Vincenzo’s Pizzeria

This is the place to be on Friday night! A steady stream take out orders of pizzas, subs and wings… at least 10 customers moving in and out, none longer than 7 minutes. I think I saw 12 people working in there to keep the take outs, dine ins and off site catering jobs on time and happy! Great sub ingredients and the rolls are made daily on premises!

Great when they reopened. Now a little inconsistent. It’s hard to find a pizza joint local that’s better though. Delivery is fast though.

The food may be amazing but if you’re dining room is below 60 degrees on a cold, blustery day, it’s not very enjoyable.

Vincenzo’s used to be a regular stop for us on road trips. This recent trip, we learned that the restaurant had changed hands and based on my credit card statement, it is now owned by Clemenza’s, which I believe has a location in Mendon, NY. We called in our order 20 minutes early before we got there as we have 2 small children and would cut down on wait time. When we arrived, our order had not even been started yet. It took another 25 minutes to make a large and a small chicken finger sub. We received the subs and neither was correct as far as what we ordered. We then had to bother them for the slice of pizza we ordered for our 2 year old. They had forgotten, no big deal. They promptly threw a slice in the oven to re-​heat it. 5 minutes later, still no pizza. We checked with the counter and they had given his slice away. We asked again for another and they still did not bring it to us. Finally the wife had had enough and walked up to the counter and asked for a slice from the freshly cut pie they just took out and we were on our way eating. The sub rolls were rock hard, they were lacking in chicken and as previously mentioned, they did not get any of the toppings correct. On previous trips with the old owners, they used to offer the food in nice plastic baskets and they came with a pickle on the side. The subs were sloppily made, came in paper type serving baskets and no pickles. The sodas we pulled from the cooler were warm. This could either be an attempt to save money on their part or as we assumed, they were just stocked. We didnt bother to investigate. We left and did speak to the girl that «took care of us.» She offered a cookie for my son for our troubles. We told her not to bother and left. We won’t be going back. Too bad. Vincenzo’s used to be a nice stop on our way through Lakeville.

I have a cottage right down the road and have been here before which was sub par. Under new management we decided to try it out again. The medium pizza we ordered was over the size that a normal large should be and was loaded with the veggie toppings that we ordered. It was AMAZING! The service was impeccable and we were astounded at how quickly our pizza came out. It was perfectly cooked and super cheesy as we requested. As a server myself I set up the plates and silverware and got ready to toss the garbage away, but Steve came up and took them away from me before I even had a chance. He was absolutely awesome and came outside with my grandmother and I and had an entire conversation about how he would make sure to continue perfect service and food from here on out. I would highly recommend anyone to dine here!

I visited here spontaneously and was not satisfied. It was mid winter and the building was cold. The tables were also cold which caused an unwelcomed experience. The pizza claims to be «authentic Italian», it was definitely not authentic. The pizza was horrible, overcooked, and hard. It was far from fresh. Upon leaving the restaurant, I began feeling sick.

My parents live on Canesus Lake and they always order from this place! Large assortment of options on the menu. Salads, subs, fried favorites, and of course pizza! They never take too long and they always have good quality food. Whenever we don’t feel like making dinner, they are our go to. A couple other pizza places to choose from down the road but this place is the best! Friendly service too!

Perfect place for subs, pizza, and Italian eats. The service is excellent. Even though it is counter service for ordering, the staff go out of their way to serve you at the tables and make sure you have everything you need. The portions are large, the price is low, and the food quality is good.

Best buffalo chicken pizza around. They use real pieces of chicken, not fried up chicken fingers like a lot of other places.

First time eating here. Impressed with the menu, food was good. Will definitely be back!

This is some darn good pizza! I was in town visiting my sister and had a huge sheet pizza from Vincenzo’s. Just cheese. This thing was monstrous. The cheese was good and stringy, just like you remember it from your 4^th grade pizza parties! The crust was tasty: a bit chewy, a bit crunchy on the edges, not soggy, and tasted great. The sauce was quite tomatoey (is that even a word??) and very good. All in all, it was so good, I had it for breakfast the next day. It’s too bad there isn’t a Vincenzo’s in Indy!

Vincenzos has pasta, pizza, subs, and salads to eat there or have delivered and I can honestly say their food is really good. As far as subs go they have many many different kinds. You can have something from a regular sub to a cheeseburger sub. Their prices are also very reasonable. They are also located across from the lake so go and get some food and then enjoy the scenery of Conesus lake that’s directly across the road.