Key Lime Pie Bakery

Great Key Lime Pie, lots of other treats/​gift options to take home as well!

The original has a very strong tart key lime flavor. The coconut key lime pie has a strong coconut flavor, but not as tart as the original. They also carry touristy souvenirs.

Visiting from Utah… We decided to go around and test all the key lime pie places. Only tried two places tonight and this place was very good; had the coconut key lime and the regular key lime. We then decided to cross the street and test out the competition… gross…Their pie was literally grainy in texture and the taste was just off! So I went back over to the Republic to tell them how much better their pie was and found out that’s because their pies are made fresh; I hadn’t noticed the kitchen that you can view from behind a window when we walked in the first time. Can’t say how they compare to all the other places as of yet, but Im not even going to bother trying places that don’t make their own pies; huge difference in quality.

We visited on Jan. 23^rd and bought a pie mix to bring home for my mom as a present.
Well she made it and it didn’t taste good at all. It actually tasted so bad that we couldn’t even eat it. We had to throw it out. She was so disappointed.
Then we realized it expired on Jan. 27^th. I was shocked that it expired so soon. I haven’t even had a chance to give to her before the expiration date. If you are looking for something to buy do not get the The Key Lime Pie Mix.

Just came by here looking for a piece of pie, asked a question (wondering what the factory was across the street) got such an attitude response for no reason. Completely turned me off from buying anything.

Good key lime pie, a bit drier/​harder than the one from Kermit‘s or the Key West key lime pie Company (my favorite), and again the original tangy and very sweet version with a nice and thick graham crust that was soft and delicious. The shop is small and you will be lucky to find a seat or a table, but you can eat the pie standing and it still will be an amazing experience!

Our family held a contest with a slice from two others shops. They won. Delicious! Perfect sweetness, taste and consistency.

You simply can’t visit Key West without eating Key Lime Pie!
I came for a slice of pie and took advantage of the $ 1 off a slice with the Unilocal check-​in. The pie was delicious. The key lime pies I’ve eaten in Los Angeles tend to be less pure with more cream.
This store also had a lot of key lime products and goodies. I bought some things to take home including key lime shortbread cookies, key lime pecans, and a key lime cake which was yummy and tasted of liquor/​vodka.

I love the Key Lime Pie! I drove 3 hours from Miami to KW by myself to get a slice of this pie and it was well worth it! Can’t wait to go back!

So it was Pi Day yesterday (3.14), and I was thinking about where I’ve had some great pies. I immediately remembered this place and noticed I hadn’t written a review for them. Hmm, I better get on that!
It was only mandatory that we had a Key Lime pie during our stay at the Florida Keys. After all, the iconic dessert did originate from these very islands! We stumbled upon this cute little shop and decided to try it here. I’m so glad we did too because it was delicious.
It was my first time trying a Key Lime pie. The closest thing I’ve had to one prior was the Yoplait version of it. The yogurt definitely does not do these heavenly pies justice! I was thankful that the lime flavor wasn’t overpowering. It was such a perfect blend of tart and sweetness. The filling was smooth, the crust was flaky– The pie gods would definitely approve. Even my Hubby who isn’t a fan of Key Lime pies wanted seconds!
The shop actually sells an array of key lime and coconut items, including ice cream, coffee, candy, and even beauty products. It’s located near other bakeries, but don’t be tempted by them; This is the one to go to for all your Key Lime needs.

Very tasty, but it would be a stretch to call it the best key lime pie I’ve ever had. Tried both the traditional KLP and the coconut version, I think the original was superior.

Damn good pie. I like their key lime cheese cake better. Each slice is 4 to 6 dollars. Be sure to check in to get your dollar off discount.

Lovely place to try the key lime pie. The custard and taste was really good. The place has loads of key lime products including cookies, hand soaps etc. There is also a coupon in the travel booklets around the area for buy one get one 50%.

4 slices of pie in two days. Super good. Pleasant shop with shady area to sit outside just off Duvall. A nice respite from the noise of Duvall.

Quaint small shop and café
Other Unilocalers recommend this spot as the best key lime pie on the island. And the price wasn’t bad either, especially after checking in and getting a dollar off each slice. Not a fan of key lime like my hubby, it tried the coconut cream pie. I really enjoyed it. Just the right amount of flakey crust for me with a nice rich coconut custard and a thin topping layer, I hate it when the topping is three times more than the rest of the pie. Everything is made right there on site, and if you come early enough you can watch the kitchen work behind the plexiglass wall.
Definitely give it a try for a sit down snack from touristy stuff.

Key. Lime. Coffee. Need I say more? If that’s not enough for you, how about coconut key lime pie? If you’re still not interested then this place just isn’t for you.

A nice store that sells Key Lime related products. During my visit, I tried their Classic Key Lime pie. It was really good. It was a good combination of sweetness and tartness. I could really taste the key limes. Customer service was friendly. The place was clean. I also tried the key lime pecans. It was OK. I tried another slice of Key Lime pie at another location on Greene Street for the sake of comparsion. I would come back again.

What’s there to say? Excellent key lime pie! Nice and tart, sweet, luscious, all at once. About $ 5 a slice, whole pies are a bit steep though. There are a few tables inside, but not many. Likely one of the best key lime pies you’ll ever have. They’ve been on the Food Network, if that sort of thing matters to you. They also claim to be the birthplace of key lime pie, but I don’t think that is known with any real certainty.

I’ll admit, I can in because I saw the show and wanted to see what Marcus was all about. Wow my jaw hit the floor when I tasted the candy. This truly is one of the best candy by sweet Peres I’ve ever had and the key lime pie is fantastic. Cute little place.

Love key lime pie and had to try it in Key West. This had great reviews so gave it a try. Wasn’t impressed. Tasted like many key lime pies I’ve had including one that I make from scratch at home. So it’s not a must have if you eat it often. I guess those that don’t would like it more.

The older lady who served us was really nice, she recommended us to try the flavors before we decided. It’s $ 4 for a small cup. The ice creams were okay, not out of the ordinary. We did not try the key lime pies, they just didn’t look that great. I would definitely try to get gelatos for the same price at Duettos pizza

Awesome Key Lime Coconut Pie! Forget expensive desserts at the area restaurants, just stop by here for a slice of heavenly pie! Customer service was excellent as they helped us bag up an entire frozen pie to take home on an 8hr drive.
We stopped by each night for a slice while on vacation and truly enjoyed our pie and visit! The key to great pie is fresh coconut and limes…

The key lime pie is substantial while the service is always busy with conversations than the actual customers. Would not recommend to anyone who wants good key lime pie.

My first visit here was in May and I was ignored even though there was only one other patron in the store, when I got to the counter, the guy didn’t have the time of day for me but had much to say to the other customer. Booooo! This last visit in June, the exact opposite, I was greeted and felt like a valued customer. The pie was good but not tart enough for me. I’m not giving marks off for that, but for the cold shoulder on my first visit.

Great pie! My first time ever trying it so I figured I’d better do it right and come here!
The pie is a bit of an acquired taste as it’s very tart in an odd way if you’re more of a sweets person, but still well made… and the crust was to die for!

I have been on the island for a week and still haven’t had a slice of key lime pie. So today I decided to go get some. And I’m so glad I did because it was delicious. The pie tasted like they used fresh limes, which they probably do. The lime flavor overpowered any sweetner, which I loved, because I don’t like extremely sweet things. I give it 5 stars. The coconut shop next door was pretty cool too. All kinds of different gifts.

Came in here around 9:00pm or so
Quick service. Checked into Unilocal and for $ 1 off a slice of pie.
Very, very rich key lime pie almost like a cheesecake consistency. pretty sharp lime flavor, which as nice… But there wasn’t nearly enough whipped cream for that bad boy. Oh well… I survived. ;)
Also had a cappuccino that paired lovely with the pie. Glad they had coffee service !
Almost went with the coconut key lime pie… but I figured I should stick with the original first.
Nice little spot, but I look forward to testing out other spots In the area for comparison.

The service was amazing. The two ladies are very very friendly and they are willing to help the tourists in any way.
I am basing my rating on their coconut and key lime pie. They are made right there where you can see the preparation and smell the pies cooking. The crust layer was ok but the other two layers (one coconut and one key lime) were on the mild side. I expected the pie to be better. It was not bad, but it didn’t fulfill my expectations either.
They have a large range of key lime snacks and candies. I took a couple but haven’t opened them yet.
Next time ill try their chocolate covered frozen key lime pie stick.

First time visiting Key West, First time trying key lime pie.
Soooo i love limes. i’ve joked that i need a lime tree in my condo with as much limes as i consume, yet for some reason I’d never tried Key lime pie. I usually go for chocolate or coconut when it comes to pie. so what better place than Key West for my first foray into the key lime pie biz. Looked up reviews on Unilocal and Unilocalers didnt disappoint.
We went with the key-​lime coconut flavor and it was heavenly! The crust was perfect. the filling was not overly sweet. The sweetness of the coconut perfectly balanced out the tartness of the lime. Now i love tart. don’t get me wrong. but in desserts not so much… The same with coconut. i love coconut but sometimes in desserts it can turn out to be too rich; so much so that i can only handle one bite and be done. But this was not the case here.
Bottom line. the lime-​coconut is a perfect marriage of sweet and tart and the crust is perfect as well. not too flaky not too buttery. I’m a fan! So much so. we went back for one more for the road! :) Needless to say the 2^nd pie didn’t make it back to Miami.

The best place on the island for Key Lime Pie featuring a very tart edition. They also feature the Key Lime Cake that is great for gifts when your there on a cruise and you need something that won’t spoil while you travel.

I stopped in here for a slice of its namesake. So often in Key West the pies are too sweet. This pie was nice and tart. It was the best Key Lime Pie I had while in Key West. The staff was friendly, and the cup of coffee I had with my pie was tasty as well.
The store sells all sorts of related items. This would be a good place to pick up a gift for someone when stopping in the keys.

Key West if full of Key Lime choices — and I honestly think this shop, away from the crowds of Duval Street, is the best.
First, they have key lime cookies. They are so good, and they are actually made in Key West! Actually, they have key lime everything from tea to marinade.
And, best of all, they dip their key lime pie into chocolate and serve it on a stick. Amazing.