Mmm-Marcia’s Sweet Pantry

Holy, Batman, Macia knows how to make a woopie pie. Right now (October) she has pumpkin spice woopie pies with cream cheese frosting. I was in Wrentham on a week-​long rotation. I popped in with a major sweet tooth on Thursday on recommendation from some new friends. She had recently taken the woopie outsides from the oven and was getting ready to fill them. I had to have one fresh. It was so amazing, I went back Friday to grab a couple more for dinner at a friend’s house. t only $ 2.50 a woopie, it would be a crazy addiction if I lived in the area.
I had heard from others that her pies and cupcakes are great. Judging by the consistency of the woopie pies, I’d say her cupcakes had to be great.
I have, however, heard that her full cakes are not as noteworthy. Pies and full cakes have to be ordered in advance. I heard the pies are $ 12 each and worth the price.
She offers a lot more than baked goods. She has fudge, candy, tea, oats and such, toys, books, etc. This can make the shop look cluttered, but she’s supportive of other locals, selling their things.

I do not suggest getting any cakes from here. My friend and I had ordered a cake from here for her daughters birthday. My friend specifically asked Marcia to do certain designs on the cake and even gave her a napkin of the birthday theme so she could do those designs on the cake. Well, the day of the party arrived and after seeing the cake, it looked horrible! The cake was nothing like what was asked for and was just horribly done, very unprofessional looking. The worst part was, the cake was inedible. It was so dry and gross that most people took one bite and tossed. Literally, people threw their slices away. We were so disappointed and disgusted that someone actually made us pay for such garbage. I do NOT reccommend this place at all…