Il Pescatore Capri

This was the first place we could find to get away from the tourist hordes roaming around the docks in Capri. It was better than expected. Nice pizza and pasta and even a milkshake. There was a bit of a mix up on the orders due to language problems but it was quickly and cheerfully corrected. Inexpensive compared to other restaurants in Italy.

Kind of a ripoff. I felt like the tour guide hustled us tickets for 18 € per person (with 15 € per student) because of our appearance as tourists. This boat tour would give us a tour of the entire island.
The boat is pretty big, but still intimate enough to see most of your boat companions. The seats are great for seeing the entire side that you are seated on. The tour was led in Italian with a broken English translation. Parts of it, I believe the translator got caught up in the views and the Italian dialogue that he would forget to translate.
With all those complaints being said. The sun felt great and the wind felt great and the views were beautiful. We saw some colorful grottos, statues, cliffs and even some mountain goats. It almost seemed posed to see the three random goats on the cliffs.
The tour ended up being over an hour: from 2:45−4, approximately. This was definitely much faster than trying to walk and travel around the island, as the tour guide promised, but we did miss out on still moments on top of cliffs or at the lighthouse.
If you are in a rush, I recommend taking the boat tour. Otherwise, take your time and explore the island on your own!

Getting off the Caremar fast boat, Laser Capri employees were right there on the ferry dock selling tours around the island. They said that the boat was leaving right now and we looked over (literally the boat next to the ferry) and saw that the boat was barely 50% full. It wasn’t a super small boat either. Our research online said that these tours usually pack you in like sardines, so getting a lucky break that the boat was half full, we decided to go. Each person was 17 Euros. The ride itself was enjoyable — it was one of those perfect, sunny, warm-​but-​not-​hot days.
We did not go into the Blue Grotto. It was high tide at 1pm. Moreover, even if boats were allowed to enter the Grotto, I think we had to pay more money to go into the Grotto on another smaller boat.