Milly’s Pizzeria

Pizza is okay if you’re drunk and hungry.
However, a slice is still 2.50 and it’s subpar. I think dollar pizza is so much better. If you’re up for it, just go to graham ave. and get those dollar slices. Don’t waste your time here.
The two stars go to the people that work here. Very nice people. Sorry to write this review but I really did not like the pizza all too much.

The pizza here is terrible. Spend your $ 5 dollars somewhere else. Bland. Dry. And stale

The owner is such a cool guy. For the part of town it’s in, this is a gem. Wonderful, clean place with cheap pizza. They really make you feel welcomed here. I sat for several hours doing some work. They even have wifi but it’s private and you have to ask!

So my boyfriend and I are still on the fence. He hated it, I enjoyed parts of it. My first complaint, we ordered thru seamless at 1:40 on a Saturday afternoon. At 3:20 I get a call the from the delivery guy asking me to come down. This is bias of mine, but if I order delivery it should come to my door. I ordered because I was to lazy to put on pants. So I calmly told him the build has two elevators that would bring him to my floor.
He came up we got the food, open the box to the Sicilian pizza and half the pizza is on the lid of the box. Rookie mistake! After scraping off the cheese from the box I got down on my slice. I thought it was perfect, the crust was seasoned well. My boyfriend thought it tasted like Ellos pizza. The garlic knots were hard as hell, like break a tooth, how do you have the balls to serve these garlic flavored marbles.
The price was great, but if your looking for good old style pizza that will rock your world, spend a little more and go to Sal’s.

Extremely disappointing.
The reviews a month or two back — when I first moved here — were really high, and so I figured it would be my go-​to pizza place.
But… the slices are very plain, cold, not well made. There are virtually no special toppings. And it’s not cheaply priced — the quality doesn’t match what you’re paying for.
So I’m still looking for an awesome local pizza place… any suggestions? :/

Fast delivery but the pizza didnt taste good. really nice people but no I dislike there pizza. there beef patties are good though (:

I created an account just to write this review.
So today I didn’t want to cook and needed to feed myself and my Daughter and I ordered.
Food came after an hour and was cold. I had to reheat the food myself.
I ordered chicken fingers and french fries for my daughter and I had to take the fries that you can tell were fried a few times and were old and bake them to get some of the grease out and to make them crunchy again. The chicken tenders HAD NO TASTE WHAT SO EVER but she ate everything anyway.
Let’s get into the EggPlant Parm that was for me.
First off this came to me cold as well. It was def had a lot of cheese and that was because it was cover the eggplant that was not in complete slices but in small pieces. I said to myself ok well that looks good (I didn’t see under the cheese) and the first thing that I did was take the bread which was good (only thing that was good) and dipped it into the sauce of the Eggplant parm and the first thing that I said to myself was NOPE, it’s going to be horrible but you need to eat anyway.
After serving myself the eggplant wasn’t even crispy (EGGPLANT PARM, is supposed to be crispy).
The salad even looked nasty…
Bottom Line. I wish I would’ve ordered dominos or papa johns. I can just imagine what their pizza must taste like. People here who say that the pizza is great really does not know what really good food is.
This place F**KING sucked

I hate writing reviews like this, but I have to because the food was inedible. The pizza had no flavor and the texture of the cheese was questionable.
the pizza was rubbery and the crust was hard at the same time. The garlic knots were hard and dry as if they were made earlier that day, then were thrown in the microwave. For the amount of butter and garlic they had on them, they still had no flavor.
I would have been way more satisfied with a bag of Coolranch Doritos for dinner. I would have ingested the same amount of calories and my food would have had flavor.
Stay away.

Not sure if there’s been another change of management, or if most of the positive reviewers are ordering for delivery, or what… But this place sucks a bag of dicks.
Pizza: terrible. Really, like 99cent Pizza terribile. Crust is so dry you end up throwing out the rinds instead of eating them. Sauce is full of sugar, clearly from a can. And they didn’t even manage to heat it up past luke warm, despite the time it took (see below).
Service: terrible. Like Time Warner terrible. 15min waiting at the counter with just one other guy, while employees walked in and out like no one was there. The other guy said he was about to give up and walk out without the sandwich he’d ordered sometime earlier that month. 20min experience, for cold slices. On the plus side — no line!
Oh, and watch out for the 4-​foot old man in the white hat & suit. I asked him if the place was even open, as he walked out from the kitchen, and he started screaming at me that «You don’t know me», and trying to solicit a fight. I turned him down, though I did sort of want to see what that would look like. He was like an apoplectic, semi-​coherent Tattoo.
No smiles. Everybody — no smiles.
(To his credit, the guy who eventually came to the counter spontaneously apologized for their angry mascot /​owner. So though the service was bad, those staff who didn’t actually threaten bodily harm were pretty friendly.)
UPDATE: go a few blocks east. Romeo’s Pizza is under new management. Pizza as it should be, or as close as, for Bushwick.

A great place! Food and service was not what we expected in the best of ways. Will definitely be going back.

After the disaster that was Mike’s Pizza, I knew full well I needed a solid pizzeria within ten minutes’ walking distance. Milly’s had some strong reviews, so I gave it a try.
It’s not in a great part of town, but is very clean and cool inside. There’s nothing too fancy, a few Italian options (the chicken parm hero is well-​reviewed, though I didn’t get it), but it’s mostly pizza, so that’s what I went with.
The pizza was very good! The definition of thin crust, but also sturdy, so you can fold it and go without it flopping on you — exactly like a good thin crust should be. Two plain slices and a bottled water came to $ 5, so no gripes about the price here either. This is looking like my new go-​to pizzeria!

Friendly owner and staff. Pizza was out in a relatively short time span.

Ordered 3 slices. The toppings were good but the crust was way overdone. It was like eating a cracker. The delivery bicyclist must’ve fell off the cabbage truck. couldn’t understand English worth a damn. He screwed up the address and the pizza arrived cold. If you want to work in America then learn the language.

Good service, amazing pizza. The last time I ordered delivery, I asked if they sold beer, and they don’t, but offered to pick some up along the way. He may have been joking, but I just love these guys. They’re talking about opening up a backyard for outdoor seating soon.

Best pizza in bushwick.

Save yourself!
If I could give a zero-​star rating I would.
Milly’s pizza was a decidedly yucky experience. My hand to God, my calzone was made with Pillsbury’s dinner rolls instead of actual pizza dough. My wife’s chicken parm hero was a greasy fried chicken cutlet on stale bread with a little bit of sauce and cheese. Neither of us could eat much of our order.
Don’t waste your money on this extremely bad «Italian-​American» food!

I have been eating here since it was Moses… The new management and name change to Milly’s was a huge improvement. I’d get like a slice and go when it was Moses, but the Milly’s team is so friendly and welcoming I started ordering different items from the menu (something I rarely do at a pizza slice joint). I am like addicted to the Ravioli, it’s quick easy and inexpensive — and tastes great. I really am picky about my slices too — in the city I only eat it at few spots, like Joe’s or Artichoke — I just won’t eat crappy slices. Milly’s is the best slice by far I’ve found in Bushwick and the only place I will buy it.
Lastly I need to mention the staff at Milly’s, they are friendly and engaging… you feel a part of the neighborhood when you are there.

Pizza is very very good! Ordered from this place on Sunday of course for Football games. The wings are okay but the pizza is very good! I would definitely order from this place again!

Milly’s Pizza, Moses Pizza, I don’t really care — this stuff is mad delicious! I’m only going to order my pizza from here from now on, it’s just too perfect every time. I also got their fries, which are like the potato slices of God’s gentlest angel.
Stop playing silly little games with your tastebuds and get yourself a pizza from here. Feel free to message me later with thanks, gift card codes, haikus etc.

i’ve eaten MILLY’s Pizzeria a couple of times now and I can say that I love this place. Everything has flavor and is delivered very fast. Ive had the regular slices, grandma, baked ziti, a sausage parm, garlic knots and I approve of everything.