Toastie’s Sub Shop

This is a great find. Really enjoyed the Bambino and Islander. Give the voodoo chips a try they were delicious. They also suggested the bratwurst but we could only eat two subs.

NOTORIETY: Chain sammy shop
FOOD:
Toasty club sub: I didn’t eat the sub right away, so it wasn’t as toasted as I would have liked. Good flavor but not as much as I’d like for the price.
OVERALL: Decent sub shop but they messed up my order. Asked for a fluffernutter but ended up getting a PB&J instead.

Definitely better than Subway. The Islander tacos were probably worth 4-​stars. The Baja tacos were pretty low on flavor (though with an extremely spicy side-​sauce that just overwhelmed all the other flavors) and about 2-​star. The bread is pretty good, and the meatball sub was a 3-​star (sauce was a bit salty). The pita is also pretty good, and the Bambino was a 3-​star (not well balanced, can’t taste the pepperoni or bacon).
So it’s got some good points, but mostly the take-​away feeling was that it was lacking some spark. I doubt I’ll be back anytime soon. I do like a good sub, and this might edge out all the other sub shops in town, but it isn’t a taste sensation. You can get better pulled pork in town, and you can get some decent sandwiches in town.
Note that the Unilocal map is a bit off. This is part of the Northpoint complex and it faces University Ave.

Best sandwich shops in college station
Good prices for good food & fresh ingredients everything is tastes great
Way more worth your money then potbelly or jimmy johns
Cali club and bambino r the favorites
Also can’t go wrong with any of their tacos

A little pricey for the size of their sandwich but the Islander sandwich I had here was one of the best sandwiches I’ve had in a long time. Like a lot of other reviews are saying, go for the pulled pork it’s fantastic

This place is a nice change from the normal sandwich places in College Station. We really liked everything we got and will definitely be back.
I got the Islander: pulled pork, grilled peppers and pineapple, and slaw on really well made hoagie-​esque bread.
My wife got the Medi Veg: roasted squash, zucchini, and red peppers, fresh spinach, and lemon aioli on a garlic-​herb roll.
Each component of both was really well executed and paid attention to.
Service was great too.
We parked in the back of the Hampton Inn near the parking garage and had no problems. Hopefully the parking will become more clear as the center grows and adds more businesses.
Again, great overall experience. We will be back!

I made a Unilocal account just to write this review. Too many small businesses come and go in this city; this is one amongst the few that I really hope stay.
Sometimes people don’t realize how important bread is to a sandwich or sub. Toasties gets the bread done right. I’ve eaten here six times now and have enjoyed all six subs. The owner is also very friendly.
Prices for subs range from about 5 something to 8 dollars for the cuban.
You can look at their menu here:
BBQ Pulled Pork Sub — ⁵⁄₅
Generous with the pulled pork. I was expecting the sub to be inundated with bbq sauce, but they put the right amount to not get things too soggy and make the sandwich too sweet. slaw was good.
Brawtwurst Sub — ⁵⁄₅
Sauerkraut, good. Spicy brown mustard, good. brawtwursts GOOOD.
Cali Club Sub — ⁴⁄₅
Delicious but would be a ⁵⁄₅ if it had more turkey.
The Cuban — ⁴⁄₅
Again, generous with the pulled pork. In the cuban though, the pork was a little under salted for my taste and they probably could have put more mustard.
Big Dipper — 3.5÷5
Didn’t love it. The au jus was a little thin on flavor, could have used more beef, and I would have preferred thick cut onions. It still tasted good, but I won’t be ordering it again.
The Rueben — 3.5÷5
It was good, but I’m a bit picky with my pastrami. All other components of the sub were great.

So dang good. Had the Cuban and bambino on 2 separate occasions, absolutely delicious

This was my first time visiting the new Toastie’s next to Northpoint Crossing apartments. I got The Cuban sub. I have drawn a few conclusions.
1) The pork is really good. It is juicy and served hot with good flavor. Strongly recommend the pork.
2) I wasn’t a huge fan of The Cuban. As good as the pork was, the other ingredients didn’t bring the sandwich together. The pickles were actually somewhere in no man’s land between pickles and cucumbers.
3) I will definitely be going back to Toastie’s. Although the flavors didn’t work on The Cuban in my opinion, the individual ingredients (except pickles) were very good and the sub was served hot and toasty. I may try the Banh Mi next time. My roommate got that and said it was really good.
4) The atmosphere was too much like a home business and the color scheme was atrocious.
Conclusion: Unless they get an interior designer, get your sub to go and get something with pork in it (not The Cuban). I had an overall good experience and will update to 4 stars if the next sub I have is really good.

Well this should be very popular. We enjoyed lunch here today after seeing the open sign flashing. I’ve known this was coming for about a year and having eaten at every sandwich shop in Aggieland I was curious as to how this would be different.
VERY VERY impressed!
So we parked at Northpoint Crossing which has a huge easy to use Parking Garage which is free for visiting the businesses. Popped in just after noon to check out the very first of a good number of businesses coming soon and wow, it looks really cool inside. Love the colors. Looked at the beautiful hand painted menu, saw the tacos (yeah that’s right TACOS!) and realized that I will be eating here often.
Wife is an expert at wraps after having eaten many wraps in town and she said this is the best one by far. She said the way it was toasted was perfect.
I had the Bánh mì tacos which were served nice and hot at a proper temp on two white corn tortillas. Menu lists Slow Roasted Pulled Pork topped with Cucumbers, Pickled Red Onion and Carrots topped with fresh Cilantro, Sweet Red Chile Sauce and a squeeze of Lime. A true bad ass duo of tacos if I must say. I think they beat Torchy’s and are different from any others in town. Fun, creative and delicious.
Friendly staff explained the history which was fun. This is not a chain, it’s a Mom & Pop brand which is extremely popular in Austin.
I think it’s awesome that College Station now has it’s own Toasties as it fits in well in a town of people that like better food. Perfect distance from campus as a brief walk is good for you after eating excellent quality unique foods. Love it!