Williamsburg Creamery

Lapin and I came here a month ago or so (I know, I am always on top of my reviews) because I wanted a pre-​brunch snack (it’s a thing). The tiny store was empty upon our visit but the staff was still helpful and nice. They allowed us to try a couple of their eclectic flavors with a smile on their face. I ended up getting a plain swirled ice cream cone with sprinkles because I had a bit of a flavor overload and couldn’t decide what I wanted. The cone, however, was around $ 7 which is pretty expensive since it tasted the same as a Mr. Softee and cost half as less. However, I would spring for the other flavors as a treat, since they were tasty.

Another great institution closed down.
This was a perfect place for yummy ice cream at a decent price.
It was always wonderful to get a cone here in the hot days of summer walking around Williamsburg.
You will be missed Williamsburg Creamery!

It’s a sad day in BK, Williamsburg Creamery is closing its doors for good. Your hand spun peanut butter fro yo blew my GD mind and I’m not sure how I’ll make it all summer. If you plan on selling your hand spinners please msg me. RIP WB Creamery
— Peanut Butter Bob

After some severe drinking and the loss of ability to feel the cold weather, decided ice cream was the best option. This creamery was on my list for their cool exotic flavors (wine ice cream!)
First time I stopped by at around 12pm they were closed; my late night trip back they were very open and not crowded. To my surprise they actually sell Dough donuts here! The inner stoner in my immediately asked if they do doughnut ice cream sandwiches, and they happily obliged. Got the birthday cake ice cream (amazing) in a pecan doughnut with whipped cream and caramel drizzle ($ 6ish). Simply fantastic and super dense.
Staff is friendly, some bar stool seating, and located in a good area. Will surely come back.

This place is amazing. Not only do they give you a big helping of ice cream for only $ 6 (cup), but the ice cream is just sooo good! I had the Chocolate Peanut Butter Oreo and Piece of Cake. Both were incredible. The only thing I would recommend is that if you’ve eaten before coming here, get the tiny cup because the ice cream is so rich you might not be able to finish it. Otherwise, get the bigger cup and try a few different flavors.

This isn’t only a ice cream place! They have massive donuts and a wide variety of ice cream flavors. I got cookie dough this time but chocolate Cabernet and white faces raspberry are the best!

I had a double-​scoop of Apple Pie and Pumpkin — a winning combination for a cool day, in my opinion. Although I got it in a cup (so I could better mix the two together), I appreciated the Pie scoop having little bits of sugar cone. It was tasty stuff.
I came here after eating Brick Lane Curry’s Phaal, which is reputed to be the hottest in North America (and maybe the world) — so maybe my review is biased, but their ice cream did get rid of my heartburn.
All in all, I’ll go back next time I’m in BK.

Very good ice cream!
I selected the White Raspberry with chocolate chunks and it was delectable and oh so mouthwatering and sweet! I also had the Vanilla ice cream with fudge and peanut butter, which I expected to like a lot more. It was actually too plain for me– The vanilla didn’t have enough of the fudge and peanut butter mixed in.

YUM! I just finished my double scoop of «Oh my Cherry Pie» and «chocolate brownie peanut butter Oreo» and wow was it good!
Abraham helped us and was SO patient. I sampled 6 flavors (yes I know, 6 is ridiculous).
The music was also the
with tons of great throwbacks like say my name and what doesn’t kill you makes you stronger!

My mistake here. I sampled the carrot cake ice cream and it was pretty delicious– strong flavor, airy, sort of like a whipped consistency — really good. I went instead with the chocolate peanut butter oreo — this flavor I would rate 2 stars if that.
Should have stuck with the carrot cake or sampled some other flavors but the store was too crowded to hold up the line.
4 bucks for a small — pricey as most ice cream places now are.

I came solely because they are the closest ice cream shop that carries Mercer’s chocolate chip cabernet. The shop is dingy, like the Beacon Creamery. It does have decent outdoor seating though, and overall, a good selection of flavors. Apparently they do food as well. I saw paninis posted on the menu board. Prices were fair for the ice cream.
Not sure if I’d trust the panini, but if you’re looking to get some ice cream, this is a good spot.

I guess when you come here and who is working really has an impact on your overall experience and your willingness to return. Came here last on a busy Saturday night with a pretty long line.
The Potentially Bad: You’re going to pay a lot for ice cream. Paying for primo Bedford Ave. rent isn’t cheap and that’s pretty much where you’re taking a bulk of the hit.
The Good: You can sit outside or take your cone on the sidewalk.
The Great: The flavors. Butterscotch and birthday cake blew me away. I tried some wine infused sparkling strawberry and that was fantastic too. What they do right, they do very right. The girl at the counter was nice and there was no issue of attitude problems as other reviewers have listed. Maybe they got rid of that particular bozo.

I will start this off by saying you will be paying anywhere from $ 4-​$ 7 for Icecream.
The shop is very small but nicely decorated.
There are seats located right outside the shop with a nice ambient in the very hip area of Bedford.
The Icecream is delicious and you are looking at some great quality cream with all types of flavors. The workers are nice and you could taste the flavors.
Come out and try the Williamsburg creamery.

Our rating 1 out of 5: (1= worse and 5 = best)
Andrea 3.0
Fanny 4.5
James 3.5
Total = 3.67

Really wanted to try this place for their wine infused ice cream. I came here around 12:30pm on a saturday afternoon with a friend. Having never been here before, we sampled some of their flavors. The girls was nice enough to let us sample multiple flavors. They had 2 wine flavors for the day — one was chocolate chip cabernet and Peach Zinfindel. I ended up getting the chocolate chip one which was really good. You can actually taste the wine flavoring. The peach one was okay — It was mostly like peach sorbet taste with the maybe an aftertaste of wine. The other ones that we sampled were pretty good in terms of having real fruit incorporated into them. My friend got the popcorn flavor, which was another popular flavor — it reminded me of kettle corn. They had bits of caramel and popcorn flavored pieces.
Portions were big — you get 2 scoops in a single cup — so go ahead and try more flavors! :)
P. S. I love their colorful seats outside lol. The place got busier around 2pm when we passed this place again on our way back since all the tables and seats were taken.

Maybe I am a spoiled Long Island girl… but this place did not really do much for me. I have been to a lot of creameries. Usually with three times as many flavor options as this one, and overall better flavor.
My boyfriend got birthday cake… and I have to say it was VERY good… if i did not try his I would have given this place two stars. I recommend getting that flavor.
I got cookie dough and raspberry sorbet. The sorbet was so bland… idk… really something was missing. Same with the cookie dough. it was just okay… nothing special or flavorful at all. Not to mention the consistency was weird. Put it this way… i had the ice cream right under the beating hot sun, and it did not melt… it was an interested consistency.
Idk maybe only some of their flavors are really good?

2.5 stars
Hot chocolate ice cream float: too rich, and by the time I started eating it, the icecream had mostly melted.

The price is high but it’s some of the best ice cream I’ve had recently. I paid like $ 6 bucks for two scoops but the cannoli flavor and the chocolate were delicious, unique and honestly, kinda worth it.
The line was out the door due to the nice weather though I can imagine it’s like that all summer. A nice treat if you’re going to be walking around the area…

Delicious ice cream, creative flavors, never a disappointment.
Today, we had some cake flavor and used the Unilocal check-​in deal to get free rainbow sprinkles. A small cup was four dollars and change. Really good flavor, I’d recommend it. The blueberry cheesecake flavor also looked really good. I love that they have a good variety of staples (pistachio, strawberry, etc.), with some interesting ones.
The line for this place definitely gets long during the midday hours once the weather gets nice. Tables outside turnover pretty quickly, so you’re pretty likely to get a seat if you are willing to wait for a few minutes. The staff is pretty friendly, but I also find it confusing that an ice cream parlor serves soup and sandwiches? Whatever. As long as they keep serving awesome ice cream, I’ll be one happy camper.

They’re the first ice cream parlor I’ve seen that offers alcoholic ice creams. That fact alone made both the Boyfriend and I buy a scoop of ice cream even though we were quite full from dinner. We’re little piggies, I know!
We went with the Chocolate Cabernet, which had little chocolate chips throughout the ice cream. It was so good! You can actually taste the wine but it didn’t overpower the chocolate. Each scoop has about 5% alcohol in it according to their menu so the alcoholic scoops are 21+
If you’re in the area, definitely stop by for a scoop — I hear they have Peach Zinfindel too!