This review is only for one type of cookie only — Chocolate walnut cookie(not sure of the name). I’ve never been to the store but my boss went to this place for dinner and brought some to work. I can say these chocolate cookies were brownie like, super chewy, with a crispy kinda layer/crust and walnuts inside. The cookie was not too sweet… I can say these were the best ever and I am craving it now even I had like seven of them yesterday… LOL… I would have eaten more if i could. I will definitely visit this place.
Alan W.
Rating des Ortes: 2 Syosset, NY
Always remember as a kid going to Milleridge Bakery and getting a lemon meringue pie. It was the best on the planet. I was in the area and decided to stop and see what they had too offer. The store is tiny and not much of a selection to choose from. I got an apple turnover which looked pretty good. The store was old looking and a bit rundown. The staff were friendly and helpful. Unfortunately the apple turnover was yuk! The crust was way to thick and did not taste good and the apples were not great tasting as well. I might go again but definitely would not get an apple turnover.
Phil H.
Rating des Ortes: 3 New York, NY
It’s always a joy to pick up a few bakery items to bring home after a feast at the Milleridge Inn next door. Located in the small village alongside it that features some boutique shops it’s a nice way to walk around and try to digest the massive brunch I just consumed. The cinnamon rolls are delish! As are some of their pies and specialty baked goods they make here. Grab a few snacks to bring home and enjoy with some coffee while reminiscing about the gluttony you experienced earlier in the day.
Tracy K.
Rating des Ortes: 2 Syosset, NY
The Milleridge Inn has a number of shops in the Milleridge Village. This is the bakery that bakes the famous cinnamon rolls that people love, The rest of the items are banquet style desserts, not fresh but prepackaged fruit in the pies and turnovers etc. I did see a cake that was decorated very nicely waiting for pick up. Odd bright yellow on chocolate though. Also tried the hamatash cookies and pecan bars. The place is cute and quaint but quasi commercial bakery wise.