home, opened the box, and it was a stuffed pizza, with olives and mushrooms on it (and none of the toppings we ordered). I didn’t want to take it back since we had just driven home, so I called to see if they could give us some sort of compensation. The woman offered $ 5 off our next order. Really? This was a $ 27 pizza that was wrong in every way possible. So she went to talk to her manager, came back, and said the most her manager said they’ll do is $ 10 off our next order. To me, a full refund would have been appropriate. Or at least 50%. I will use the $ 10 in the future, but will think twice about going back to this location again after that. Mistakes happen, but when literally everything is messed up, from the order time to the entire $ 27 pizza we paid for, a small credit towards my next order just doesn’t quite make up for it.

Since apparently, it’s national pizza day, we decided it was only appropriate to indulge. Found a Groupon for this place and decided to give it a try. Ordered a «roccos party pizza» (green peppers, mushrooms, onions, and sausage) and a tomato basil thin crusts. Greek salad on the side in efforts to be healthy. Pickup was ready in about 30 min; friendly and helpful service when we got there. Pizza was great and generously topped. The salad had tons of olives, feta, and peppers, and fresh lettuce. Without the Groupon, it would have been a little pricey, but I would def go to this place again with another groupon.

Best pizza in Chicagoland hands down!!! Thin crust cheese w/​Extra pizza sauce is my preference but either way you will love it! Order within 10 days and you get 20% off your next order!

Just recently moved to the area from the east coast. Never been a fan of «thick Chicago style» pizza as where I come from that doesn’t exist. Anyways, I tried Nancys thin crust on Weds night and was pleasantly surprised. Ample toppings, good crust and good customer service. I would recommend this place!

We ordered from Nancy’s for the first time the other night. We got the thin crust, and it was really good. I was impressed and my whole family liked it. It’s a little pricey (2 16″ pizzas with two toppings and a family salad = $ 60), but they don’t skimp on toppings and delivery was hot and fast. I guess if you want good pizza you have to pay for it. We will be going back.

This location doesn’t make a good product. I order spinach on my pizza and got three green strings and the pizza wasn’t good. The woodridge location is much better.

The deep dish pizza is outstanding!

So, about a week after my last review, I received a call from the owner, who said that he just took over the business & was working on improvements. We discussed what had happened. I decided to go back, mainly because he assured me that it wouldn’t happen again, but also because I know their pizza is good.
Much happier with my second order! Ordered 2 pizzas. Only tried one, because my wife wanted olives on the other (one of the few foods I dislike).
On a side note, whenever I pick up a pizza or have it delivered, I always ask for the pizza to not be cut. When a pizza is cut, the juices are allowed to seep into the crust, causing soggy pizza. Ordering no-​cut, halts this unwantedness, until you’re ready to eat. Try this the next time you order. If you taking the orders, then suggest it to you customers.
Previous review:
Not too happy with our order.
Ordered a pizza with giardiniera, onion & mushroom, which is swimming in the oil, because the giard wasn’t drained.
Also ordered potato wedges with BBQ sauce. We got about 10 wedges (doesn’t seem like an «order»), & they forgot the BBQ.

Pretty good pizza! It’s not quite as good as Barone’s or L&F Pizza, but still, very good. We ordered the pizza for pickup. It was ready when the said it would be ready. One nice item that Nancy’s Pizza includes with their pizzas are miniature pizza tables. They are designed to keep the top of the box from sagging/​being pushed into the pizza. Yep, pretty good pizza. I said that already, but it is true.

Whenever I come home to Chicago, I am usually excited to see my relatives who always greet me at the airport with open arms and a deep deep Nancy’s pizza in the car. Yeah it’s a chain but they still do their deep dish pizza well.
I love the spinach-​mushroom-​sausage deep dish pizza which is my family’s go-​to pizza. They recently created a deep dish «lite» version which I don’t get at all. I haven’t tried it but really if you’re going to go deep dish, there’s no point to going «lite»!

My family was hankering for some pizza, and the Chicago burbs offers many options. We were looking for something new and different, so we tried Nancy’s. I’m going to stick with Giordano’s for stuffed pizza, but their thin crust pizza is phenomenal!
We ordered the bbq chicken pizza and it was superb. The pizza was filled with huge chunks of chicken, gooey, sweet, bbq sauce, onions and cheese added a nice tang. Cannot wait to order from here again!

Nancy’s makes very good stuffed pizza.
This is not really a sit down place although they do have a few bar stools, which is used mainly to wait for your order. It’s definitely a pickup or delivery pizza place.
I’m not a fan of their thin crust and would order elsewhere if I’m in the mood for thin. But I love their stuffed. They have two stuffed sizes: original stuffed (2.5″) and stuffed lite (1.5″) which is great because I’m not always in the mood for a huge crust so the lite option is perfect.
I always order to pick up and it amazes me how fast they have their pizzas ready considering they are made fresh to order. They usually have the pizza ready in under 30 minutes. I like a few of their appetizers too like the baked zucchini, jalapeño poppers, and broccoli tempura.

Pizza Chain that has very good pizza. The taste is not outstanding, but it is dependable. The prices are average and when you call in an order, the pizza is delivered hot and in a reasonable amount of time. It’s a good place to treat yourself and your family for ordering out any night!