Insomnia Cookies

First time here, great cookies I recommend the Smores Deluxe it is amazing. Great service and I got warm cookies I would definitely come here again. Great service.

How do they not deliver 1.5 miles away. Called them and said were in the cutoff zone ut on their own website it says we are in the zone. Seriously? Why the hell would you Advertise delivery when you clearly dont.

No delivery! What?
I live 5 minutes away by car and didn’t qualify for delivery from this location. What’s the point of having a cookie delivery service less than 2 miles away if they won’t deliver?
As for the cookies, they’re pretty good. A little too sweet but they are cookies after all.

The reason that this place didn’t get 5 stars is because of the prices. I had the smore delux cookie and it was around $ 3.50. The cookie was pretty delicious, but it was hard to justify spending that much for ONE cookie.
The employee we delt with was SO SWEET AND FRIENDLY. I wish we had gotten his name so I could give him a shout out. He had dreads half way to his shoulders. I mean, he was such a pleasure to interact with.
The actual store front is small and a little cramped.
I would come here again.

Nothing special! The cookies tasted below average for the price. Expensive for the quality and horrible customer services. Do not waste your time and money for cookies that aren’t worth it.

My husband and I just got a six pack of cookies from here for the first time tonight. I wouldn’t say it’s worth the cost. You can get a whole bag of fresh soft cookies from jewel for half the price. I asked for two double chocolate chip cookies and a mint chip cookie and my husband got a snickerdoodle, peanut butter and white chocolate chip cookies. When we got home I realized that I got two regular chocolate chip cookies and the mint. So she didn’t listen to what I actually ordered which was slightly annoying. Luckily the chocolate chip cookies were still warm and pretty tasty. The mint chip was not that great. It was hard and cold.
I think if you’re really craving cookies and can’t be bothered to run to the store or make your own, ordering cookies for delivery is worth it.

After coming here multiple times after MIDNIGHT, I realized they consistently served us cookies that weren’t fresh. They were cold and you could tell they’ve been sitting there for a while. I felt like the cookies tasted below average for the price. I’d rather have ate Subway cookies or drive to the LP Location.
They also have some super ghetto music playing at night. The songs aren’t even filtered… not very professional on their part.

They were extremely rude to us. After waiting in a long line, they told us that they would not be accepting credit card. Then I ran to the nearby CVS to get cash. After paying a $ 3 fee to get cash, I went back there. They told me that they wouldn’t accept cash or card. Thanks for nothing…

Sigh. Regretfully, I ordered delivery from here. Yes, I admit it. I had cookies delivered to my doorstep. And no, it was not «worth it:» Worth the wait, worth the cost, worth the sad realization that popping refrigerated cookie dough from Jewel in the oven would have been quicker, warmer, cheaper, AND more delicious.
I learned my lesson. Next time I’ll just bake them myself. Sigh.

I don’t actually know what their cookies are like. We waited for a few minutes while the guy in the corner was sending a text or playing angry birds and the service girl was nowhere to be seen. We only saw her after we left and could see her coming from around the corner. I guess they don’t want to work. Almost reminded me of the service from the show Faulty Towers, but at least there you got a service.

I assume I’m giving this place ²⁄₅ stars because I didn’t eat said cookies at 3 a.m.
I mean, the cookies are decent. But by the time we walked back to the apartment they weren’t warm. And they certainly weren’t $ 15 tasty.
I would probably give it another go to try one of their ice cream sandwiches, but it would have to be late or I would have to be drunk enough to pay for these cookies again.
Bring $ 15 by my apartment and I’ll make you a better batch.

When I finally got to try Insomnia Cookies, it was a cruel discovery that its reputation is based on its business model rather than its cookie quality.
The store seems to cater to the late night college kids or drunk folks with late night cravings and no ingredients to make cookies at home. The only food options available are milk, cookies, and ice cream. The cookies themselves are not remarkable. They don’t have any interesting flavors of cookie available (just your standard oatmeal raisin, chocolate chop, white chocolate macadamia, etc.), but they are kept warm. I found my cookie to be so sweet (the white chocolate macadamia) that I threw away a couple of bites. Granted, I don’t have a huge sweet tooth, but I still enjoy a good cookie.
If I want a good cookie at some crazed drunken time, I think the better bet is 24-​hour Subway cookies.

Waaaay overrated. The cookies really aren’t that special at all, besides being warm. I guess its perfect college students who don’t know any better when coming home from the bars or needed a study break, but you can make much better cookies at home– from scratch, or from a roll in your local grocer’s refrigerated aisle.

Not too impressed with the chocolate chip cookie I had. The only thing that makes this place stand out is the hours and college kids late night cravings are satisfied. Otherwise, it would be an ordinary cookie joint with your average cookie flavor.

Oh my effing gee!!! You know how some nights you make yourself a nice dinner and have some wine and you just want a little something sweet to top it all off and you realize that you ate the last of your Trader Joe’s dark chocolate covered pretzels last night and there is literally nothing sweet in your whole apartment unless you want to spend an hour and a half making rice pudding? Yeah, me too. Enter Insomnia Cookies and their super speedy delivery of just-​baked warm chocolate chip brownies, double chocolate chunk, and snickerdoodle cookies. The minimum delivery order is $ 6 so I had to order all of those. And of course I had to eat all of those because they were SO RIDICULOUSLY DELICIOUS. And now I’ll have to do an epic spin class tomorrow, but it was oh so worth it.

I was so psyched when I found out an Insomnia Cookies was opening up right by Loyola. Warm and delicious cookies available til 3 am. What more do you want? I’ve made the walk down from the Morse area several times just to get cookies. I’ve tried most of what they offer and everything is good! My personal favorites are the jumbo cookies, especially the peanut butter cup one. If you want a cookie a la mode their ice cream is pretty good as well and they give it to you in what looks like a small pizza box, which is pretty funny.
If you’re craving cookies, any time of day, this is the place to go!

I had one Deluxe Peanut Buttercup and one Deluxe S’mores cookies. They didn’t have much flavor except that they were very very sweet, so both cookies tasted exactly the same — and $ 6 for two overly sweet bland cookies is too much money. Might hit the spot for Loyola students with sweet cravings, but others need not bother.

All the cookies here are fantastic! There is no way to pick just one favorite! I can literally eat like 5 of them in one sitting. The staff are all really friendly and efficient. Even when there is a line that goes out the door, the pace is good and I never have to wait too long. Everyone has to try Insomnia Cookies at least once in their lives. It is life changing.

Insomnia cookies are my favorite! As a Loyola student who lives close to this location, I was super duper excited and had been anxiously waiting for it to open up. The best part of this location is that they deliver REALLY FAST! And the cookies are still warm and gooey. Mhmmmm, deliciousness in every chocolate chunk (those are my favorite!)
I have the insomnia cookies app downloaded and lately they’ve had 12 cookies for $ 10 only and with delivery it’s only $ 11.85+tip which is almost $ 4 less than when going to the store to pick up a dozen for close to 16 – 17 bucks! Cookies stay fresh for a few days and taste just as good when I warm them up in the microwave.
Thanks for being so awesome Insomnia!!!

Today was my first visit to this newest location of Insomnia Cookies,
and pretty new to Loyola it is, 12 days old as of today!
And, okay, I must admit that I was pretty excited about this place being
open because I have never had Insomnia Cookies before today.
And, upon entering I found a very small cookie place interior, but the
young man who rang up my order was very nice!
Now, these cookies vary in price and honestly, I thought that $ 1.50 per
cookie was an okay deal, and they also had some specialty cookies
for $ 3.00 like a Smore’s cookie that now I wish I had gotten cause
I have such a fondness for Marshmallows.
They had some ice cream choices as well, but, didn’t come for Ice Cream
came for cookies!
Now, for any of you that may unfortunately truly suffer from Insomnia this
Cookie Paradise will deliver to you until 3am.
For the record. I do suffer from Insomnia from time to time, and I
will desperately try not to dial Insomnia’s digits…
So, welcome to Loyola Insomnia Cookies, may you deliver many cookies
to Insomniac’s all over Chicagoland!
You’re serving up very tasty cookies indeed!
And, if you visit Insomnia Cookies on Sheridan Road don’t forget to tip
Cookie Monster on the counter!
After all, C is for Cookie…