Mission Hill Coffee House

Jayne is an incredible barista! Loved the iced mocha and the service was wonderful! Can’t wait to come back again for more. Definitely would recommend! Thanks Jayne! You’re great :)

Jayne is the best employee ever she was very helpful and amazingly friendly! I can’t wait to come back again and see her smiling face. The food was very good and served in a timely fashion. Very pleased with this place in every way… again Jayne was the best!

They are nice people but don’t seem to know how to make coffee drinks like iced mocha, cappuccino etc. the store is dirty.

Fantastic. They actually listened and I got an original Cap… yummy …what more can I say… dry…yummy…hot…okay …words can not express how I loved it

The coffee is pretty good and so is the service. If your hungry grab a sandwich for the road or hike.

Just. So bad. Rotting potatoes in a basket in front of the counter, dusty jars of sauces for sale, faded t-​shirts for sale, toys and games for kids covered in disgustingness, dirty tables and floors.
The baked items are likely shipped frozen and thawed from some warehouse. They certainly tasted that way. The hot chocolate was from an envelope with an extra scoop of ghiradelli chocolate stirred in. The staff barely have room to move behind the counter because it is stacked with just… crap. It was like getting coffee at a border-​line horder’s house.
We go to Madeline every year, and twice we have gone here. The first time we thought maybe it was a fluke. The second time, we threw our coffee and hot chocolate out and said never again.

This is definitely an eclectic coffee shop. It’s not our typical cute and cozy coffee shop, but instead is kind of filled with junk. I felt like I was at a garage sale with a counter in back selling coffee. It’s definitely a different atmosphere. I’m not sure what was with all the random toys and other items for sale in the main room. There were only a few tables, but we took our drinks to go. They also have another room attached to the main room that has shirts and Madeline Island knick knacks for sale.
We stopped here twice on our stay. Once we ordered a chai tea. The flavor was great, but the drink wasn’t really hot. This is fine becuase you can drink it right away, but it does get cold a little fast. The next day we ordered a hot chocolate and some breakfast. I had a bagel and my hubby had a brownie (yes, a brownie for breakfast). I wasn’t really a fan of the hot cocoa, it tasted a little bitter to me. I would have preferred a muffin or scone, but I could tell they were at least a day old since they were the same muffins as the day before, wrapped in plastic wrap. The bagel was your traditional Lender’s white bagel with regular cream cheese. The brownies were definitely fresh since we could smell them baking when we walked in the store. The flavor was good, and they had a nice crunch on the edges with a gooey center.

I think this may be the only coffee shop on Madeline Island — so clearly it’s the best.
The coffee was actually fairly good, but the Blueberry muffin was SO good! Probably the best blueberry muffin I’ve ever had, cause there were SO many blueberries in there. Way more berries to muffin mix ratio…
But a few chairs and tables outside, this place was always the happening little spot in the mornings. (We went here twice.)
I can’t confirm, but I’m assuming they had WiFi here — as both mornings I saw a couple patrons with their notebooks.