Timothy’s Bakery

Another beautiful and perfect cake from Timothy’s bakery! Whenever we make the four hour journey to Woodland from Fort Bragg, CA to visit family we must bring home a cake! We wish we had a Timothy’s bakery here in Fort Bragg California.. Highly recommend… you won’t be disappointed.

I just discovered their custard filled donuts — OMG, forget Krispy Kreme — these are crack donuts; light, fluffy, delicate, and incredibly FRESH. Their bags of rolls on the counters are all fresh and delicious as well.

Timothy’s did my baby shower cake and it was amazing. Just perfect! Every one said it was one of the best cakes they have ever had and it looked exactly as I wanted! Thank you Timothy’s!

We ordered our son’s 1^st birthday cake from Timothy’s. We got a half-​sheet Champagne Cake and paid additional for fresh strawberries. But I’m going to ding one star because the «fresh strawberries» were actually some kind of strawberry sauce-​type filling. I wish that had been made clear. Luckily we served some fresh strawberries on the side with the cake, so that made up for it, but I would not have paid $ 8 extra for goopy strawberry sauce had I known that’s what it was. It was $ 50 total for the cake and they did basic decorations on it in the colors we had specified, although nothing super special. The Champagne Cake itself was tasty and everyone at the party enjoyed it. I also took off a star for customer service. I walked in to order my cake while juggling an infant and while I saw 3 – 4 staffers in the back with whom I made eye contact, I had to wait a full 10 minutes before someone would come to the front to take my order. Even after someone came to help me, she walked away for a few more minutes in the middle of me placing my order to finish talking to a coworker in the back and take a phone call. It was a little unprofessional in my opinion and made me wonder if I shouldn’t just order a cake from Costco at half the price. My family members enjoyed the fresh baked goods and donuts they got when they picked up the cake on the day of the party, but I’m not sure that I will return in the future.

Perfect Wedding cake. Showed them 1 picture got exactly what I wanted at a great price. No pressure to do more or spend more. The carrot cake was delicious.

Amazing wedding cake!!! So many compliments on how our cake looked but even more how it tasted. So many guests said it was the best wedding cake they had had. The delivery was later than scheduled but I was unaware until my mom told me the next day. It was there when I was ready to cut. Four days later I’m still eating the leftovers they’re still amazing

Love this place, best in town, called at last minute for a bday cake and they did an excellent job!

Worst looking birthday cake ever! Don’t be fooled by the pictures on their website! Completely overpriced when the cake looks like a 5-​year-​old masterpiece.
Pre-​ordered the cake at least a week in advance and the cake looks like they finished making it 5 minutes ago.
Huge disappointment.

This place is the best. Has a good selection and everything is very delicious! Love getting the donuts. If your every in downtown woodland and your sweet tooth is itching it is a must to stop by!

This review is long over due, but better late than never.
Last year i came to Timothy’s to talk about some wedding cake ideas at Timothy’s, where i met Katelyn.
I showed her some pictures of the cakes my wife really liked and hope they could replicate. Katelyn took the time to go over all my questions and provided great insight to what would work and what wouldnt.
The cake we wanted had lots of little edible bead work that added complexity to the cake. Katelyn told me it might be possible but she would have to talk to Kathy about it. Luckily things worked out and they were able to source the right beads and confirmed that they could make the cake in the picture i showed them.
I chose all the flavors of each tier with the help of Katelyn, gave her the info on the wedding date and setup times. She texted me the day of and confirmed everything with me and the cake was there exactly how we wanted it and on time!
It was a pleasure working with Katelyn and Kathy at Timothy’s. They do excellent work and i would not hesitate to order from them again.

I went to this bakery from a recommendation from a friend. I told the lady that helped me what vision i had for the cake and we decided exactly what we wanted based on a pictures. I took a style from one cake and one from another. When they made my cake for me it turned out EXACTLY like I wanted it to. It was absolutely perfect! They are also inexpensive too. I called around and everything was like double the price for a 4 tier cake that I needed for my big wedding. They definitely came through for me. :)

first off, exceptional pastries. the customer service here has always been phenomenon. Back when I was in high school, this would be my go to place before class starts. I like having a fresh donuts before hand and they are always open right before my class starts. I highly recommend them.

Timothy’s Bakery provided our wedding cake last weekend and the experience was perfect. We got several compliments on how our cake tasted delicious! My husband and I thought it was the best tasting wedding cake we have ever had. And after shopping around before finding them, they were the most affordable as well, which made the decision easy. We got a two tier cake along with two sheet cakes and we rented the tree stump as well which was a huge hit. They were easy to work with, which may be what I appreciated the most as some of my other vendors were not that easy to work with.
My only ‘complaint’ was I don’t believe they left a cake box for us to out the top tier in to take home, but they gave us one as soon as we returned the stump the next day and the cake was still delicious and perfect looking. Thank you so much Timothy’s bakery in woodland! We will be using you again!!!

We did our wedding cake with Timothy’s. They were great to work with. They didn’t pressure us into any decisions and worked to create the cake we were looking for. I never worried about the cake style, delivery, etc. It showed up on time and looked great. It tasted even better! We ordered a confetti naked/​exposed cake. We were so pleased with how it turned out. And everyone at the wedding commented on how great it was!

I had my wedding in 2011 and wasn’t a profound Unilocaler yet, so here I am, making amends and giving this bakery the kudos it deserves.
They did two cakes for me: a wedding cake and then a groom’s cake. Overall, the family did an EXCELLENT job keeping communication open and making sure the design, concept, flavors, colors etc. were all what i wanted. If they couldn’t make something happen, they would offer up their best recommendation for an alternative.
On to the cakes. People are STILL raving about both how beautiful and delicious our wedding cakes were! When i first saw it in person, i was speechless. Granted, I was already emotional from a full day of love and unity, but this was the proverbial drop of water than broke the dam. The main cake design was JUST as I described, both elegant and clean. The groom’s cake — well, it looked just like a super nintendo! I even provided them with a video game cartridge and two controllers, which they incorporated perfectly.
I should also mention that coming in for taste testing and general introductory communications with them made me feel at ease — they were ready and willing to help with whatever i needed, and as a stressed out bride at the time, it was truly a breath of fresh air. Other pros: they deliver, and their price point is wonderfully manageable. Anyone who has planned a wedding knows that budget is everything!
The only negative in my own personal book is that living in San Francisco, the drive to Woodland was long. I wish they were closer!

Timothy’s bakery is the best around! Absolutely delicious and friendly service. Timothy’s made a beautiful wedding cake for us Sept. 2012 and I was still in need to write a review! If you are looking for cakes, cupcakes, or even just a morning pastry– this is the place to go!

Was here earlier today to return a cake stand for my girlfriend who ordered her wedding cake from Timothy’s. Her wedding was in Sacramento, where we’re from, so that right there already shows how good their cakes must be. I, unfortunately, was busy with bridesmaid duties and never got a slice of this beautiful cake. However, I had a chance to speak with the guy that delivered it and he was the nicest guy ever! He set up the cake for us and it was just beautiful. I saw him again today when I was there and, again, he was a pleasure to speak with.
Of course, I couldn’t leave without trying their pastries so I grabbed a maple donut, powdered sugar donut, crumb donut, red velvet cookie, florentine cookie, snickerdoodle and this other one with fudge on top that I forget the name of. I didn’t get to try everything since I shared them with friends but whatever I did have was delcious! And to top it all off, I spent less than $ 4. When he gave me my total, I literally said «wow!» If I was closer, I’d definitely be a regular!

If you’re a student at UC Davis, you’d notice that there isn’t really much to choose from when it comes to bakeries (well, at least not as many as I’m used to). Woodland may be out of the way, but if you have a car and a special event coming up, the drive to Timothy’s is well worth it.
If you’re sick of having only donuts, supermarket baked goods, or mediocre Davis desserts, make the 20 minute drive up to Woodland and be amazed at the selection. There’s an even bigger variety here than in some San Franciscan bakeries. They’ve got cute petit-​fours, cookies, and bars perfect for gifting or snacking on, and if you’re looking for cake, they’ve got an excellent menu to choose from. Choose a size (smallest= cupcakes or 8-​in round), choose your cake flavor from like 12 different ones, choose a filling, an icing (whipped cream, chocolate whipped cream), choose a design and a color. If you don’t have a design in mind, look at the beautiful displays – you’re sure to get ideas from comical to elegant.
They’re very punctual and will rush a cake if you need them to. Plus, they deliver.

Always tasty, always beautifully decorated and always reasonably priced. Their fruit basket is the BEST. You will not be disappointed. Promise! :) We have been ordering birthday cakes from Timothy’s for over 30 years, we should know. And we come all the way from Sacramento. It is that good.
I saw a bad review about a wedding cake experience. That is sad to me, because Timothy’s is a wonderful bakery. That may have been the personal thoughts of the cake designer that you spoke to, and I know that if it was my wedding cake, I would want someone to be honest with me. They probably have lots of cakes in different varieties and shapes and flavors and fillings, ect. because that is what the customers want. I wouldn’t knock the whole company because of one persons views. She was probably giving you her experience, and she would be after all the expert. I don’t know that it meant she was not professional or had bad service. That has never been my experience.

Donuts. They make their own donuts. If this place was in NYC, there would be a line around the corner. I would give it 6 stars if I could.
Thanks for keeping a bakery alive in a small town.