Stewart’s Restaurant

Great place, takes their time in making drinks that taste delicious ! Since I ordered to go, I can not comment on their food. Kinda cool they have bar seating as well !

All in all a good place to eat. Clean, service is good, the best sweet potato French fries you have ever had. I ordered the popcorn shrimp and it was all bread, otherwise I would give it 5 stars. Don’t order anything breaded and you will be good to go. I would go back to try their burgers and other things. Would recommend giving it a try. I know people who thoroughly enjoy this place.

Never even knew there was a restaurant for «Stewarts» but when I passed by this little spot I had to check it out. I was surprised to find that its actually nowhere near little, the inside was awesome because it resembled the whole roller skate waitress back in the day theme, so I already had a pretty cool vibe walking in. Everyone was super friendly and all smiles. Wasn’t sure what to expect for food, when I had asked the waitress what smelled so delicious she told me it was the waffles, though i wasn’t in the mood for breakfast she went to prepare it for her table and gave me a glimpse topped with a huge ice-​cream scoop and fresh cut strawberries. I opted for a california cheesesteak with american cheese and sweet potato fries.
I can now proudly say I am a sweet potato addict, they were so good. The philly cheesesteak was really big, and when I told them I needed it wrapped because I wasn’t going to finish my waitress even told me next time I could substitute the hero bread for a wrap. Im absolutely addicted, can’t wait to go back !

We so miss the old dinner that was here… This place is a hot mess. Was there last night, at 8 pm, there is only one waiter for the whole place. He forgot about appetizer, brought out our food first then appetizer which we didn’t want. Never came to see how was everything. What a bummer, we really wanted to like this place… Definitely not the same satisfaction… quality … & hospitality as the last owners… Last time I’m going there!!!

This 50’s style diner has tile floors and red booths. Service is friendly, portions are generous. I love the salads. The American cuisine offers burgers and sandwiches. The ice cream is homemade, and the root beer floats are yummy.

Decided to come here with my family for brunch on a Saturday. The décor resembles that of old school diners, something that a lot of places lost. We were in a group 8, were seated immediately and were very comfortable
I ordered the Benedict wrap, with turkey bacon; I was a bit hesitant at first, have never really had Eggs Benedict as a wrap but I actually enjoyed it. It came with a side of house potatoes. As always, I ordered a second dish, Belgian waffles which were also pretty good.
I also tried their Breakfast burrito, it was a bit spicy but tasty and filling as well. I also got to try their Western omelette, which was probably my least favorite. The service here was great, would def come back; my family was satisfied

Saturday morning breakfast, all the tables filled and yet no cooking smells, how odd.
I soon found out why. I ordered pancakes and bacon. My order appeared almost instantaneously… rancid re-​heated bacon, lukewarm, rubbery pancakes. Is this food pre-​cooked and then nuked?
The orange juice was ok.

I have lived in Bay Ridge almost 30 years. Eaten at Hinsch’s a few times. No great shakes (no pun). Limited food menu. More a dessert place. Then they changed hands and now the place is my «go-​to» restaurant. They renovated the inside, making it more modern, and they renovated the menu as well. Now it’s more like a diner, and I mean that in a good way.
My food has always been prepared the way I like, portions are plentiful, and they replaced the Storm Trooper waitress with several extremely pleasant and friendly servers. We have two favorites – Ali and Adriana. Both greet us and talk to us like friends and always provide excellent and professional service. On the weekends, we get to see Barbara. Always a treat.
Eating at Stewarts is like eating at home, only without the stress and dirty dishes.

I was visiting friends in Bay Ridge and we decided to get dinner at Stewart’s.
It is a Wednesday and we did not expect a whole crowd at the restaurant.
There were no crowds and only two tables were occupied.
I ordered the Stewart’s signature hamburger and a side of fries.
What I got was a nice looking platter but I quickly discover cold fries and lukewarm burger.
The onion was a small chunk that made it difficult to eat.
I ask for a hamburger and I got a cheeseburger.
The pink sauce they slapped on the bottom was messy and already soaked through my lower buns. So it appeared to have been sitting on the count for a while.
The burger platter– below average. Rate ²⁄₅
Service was slow, two waitresses and two tables but never could find one for napkins and refill on the water.
This place is definitely not my favor.

I had high hopes for a chain restaurant from Stewart’s. Unfortunately the empty restaurant with two tables occupied should have scared me away. Little did I realize what I would be in for.
The restaurant itself is clean and the décor is funky as any mass produced chain.
When we first walked in no one greeted us or said hello. We stood around for about 45 seconds before our waitress said sit wherever we’d like. She was great throughout the service.
The food: horrible, cooked on a dirty grill and with chicken that had been cooked to the point of no moisture left in the flesh. Cheese was stringy and chewy like it was fake. Bread was oily and burnt.
Soup was very salty and lacked any substance like ham or chunks. Split pea was served without croutons. Milk shake tasted artificial. My friend actually asked if it tasted like plastic and I told him it was because they either used artificial vanilla ice cream or that it was some sugary syrup they added to sweeten it.
All together the entire meal was a let down. No actual dinner menu. Hot dogs, burgers, some breakfast and a glorified page of specials that seemed mediocre at best.
Service was impeccable but unfortunately that is not edible, in this instance, neither is the food.

Came here for a late night sweet snack. GREAT on a weekday because they are open until midnight and EVEN BETTER on weekends because they are open ²⁴⁄₇. We got some root beer floats and they were dope. Didn’t disappoint. Vanilla ice cream was creamy and delicious. We also got the a waffle with ice cream. The waffle was so good, we had to get another one. Can’t speak for the savory foods yet tho :)
Service was quick and friendly, will definitely be back soon. So glad to have a Stewart’s open up in Brooklyn!

Had a great meal… Service was excellent
Had a great Root Beer FloAt with ice cream overflowing.
Would definitely go back and a highly recommend this place for a quick friendly meal

Came here with my bro and friend. Had the cheeseburger on an English Muffin, brother had the buffalo chicken wrap, friend had the cheeseburger with sweet potato fries. Food was good diner food. But the service was immaculate, that’s what sets them apart from others. I was greeted and seated by an older lady whom I assume was the owner or something. She was extremely nice and then we had a waitress who was very attentive and helpful (she was beautiful as well) she even told us about these flavor powder to season up your fries, she basically gave us all of them and let do our thing lol. I would absolutely come back here again with people.

I want to love this place, but can’t. I was in there today, and my server barely understood or spoke English. He first told me no when I ordered a kids root beer float for my daughter. I asked him what he meant. He said no they don’t do that. Yes, they do. I’m in here at least once every two weeks.
I order my daughter a hot dog and fries, myself a tuna melt on an English muffin.
The hot dog and fries come out, the looked like they had just been tossed on the plate with an anemic amount of fries. The fries were undercooked.
My order came out wrong, a tuna sandwich. They quickly recovered and my melt came out quickly.
Please, please, please clean your toilets. The woman’s toilet had pee all over the seat and the floor was sticky. Your soap isn’t antibacterial.
I want to love you, please up your game. Then we can see each other more often.

DISGUSTING!!! GROSS!!! The food is awful. I recommend that you do not eat here. This is the worst restaurant in Bay Ridge.

This was my second time having Stewart’s. My first time having it was in wildwood and than this was my second time having it.
Here I got a root beer in a frozen mug and it was excellent. It was nice and frosty.
To eat I hate a jumbo sized hotdog with bacon and it wasn’t excellent but it was pretty good. It was a basic hot dog to me nothing special. I also got fries with it and to me it was basic food.
We were going to get a root beer float but we were to full. I would defiantly come back to try the root beer float.

I came to Stewarts the first Sunday night of the new year, I don’t know too much about the place, I do now that I was very happy I stopped by and sorry I did not get here sooner.
Sometimes we need a break from the processed food places; and here is about as good as it gets. Its great to know Stewarts is in the heart of 86^th St. Hinch’s was great too.
I’m glad they made a fantastic cross-​over restaurant****

I am a HUGE fan of Stewart’s root beer and I have been going to Stewart’s since I was very young with my dad.
If your looking at this from a foodie perspective you would probably give it THREE stars because the food is AVERAGE! Yes the hotdog with bacon that I ordered was okay, and the French fries were just alright. The hot dogs need a little help considering in bayridge there is some awesome places for bacon wrapped hot dogs that are just out of this world! There is much better food in Bayridge than Stewart’s but none where Stewart’s root beer is served in a cold mug!
Stewart’s for me is filled with nostalgic memories of my childhood! If you have ever been to Stewart’s in Wildwood New Jersey it’s a lot about the root beer! There root beer is one of my two favorite root beers!
If this review was simply based on there root beer and the kindness of the staff I give it five huge glowing stars!!. The staff is so efficient and funny. The atmosphere is your typical Stewart’s old school atmosphere with the booths and stools near the cashier area!
If you do plan on going to Stewart’s like I said the food is not the best but that’s all Stewart’s so the reason you should come here is for two things!
1. THOSE ROOT BEER FLOATS ARE HEAVEN!
2. The root beer is just FANTASTIC. Not all Stewart’s bring out there root beer in frozen glass mugs and this Stewart’s continues the tradition of bringing out there root beer in a frozen mug! I mean it’s just a whimsical experience to lift up your frozen mug and drink this cold rich root beer! That’s one of the reason I will be coming back!
STEWARTS IS A GREAT EDITION TO BAYRIDGE!
**IF YOU CHECK IN ON Unilocal YOU GET 10% OFF! It helps!
2 jumbo bacon wrapped hot dogs, two root beers in cold mugs, and an order of fries was 25 dollars with tip after check in offer. reasonable for two people!
No free refills on those cold root beer frozen mugs!

So glad our girl Ally is still here! We were concerned when the name changed it would be all new staff. Ally’s attention to detail is an asset to this establishment! Her hospitality is excellent because she always has a genuine smile. The food is always a generous delicious portion, no matter what you order! We love to come after church on Sunday and look forward to the old diner atmosphere. Glad to return weekly.

We’ve been ordering from this place for a while now and it used to be really good. Lately though there have been some issues with delivery — coffee lid not on right and spilled all over the food, missing food that was paid for. Food is usually good though, too bad about the delivery.

The girlfriend was very excited about Stewart’s opening in Brooklyn since she’s a big fan of their sodas. We might have seen other locations outside of NYC but this is a first in the city. We were excited to come here but the good feelings diminished rather quickly. One would expect a lot of traffic for this restaurant since it’s in such a busy area, however we didn’t see many patrons on a Monday night.
Upon entrance, we saw a lot of Stewart’s signs but also remnants of what used to be here, which was a Greek diner. The doors still had old signs but we brushed it off thinking the food will be different. Sadly, we were mistaken once we saw what came out.
The burger and chicken sandwich that were ordered reminded us of what we had in public school cafeterias. The burger was dry looking like it sat under warming lights for the whole day. To make it a chili burger, they just threw a slop of chili on top and sandwiched it between cheap buns from the supermarket.
My buffalo chicken sandwich was even sadder as it was obvious they put even less effort into it. Old fried chicken cutlets were laid on top of a bun then buffalo sauce was poured on top, that was it. Technically, that’s what the sandwich called for, so that’s what we should’ve expected. Too bad we expected something more appealing, silly us.

Stopped by for desert after my daughter’s win at basketball. Coffee was good and my kids enjoyed there floats.

2 stars because I feel bad giving any less. Ordered online. Food came completely cold. Not warm, COLD. They didn’t follow my instructions. I simply asked for no tomato since I’m allergic. Burger was cooked medium when I asked for well done. Bun was half the size of the thin, tasteless patty.
Got a call from the location. It was very thoughtful and appreciated, glad to know they care about their customers and their business

Came here after craving a hamburger. It hit the spot. I redeemed the Unilocal check in offer which was a nice little discount off the meal. The food is decent and not too pricey. I used to love coming to the diner that used to be in this location. Not sure if it’s the same owners and they changed the name and menu. Either way I will be back.