Jeremiah’s Italian Ice

Where else can you choose from 20+ Italian ice flavor options paired with creamy, vanilla or chocolate soft serve? And get that refreshing dessert served with a smile? And listen to fun, nostalgic music? No where. Jeremiah’s is it!

Absolutely the best italian ice/​gelati out there!!! A must have when in Florida. Mango’s my fave.

I’m pretty sure it’s considered blasphemous that I live in Central FL and had never been here. Now I understand why every time I pass one the line is around the corner. I had the Orange Smash ice and it was #soooooogood. I will be back to try other flavors.

Great Italian ice at a very reasonable price. Service is always energetic and super friendly. So many flavors with seasonal flavors always rotating in and out. Some of the favorites are scoop froggy frog (mint chocolate chip), peanutyy, cookies and crème, and many more! They have a single lane drive through, or you can walk up and order with small benches to sit and relax.

This company has been around since I’ve been a little girl. It’s nice to see that they have expanded and open multiple locations in central Florida.
The ice is top notch. My favorite is always coconut or orange. Have the orange ice with vanilla ice cream. It’s a true dreamsicle.
Don’t eat too fast or you’ll get a brain freeze! However, it will probably be the best brain freeze you’ll ever get because the ice is so delicious!
I hope they continue to expand the company and maybe come down to SW Florida so I can have it all the time!

Love love love it! The gelati is the best and the pinacolada is the best!

Anytime someone comes to visit Orlando, we share the magical beauty that is Jeremiah’s with them. There’s no place like it and there’s absolutely nothing more delicious on this planet. I want their salted caramel Italian ice/​vanilla soft serve in an IV! I want them to build a new location in my backyard. No, in my kitchen! The backyard is much too far away for such tasty goodness. I mean, why are you even still reading this? GO PUT SOME IN YOUR BELLY RIGHT MEOW. That’s an order!

Caveat: I’ve never really been a fan of Italian ices unless they were authentically made with fruit juices. This was our first trip to Jeremiah’s and I must say, the young women that work there are friendly and helpful. They rate five stars. I tried the strawberry lemon and hubby tried the lemon. Far too cloyingly sweet for either of us. We pitched them and re-​ordered the chocolate soft-​serve. He doesn’t like soft-​serve and didn’t like this either. I thought it was good. Far better than MANY other soft-​serve chains. Though it was hot, there was a nice breeze so we sat outside. Drive-​thru was very busy and the tables were full with a variety of families, college students, teens and seniors. A nice mix of people. Would we go back? I will definitely go back for the soft-​serve but honey says he’ll not. To each his own.

Love Jeremiah’s. We have been going to see the Frog Squad since they opened a location over by UCF. Now moved on from college life, we frequent the Winter Springs location. Here they have friendly staff and they really knows how to move a packed drive thru! I even like the personal service of giving a order face to face in the drive thru versus a speaker. They really get their exercise running back and forth between the kitchen and cars.

This place has a drive thru! We ordered small gelatis and they came out quick. The gelati base they use is very good. Very nice place to come and cool off on a hot day.

Jeremiah’s is delicious! We love this as a Sunday treat and can never get enough. A million great flavors to try, friendly and fast service and always a great experience.

This was my first time trying the Gelati. I had the salted caramel with vanilla. Very tasty!

This place is unbelievable and makes the best Italian I’ve on the planet.!.

The best — I love the Italian ice here, my kids love it too. The mint chocolate chip (scoop Froggy Frog) is awesome. The watermelon is also one of our favorites. Yum!

Jeremiah’s is my favorite desert place in Orlando. Numerous flavors of Italian ice that are always rotating through and great soft serve ice cream make for excellent gelato.
The prices are inexpensive and coupons for buy one get one deals are frequent. This is another example of a great local chain.

The best and most reasonably priced treat in all of Orlando. I love the ices with and without the gelati. My absolute favorite is the seasonal Pumpkin Pie (it literally tastes like a yummy slice of pie), but since you can only nab that in the fall my other favs are:
Strawberry
Cotton Candy Gelati (this taste like strawberry Quik to me)
Pins Colada (if you are over 21 add some rum — yum)
Cherry
Watermelon
Also if you have your pups with you they will give them pup cups;)

It makes me happy seeing local businesses expand, and when they opened here i was thrilled. They seem pretty much the same across the board, service is polite, and they do samples! (Don’t be afraid to ask for a sample for your dog.) Flavors, flavors, and flavors. They’re all awesome, I never had a bad «snack» here (Struggled to find the correct word for a meal at a gelato place.)

When a gelato stand showed up in the building that used to be a Checkers I was suspicious. I began taking my daughter to this location and they have totally won me over. There is a lot of competition in the area but Jeremiah’s has risen to the challenge.
The first thing that sets Jeremiah’s apart is the quality of their product. I’ve been told that they make their ice fresh every day and by the taste I can believe it. They have every crazy flavor combination that you can think of – I’m a peanut butter/​chocolate kind of guy but they’ve got something for everyone.
I like the fact that they have a drive-​through service too. I personally don’t use it but I can see how that would be handy for some folks.
The only reason it gets four stars instead of five is that there is no indoor eating area. Like I said, it was an old Checkers so there are still picnic tables you can sit at outside but in the heat of the summer I would like a little more than that! So basically, in the spring (5 stars!) but in the hot months all the gelato in the world can’t cool this cat down.

This may be the number one reason I am jealous of my husband’s life in Florida. He’s within walking distance of this place and I’m within walking distance of the liquor control board and AAA. His life trumps mine.
Anyhow, this location was easy to get to and a great place to take our dog on a walk to. They had a variety of flavors, but I chose to get Strawberry Lemon with vanilla ice cream — a «gelati.» I am curious as to how we took the plural of gelato to mean this combo — but whatever — I love it whatever it is called. The ice was perfect — not too dense, well flavored, and not too watery. The custard/​ice cream/​soft serve was thick and creamy — and paired perfectly with the ice.
Amazingly, the peanut butter ice and chocolate ice cream my husband got was delicious. I was suspicious about the mix at first — but man is it amazing.
There is a drive thru and walk up — but I like the walk up and sitting and the clean picnic tables they have out.

What a great addition to the Winter Springs area! I’ve been to the other Jeremiah’s around town but I was really excited to see this pop up. You can get gelati or italian ice and oh my it’s so delicious! I got a mix of the cherry & lemon gelati when I went and it was so good.
If you’re unsure about a flavor, don’t be afraid to ask to try — they’re really friendly at Jeremiah’s. Also, they have a drive thru!
Go check them out — great treat for all this hot weather. :)