Sunshine Bagels 3

I’m being generous with my rating… unfortunately had an unpleasant experience at Sunshine Bagels. Arrived at church early so decided to get breakfast first. Was asked to repeat my order at least 5 different times throughout the time the counterperson was preparing my bagel. The service was poor and the food was subpar at best. The everything bagel was COATED in salt therefore you couldn’t taste anything BUT the salt.

Have been going to Sunshine Bagels, in Hartsdale, for over two years.
I always found the individuals who attend the counter, to be very friendly and accomodating. But today was another story… I was starving and couldn’t wait to order two eggs on a roll with a small coffee, potato chips and an everything bagel to go. Today I had no cash on me except for my debit card. I never saw the sign indicating that there was a $ 10 dollar minimum and if the order was for less, then there would be an additional charge of 50 cents. Are you kidding me? The order was for a little over $ 7 and they still wouldn’t give in. So they lost a $ 7 order, a customer and I told them that this was illegal. The individual at the counter told me that she agreed with me, but those were her orders. On top of this, she tells me that the notice is on the counter.
Of couse it is, and I was leaning on it and could not see it. What a shame…

If I could give zero stars I would– 20 minutes for and egg wrap?! Really? The worst service ever– no idea if the food is even good but doesn’t matter I’m never coming back to this dump

Bagels as they are supposed to be! Perfect size, healthy amount of toppings like the sesame and everything bagels, tasty spreads and generous with the spreads as well. Coffee is piping hot, service is fast and friendly.

I love this place! I always get a bacon, egg & cheese on a bagel or a roll. Everything always tastes fresh. They have wide selection of juices and several other bfast options, of course. Take cash bc they’ll only take cards if your purchase is over $ 10. There’s parking.
They lose a star because there’s bees inside of where they store the bagels and inside of the store. I understand that they can’t prevent the bees from coming in on summer days because the door stays open … but something has to be done about the bees getting inside of the bagel storage.

I love the bagels here but the service has gone terribly down hill since new management took over. The service people are nervous, inept, and always get my order wrong. It never fails, they always miss something or forget something and it’s so frustrating. They seem to get flustered back there and they seem overwhelmed. I just want to go back and do everything myself all the time.

Went for breakfast on Sunday with the boyfriend; he got the Bronx bomber on an everything bagel, and I got a park avenue classic on a multigrain bagel. Mine was delicious and the bagel was fresh and tasted phenomenal, consistent with all of my previous visits here. Boyfriend said his Bronx bomber was likewise delectable, and way more filling than he expected it to be. He had gotten a cinnamon raisin bagel with walnut raisin cream cheese as well, which we took home and had later. Also delicious. Everything was just great, from what we had. The people manning the front and kitchen work really hard, especially this one little lady who was so efficient but courteous at the same time! At one point an older Asian man in plainclothes and a gold chain who was talking on his phone and looked rather disgruntled came out of the back and into the main area of the kitchen (which is visible), sullenly looked at me while continuing to talk on his phone, then turned around and walked back into the back area. Weird. Okay then.
I had no cash and there’s a ten dollar minimum for credit cards, so I got the buy six get one free bagel thing, where each bagel you pay for costs a dollar. I chose: cinnamon raisin, poppy, multigrain, onion, garlic, blueberry, everything. All scrumptious, chewy, and fresh. The texture of their bagels is always spot on! (Yummmmmm.)
On the downside, Boyfriend went here by himself looking to try out their frozen yogurt. Apparently, it tastes weird and awkward, and something was «just not quite right» about it. He didn’t like it, and recommended that I avoid it in future. I guess I’ll stick to what «Sunshine Bagels» is named after, and I should be safe!

Good bagels, good cream cheese, nicely made egg sandwiches… What else could a girl need?

When I’m wrong, I’m wrong.
Our first experience must have been an off day because we ordered the same exact items (minus the donuts) and the bagels were fantastic!
Thank you for redeeming yourselves Sunshine Bagels! I was secretly hurt that you were so close to my house and not be good but boy am I glad I was wrong! The bagels were beyond flavorful this last visit.
I will be back!

Pretty weak overall. The bagels were meh, especially the everything which had no taste. I’d go to the place by the train instead. Their ice coffee’s were solid though.

The Bagels are weak and the cream cheese taste funny. Not coming back. Two dumbs down. The quality is crap.

made it here 10 mins before they closed for the day — they were nice enough to restart the toaster oven for us.
they have dairy-​free cream cheese =)
had a sesame bagel — yummy!
Will come back and try the other breakfast offerings!

fantastic.
My husband and I crave these bagels and have made it a ritual to have them every weekend. :) Plenty of room to sit around and talk with friends, and although Dunkin’ Donuts is gone, definitely glad this is here in its place!

I used to visit the Ardsley location very frequently, so when Sunshine popped up in Hartsdale, I was obviously very excited.
The bagels are top notch, and the lunch sandwiches never disappoint. I haven’t really explored their different menu items too extensively since I mainly stick with the basics.
The service however, is totally hit or miss. Sometimes you get a great employee who gets the order right and makes everything perfectly. Then there are times when the person helping you seems like he/she’s never spread cream cheese on a bagel before in their life.
Also, only recently, my bagels have never come toasted enough. I’m afraid to say «extra toasted» to see my bagel come out black. They just need to turn the dial on the toaster maybe 1 – 2 notches and it would be perfect.
Despite some of these setbacks, I still find myself at Sunshine almost every weekend.

Excellent muffins, good egg white omelet. Very nice people behind the counter. Lots of room. Fast service. Alot of tables so you can take your time eating. They don’t rush you out.

Delicious bagel shop. Some of the best egg sandwiches I’ve ever had. The coffee is wonderful. Sunshine Bagels has a whole fleet of sweets from homemade donuts to massive muffins. They also have a whole platter of freshly made cream cheeses. One of the best NY bagel places in Hartsdale for sure.

Say goodbye to Dunkin Donuts!
My school ordered breakfast for 70 students for their field trip; we ordered muffins for kids and those muffins were amazing! Most of the kids finished their breakfast before we arrived at our 1^st rest area, which was a wonderful surprise for us! My favorite was the blueberry muffin, it’s tasty, not too sweet, and was perfect in texture. I stopped going to DD for muffins… wishing there’s a Sunshine Bagels by me!!!

Sunshine Bagels has the best bagels in Hartsdale. It’s fresh, chewy. Just the way i like it.
I absolute love their mini bagels, half the size and calories. yum!

Tasty bagels, strong coffee, friendly service.
I love the Sunshine Bagels in Ardsley, so naturally I’m partial to this spot. There’s more space inside and out, which makes parking a snap.
Their bagels are the best — and no one makes fun of me for asking for them toasted, either. If you’re in the mood for a smaller breakfast or lunch, go for a mini bagel. As for bagel toppings, Sunshine carries more cream cheeses than you can shake a stick at.

There is another bagel shop in the area but I do have to say that I consider this new addition to Scarsdale the better of the two. They not only have fresh bagels, ready for the choosing, their prices are better and they also have the different varieties of schmear, including Tofu! I love the fact that they carry Mini Bagels AND Flagels in different varieties!
I came here one time and got a little annoyed by the gentleman who was working the counter. I was waiting there and he passed over me to take care of someone else and I wanted to curse him out a little. Considering the fact that I drop over $ 20 every time I visit and the lady he was kissing ass to, bought two coffees. He was a jerk but the food makes up for it and the last time I went there he was around so that was a plus.