Anthony’s Pizza and Pasta

Open semi-​late and Serves slices. If you’re waiting to long the boys offer you a free drink. Nice guys, nice place, good pizza at a fair price. You could take your kids or sit and get drunk with your friends and there is a separate but well connected spot for each

Waited for ten minutes at the front counter to place a take out order. None of the employees would make eye contact or even made the slightest attempt to help me. The bartender was watching the game. Guess I will take my business elsewhere. I finally got sick of waiting and left.

First, the primo bread here is great… unfortunately their pizza is right on par with the mediocre Denver pizza market. They don’t know how to make a crispy pie, which for some reason seems a very undervalued attribute for this and similar establishments in the city, but it is the most important part of pizza. Anyone can purchase toppings, fact of the matter is that if you don’t know how to top it and cook it… it sucks. I ordered my pizza crispy, which, according to their protocol they followed through with. The circumference of the pizza is so crispy it is almost hard, however the area of the pizza is floppy. This is because (and see attached pictures) the toppings are layered so aggressively that the dough can’t hold up. Toppings should never be applied in this fashion, unless upon special request, in which this was not the case. Floppy pizza is no good, can’t go back unless they start thinly layering their toppings… it’s not a difficult concept. Use less toppings, make better pizza, food cost improves as well as customer retention. Pizza needs to be crisp, it that’s simple.

This is a great neighborhood pizza place! The pizza is thin, delicious and fresh. The staff is always friendly and the new bar is a nice addition.

Anthony’s has been my go to pizza since I was in High School years and years ago, and the original on Evans was the only one around. But now I am a grown-​up and there are a lot more pie places around, I can get a slice wherever I go. But luckily for me there is Anthony’s on Colorado Blvd. and 7^th Ave real close to my home. I can get a slice or a full pie any time I want and every time I eat one in or from delivery those original happy memories come back.
The folks that care for Anthony’s (the Staff) are like family to one another some with the restaurant for years others fairly new but they compliment each other as much as they care for what they serve. The place is always clean and parking is always available unless the folks from other businesses decide to occupy spaces. They remodeled last year and it is a huge improvement from before and the bar area is fabulous for watching games and sharing a pie anyway you like it. At dinner time they stay pretty busy and folks from all walks are seated eating. It’s not overly fancy or made out to be an Italian restaurant, it’s a pie shop where the pies are made to order and the cheese drapes from your mouth to the slice in every bite!
My favorites are just cheese or sausage and pineapple but all are great and they locally source fresh ingredients! The best part though is they give back and every year open their doors to the Pie in the Sky for Project Angel Heart on the eve eve of Thanksgiving this year on the 24^th of Nov. and allow distribution to take place of the pies for Thanksgiving. Thanks Anthony’s for being a great go to and having great tasting pie!!!

The new and improved Anthony’s is great. They have added a bar which has windows for fresh air and Lots of natural bright light. I had not been here in awhile but my experience was great. I had a beer and pizza. The pizza was great as usual and they offer a great happy hour on Sunday. The bartender was a female with dark short hair. She was extremely friendly and oddly extremely hilarious. It was quiet for that time of day and I thank her for her great service and entertaining demeanor. She made the experience that more pleasant. I recommend dining in on a Sunday, the prices and the pizza and the customer service at the bar will surely guarantee a good time whether alone or with friends.

Came here while killing time and glad I did.
Pros: Plenty of big TV’s, bar area is great. Pizza was delicious.
Cons: Bartender wasn’t the fastest or friendliest, but she was adequate.
Will definitely try this place again.

I always get delivery and this place is consistently good. The pizza is quite close to east coast quality and the price is right! I am a pizza snob and this place is my go-​to in the smokey hill area for delivery.

Ordered from them twice. Both times order is wrong. Pizza is good, but would be nice to get what I order. Delivery has been faster than what they quote. Still beats dominos.

They have messed up my calzone orders multiple times and the last time I ordered a pizza from them it was swimming in grease and made the pizza soggy. I will never order from them again. Usually I love Anthony’s Pizza, but this location is terrible.

I just spent $ 30 on a pizza that was delivered and looked like it had been dropped. All the cheese and toppings were suck to the top of the box. I requested light sauce and it was loaded with sauce. Not happy with my first experience here!

Horrible. They are a few blocks away and will not deliver. Out of their territory. Never again across the United Staes will I call.

I came to Anthony’s for the first time this evening, and it didn’t disappoint. I had a slice of the white and a slice of neapolitan and a slice of white, a good amount of food for $ 7.50. The white was fantastic and the neapolitan was pretty good. The service was prompt, and the restaurant was fine.

I would say that the poor customer service and delivery would be corrected by the people at the corporate level if they knew about it but apparently the attitude comes from the top. After waiting for an hour for an off-​peak delivery I called and learned that corporate ordered a ton of pizzas and told the staff to bump all existing orders. 2+ hours later, still waiting. Pitiful.

I love this pizza place! I come here all the time and the food is great and the staff is friendly! I would recommend eating here for sure!

Definitely don’t order delivery! We live 5 minutes away and it takes over an hour for them to deliver regularly. Last night we ordered two salads and a small pizza. After waiting an hour and 15 minutes, we called to check on the status of our order. We were told they had a computer malfunction and lost all the orders. They were completely unapologetic about the inconvenience. Their response was, «well, you can order now.» No thank you! Wont be ordering from them again.

What Happened?
Anthony’s used to be so good but today our pizza was soggy, hardly had any cheese, and, even though we didn’t order meat, there was a big piece of chicken right in the middle. This is not the Anthony’s Pizza we used to go out of our way for.

As far as the pizza goes… Nobody does it like Anthony’s! Their cheese pizza is sooo good. This location is hit or miss on their delivery. Some days they are on point with quick service and hot pizza. Other days, they seem to make a pit stop at the local dispensary and forget that they have your pizza in their car. All in all, I will order here again and thoroughly enjoy Anthony’s pizza.

Who is Anthony and can I shake his hand? Kudos to him.
This is what you do:
Go into the shop, order and sit down at one of their boths. Wait for the pie to come out fresh out of the oven. Have your napkins ready.
That first piece will melt in your mouth. Their Italian Sausage rocks. Plenty of cheese. Tangy thin NY red sauce.
Delicious.

Anthony’s is so awesome that when you call and complain that there are two slices of pizza missing out of one of the 6 pizzas you ordered, and you tell them how gross and uncool that is, and you get an attitude and all indignant about it — they comp ½ of the entire order and apologize. And you’re all mad that they couldn’t get another pizza over to you in under an hour because it’s Halloween night.
And then — you find out as soon as you hang up — that your friend took a second box of pizza that you were keeping warm in the oven and she removed two slices before the first box was gone. Oh my God, she was the one who ate the two missing pieces.
And then you call Anthony’s back immediately and apologize like the a-​hole that you are so the driver doesn’t get in trouble and they laugh at you and tell you it’s all good.
Anthony’s, sorry for being a jackass and the pizza was awesome as always. Forgive me!