Sugardaddy’s Sumptuous Sweeties

These are the best damn brownies you will ever eat! Very decadent and flavorful.

Sinfully delicious!
Some of the best brownies and blondies ever! And they are round!
One of my favorites is the Fiery Brownie.
Sooo good, just a hint of chiane
And the Berry Dark is awfully good
And the peanut butter
And the caramel
And the… Ok you get the idea…

After seeing Sugar Daddy’s on Food Network, I was interested to try it. I was not impressed with the product or «customer service». I stopped in Labor Day weekend– both Friday and Saturday. Same person was working both times. She didn’t take her eyes off of the computer (surfing the Internet?) any time she spoke to me. I didn’t think the blondies and brownie I tried were very good. Especially considering how much I paid for them. I won’t be back. Next time I am at Easton and need something sweet, I will go to Graeters.

Okay, these things are amazing. They primarily sell round brownies (ie: the middle cuts) but they keep the edges for biscotti and truffles.
I had a dark chocolate brownie with a drizzle of raspberry sauce. It was divine. The boyfriend had the celebration brownie (a blonde brownie with frosting and sprinkles!), my Mom had the Tahitian one and she was in love with it. My Dad demanded more brownies after he’d inhaled his.
We’ll definitely be back. And my parents (who live out of town) are going to be ordering the brownies and having them shipped home. I can’t wait to try all the other flavors!

Love their brownies.

I cannot stress how much I love these brownies!!! The nutty blonde is hands down my favorite! Every time I go into the Easton store I’m greeted right away and if any deals are going on they let me know. Dawn and Deb are always so kind and helpful!
I think the price is very reasonable for the Quality and deliciousness of these sumptuous sweets! I recommend Sugardaddy’s to friends and coworkers and have even brought in bags of pocket change to work. Everyone who tried them love them! The nutty blonde and rich mint were a big hit!!!

3 stars = an average of five stars for the brownies, which are amazing as always… and one star for service. On the positive side, I’m guessing the economy has improved if customer service such as this can be permitted.
Mind you, it wasn’t even me who was quite so directly affected in the most jaw dropping instance, though the service I received was far less than stellar, but just being in the same store was quite an uncomfortable experience.
Entering the store, the staff of two young women greeted us well enough… blandly and without feeling, but I recognize it’s not exactly the most entertaining or interesting job. One pointed out a deal on the biscotti which was nice, and things seemed to be normal. But then a woman came in and began asking questions about the ingredients in the products due to her allergies. Now, I know it can be exceptionally obnoxious when there is a persistent customer with lots of questions that may seem irrelevant, or which should have common sense answers. … but the way it was handled… The staff’s responses were basically «I don’t know. Whatever it says on the label» in surly, uninterested tones. But the kicker was when the woman asked what was in the toffee used, to which she received dead silence and a «I don’t know, it’s toffee» response. The way it was said was not polite, and had a definite feel of «we don’t care either, b*****» Needless to say, the woman stormed out muttering something about inconveniencing the staff.
…the whole time this exchange was going on, I was at the counter waiting to place an order and check out, with both the staff members staring dumbly at the woman and ignoring me (and everyone else). …there are two people working for a reason, yes?
Upon finally getting around to assisting others, there were further complications due to my desire to use a coupon and partake of the biscotti deal. I understand how insane computers can be and that if you don’t know how all the tricks of operating the thing that it can be dreadfully frustrating. But trying to just say «uh, yeah, I can’t do this» and trying to make me give up and leave, then acting like trying to ring up an order was a dreadful inconvenience is not the way to win repeat business. To their credit, the two girls did eventually manage to ring up my order correctly, and I was able to finally leave the place, but I certainly would not be making any efforts to return to that store.
Sugardaddy’s usually has exceptional service to match their product, and seeing such treatment of customers, particularly at a location as premier and busy as Easton is really quite outrageous. Yes, dealing with customers is a hassle, especially if they have all sorts of special requests, but that is why helping them is a job for which a person is paid; no matter how ridiculous the requests might seem, one needs to try and smile and be polite, apologetic if necessary. Easier said than done, I know, but there is no call for this sort of attitude in any shop, anywhere. Even an «I’m sorry, I really don’t know» no matter how insincere would have been better than… well, this.
Anyways…
Like I said, the sweets themselves are fantastic. Definitely try the Harvest flavor which has a great, moist pumpkin flavor and texture, with a crunch here and there from the nuts.

OMG delicious!!! I am not sure who had the genius idea of selling 50 cent «shots» of butter cream icing, but I bought 3 all of them lol — and they were all fabulous!
We also had the brownie with white chocolate chips — amazing. So good. I have 0 bad thingsto say about this place.

Ah! Another location to stock up on delicious-​ness.
I know that there is a lot of competition in sweet shops or bakeries, but honestly this place stands above the rest. Not only can you get amazing brownies, blondies, etc. But what really makes the place is the owners and people who work here.
Every time I walk in (which is more then I would like to admit) they smile, wave, and make me believe that I am a long time friend just swinging in to sample what’s in their kitchen.
Plus, I am glad that Easton has added this and other local shops to its massive store list!

I work at Easton and Sugardaddy’s is near my store. I have tried their ice-​cream and a few different kinds of the pocket change. They both were exceptionally good, especially when you have a long day of work ahead of you.
When talking to the clerk who helped me, I asked him where they make their products. He told me they have their bakery at Polaris and then every morning transport their products over here to Easton, so that they are freshly made.
Sugardaddy’s prices are more on the higher side, but you do get great quality bakery items. A perk of working near them is that they bring in samples to the store workers a lot, which let me tell you, helps a ton when trying to get through the day!
Their brownies are full of flavors too, so much so that you do not need a whole lot to be satisfied. I have not been able to choose yet whether I enjoy the blondies or the brownies more yet, so I recommend to try both if you are a first time visitor. The rich mint pocket change in the brownie flavor is one of my favorites however, but the cinnamon blondie is really growing on me too!
Either way I would definitely recommend checking out a Sugardaddy’s store.

Since I got Easton often and have been thinking about Sugardaddys alot and the nice email I got from its Owner I had to give it a real chance to be able to really judge and boy am I glad I did! It exceeded all of my expectations and is now my favorite stop for sweets! Sure, I might have thought the brownies are expensive but you can get a pound! of pocket change for $ 9 or 3 for $ 20. So I went hog wild and got 6 bags so I was able to sample different flavors and each and every one was amazing in its own way! Unlike other sweets where all flavors taste similar and might just have a different ingredient, each brownie is made with love and thought and simply devine! I had the auburn original with nuts, plain, simple but still very good. The american beauty with peanut butter, rich, sweet and awesome! The caramel was my favorite brownie, SOOOO GOOOOD! The cinnemon blondie was my least favorite, therefore my husband ate the entire bag and loved it which says alot since he does not usually eat sweets at all. My favorites were the nutty and the tahiti, I can’t decide which is better and coming from a serious chocolate lover these are so good they overpowered my strong love for chocolate! YUM YUM YUM thank you Sugardaddy, you have a loyal customore who is very glad she gave you another chance!

As always, this place rocks! I made a believer out of my friend!

I heart you, Sugardaddy’s. Thanks for opening a store close to home.
This cute little location is in the Easton Town Center building (where the movie theatre, cinnabon, etc are) by the doors on the Brio side. You may very well miss it!
Luckily brownies aren’t so large and they can fit plenty of their treats in this space.
Their treats are truly yummy. If you haven’t given it a shot, you most definitely should.

Another addition to what is becoming a fantastic Columbus chain — smaller than their downtown or Delaware stores, yes, but packing the same selection of delicious surprises.

My first attempt to visit Sugardaddy’s at Easton was met with the fact that they were closed… bummer. But one of the window ad’s about daily freshed baked brownies and blondies caught my eye. #1 being fresh baked… who doesn’t love that? #2 being the word blondie… I knew what a brownie was, but what the hell was a blondie???
This past Tuesday I had the opportunity to try one of these blondies, even though my better judgement told me it would spoil my dinner. I tried the Harvest blondie… nothing says fall like a blend of pumpkin and spice. The Harvest Blondie brought them both together perfectly. It was the not too dry or too moist and chewy, perfect consistency.
The staff there was friendly, almost to the point of perky. They explained to me all about SD’s fresh baked philosphy and they different products they offered besides their regular baked codes. Items such as coffee mugs, coffee, to gift sets of their baked wares.
All I can say is watch out Cheryl’s Cookies, you have some new competition in the Easton area.

The store is small, but small in the way that a box from Tiffany’s is small but still really, really fantastic.
In general I think blondies are a crime, because brownies are meant to be brown, and full of chocolatey goodness, but Sugardaddy’s is an exception to that rule. Their blondies are AMAZING. All caps amazing!
My favorite is the Tahiti, but I’ve yet to taste anything from Sugardaddy’s that I don’t like. This is a must try if you’re in the Easton area!

I immediately regretted buying an entire bag of pocket change after my first bite into a piece of the Tahiti blondie. So soft, buttery, smooth, rich, and delicious. Now, I’m pretty sure I’m going to sit here all day and finish the rest of the bag. Damn.
The Tahiti blondie’s ingredients (read from the bag) consist of toasted coconut, cashews, pineapple, dark/​white chocolate, and buttered brown sugar which makes a sinfully good combination. Plus, it’s the blondie Sugardaddy’s beat Bobby Flay with on Throwdown! How cool is that?
I’m definitely a fan and l can’t wait to try the other flavors (and gain 10 pounds in the process).

It seems like every time I review a place in Easton, I start out with, «Easton is a soul-​less hell…»
But you know what? Easton has recently added several places that are local, super-​friendly, and chock full of heart. First my beloved Northstar, and now Sugardaddy’s!
If you’re familiar with the other Sugardaddy’s locations, then you won’t be a bit disappointed with the service or the products at their Easton spot. This store just comes in a smaller, yet still adorable, package.
And if you haven’t been to Sugardaddy’s, but you’re in the Easton location, go right now to get the best brownies and blondies in the world! The owners, Mark and Tom, have created an amazing brand built on superior products and delightful customer service that would rival Jeni’s or Northstar.
Even though I would prefer to visit their Downtown location more often, I do work at Easton — so this store is super-​convenient for me. I’m pretty sure I found my newest treat shop when I need to feed people at the office!
Tip: If you go late in the day, you may get a special deal on that day’s brownies! You see, Sugardaddy’s insists on only serving fresh-​baked brownies every day.

It is smaller than their other store and it’s tucked away in the section of the mall where the movie theater is. Other than that… OH BABY!!! I have discovered their pocket change bag of delights. With the pocket change (various broken bits and pieces of their regular brownies/​blondies) I can indulge and lie to myself that I am not over doing it. Yeah! Right! Lie to me baby lie to me! munch munch munch.
After the first little piece I chomped on I felt this vision of enjoying more with a carton of milk with a straw in it as in elementary school days. Instead I opted to pour myself a mug of milk and dip some chunks in and enjoy. And milk with a chunk that has sunk to the bottom and somewhat sludged up is just too blissful for words.

We headed here from Northstar Café to grab some dessert.
We decided to share a brownie, so we had to arm wrestle over the flavor choice. Being a spice wimp, I shot down his suggestion for the Fiery brownie.
We settled on the Caramel. We were advised to let it sit for a bit, as she had just taken them out of the frig… otherwise the top half slides right off the bottom when they get warm. We somehow managed to wait until we got home. The caramel was just the right consistency, gooey but not sticky or liquidy. Delicious.
The store location in Easton is easily accessible only about 2 stores inside the doors under Bar Louie. Helpful staff, clean… as always.