Secret Pizza

Good pizza. Great pizza if you’re drunk. Since you’re in Vegas, more than likely it’s going to be great pizza, but think big picture. Is it great, or are you too drunk to know the difference?
Secret Pizza is a hidden (on purpose) gem in the Cosmopolitan hotel.
Although it’s meant to be a secret, the line the goes throughout the hallway sort of gives it away.
The staff is friendly and the service is fast (ish).
It’s quality pizza. It’s not stellar– again, unless you’re hammered and need something to soak up that vodka, but don’t knock it, because it’s good.
I’m a pepperoni guy, but they have tons of options for you so don’t worry, they’ve got the selection.
The down side: it’s super small– super. Like five people inside here makes it feel crowded and there isn’t much room at all to, «dine in».
Stand in line and wait your turn and hopefully you’re not too drunk for them to understand your order.

One change for myself since the last time I ate here is that I tried Joe’s in New York City (Union Square location) which many claim to be the best in the world of NYC style pizza. I found Secret Pizza to be better. This is authentic NYC style pizza. Stand at a counter, fold it almost in half length-​wise, say things like «yous guy», and you’ll have a true NYC experience. Fogetaboutit.
By the way, the pool table is gone, so that clue to finding the place is gone.

Confused on the hype for this place because it really wasn’t that great. I wouldn’t have even known this place existed if my friend didn’t tell me about it (wow much secret pizza) and she was raving about it so we decided to come.
The line was so long and we waited possibly 15 – 20 minutes for a slice of pizza. I got a pepperoni pizza and was really unimpressed because it looked and tasted like some pizza I could’ve gotten at Costco. The crust and dough is super thin and the cheese is too thick. I don’t understand how this slice of pizza was $ 6.
I think everyone just comes here when they’re drunk and craving pizza but I’d rather go to other places in Vegas for munchies instead!

The Not-​So secret pizza. This is everyone’s go-​to spot especially after partying at Marquee. Secret Pizza is located on the 3^rd floor of The Cosmopolitan in a small alleyway with records on the wall.
Pizza is all right. Honestly, I don’t know what the hype is all about. A slice is definitely on the larger side, but I just don’t think the quality of the crust is great. Worst of all, they don’t always have all the types of pizzas out. When one type is gone, you have to wait like 25 minutes for the next one to come out… pmo. This happened to me over the weekend when I wanted to order the supreme pizza but the person right in front of me got the last slice! UGH. I ended up getting a slice of their sausage, which had barely any pieces of sausage. What really disappointed me was their crust. It was hollow and hard. It wasn’t as doughy as I would like it to be.
And they are ridiculously overpriced! $ 6 for a slice?! You must be kidding me.

I have been coming here for years… And finally reviewing it.
I strongly suggest you try this pizza, try to do it during the day so you don’t have to wait in the crazy line after the club. Also, it’s going to be expensive— it’s Vegas, duh.
Have the white pizza, but the pepperoni and the sausage pizza are good too.

I’ve been to this place a few times now and always enjoyed it. For me, it is the best place to go grab a quick snack at the Cosmo. Yes, it is $ 5 a slice. Yes, it is «just» above average pizza (it’s Vegas!). Yes, it is not a secret anymore and there are often lines, and yes, it still is hard to find even after coming here several times (maybe it’s just me).
With all that said, I keep coming back and there is something to be said for that. What? I don’t know. I kind of expect to pay higher than average when in Vegas so I’m ok with it. I also kind of expect to wait in line from time to time. Maybe my coping skills are better than some other reviewers. But, back to the food. It’s just above or slightly above average pizza. But after a few drinks or a big win at the tables, and it is a slice from the gods. After a loss at the tables, its the only thing to eat because there isn’t much around cheaper or more convenient. I would say they have a great business model!
Pros: convenient (if you are in Cosmo), relatively inexpensive, not bad quality, can feed you on your last $ 5 after taking a beating at the tables.
Cons: kind of overpriced for what it is. I hate trying to find this place.
Overall. It doesn’t matter what I say, or whether I like it or not. If I’m staying at the Cosmo again, I’ll be back. If not, maybe not. Love their concept though, and the guys working there have always been cool as heck.

It’s a very normal slice of pizza at an outrageous price with a horrific line if you go from 10PM-​2AM. Woo, Vegas?
In all fairness, it isn’t bad. I just think there are better late night options on the strip.

Secret Pizza… not quite a secret. It’s easy to find, just look for a narrow hallway lined with vintage vinyl albums along the walls.
White Pie ($ 28) — 5 stars. I don’t know what’s in this pie, but it’s damn good. It contains light cheese but still boasts rocking flavors!
Pepperoni Pie ($ 26) — 3 stars. Below standard for pepperoni pizza.
Expect a 20– to 25-​minute wait for whole pies. They provide paper plates, parmesan cheese, and pepper. Just ask. We came in around dinner time and there was hardly any wait. I hear the lines can be kind of ridiculous right after clubbing hours.
Vintage arcade games such as monopoly pinball and original pac-​man.

This place is the bomb! I’ve never had a slice of pizza that made me feel so happy. It’s really hidden and if you don’t know your way around the Cosmo it’s easy to get lost. When you walk in you really expect more to this place but you really feel like it’s straight to the point and they’re not over doing it. For around $ 30 – 40 depending on topping you can have a whole pie here next time I will be ordering one instead of getting 4 slices for $ 27. But their product is FIRE! So freaking good I will be back for sure. Looking forward to trying the white slice next time.

wau! secret pizza! So I guess it is a secret because it is unmarked and down a short hallway? But in reality if you pass it and look at it, it seems like a normal place to go. But if you aren’t looking at it you will definitely miss it. The entrance is just a hallway.
I ended up having a little bit of the white pizza. and it was DELICIOUS! Also compared to the other pizza i had in vegas, this one definitely was tasty, and settled well in my stomach. As usual, pizza is greasy but you wouldn’t want to ask for one any less greasy than this. It’s good affordable food for those sober and not alike. Definitely recommend to go if you want quick food for cheap.

Very oily, semi-​thin crust, semi-​crispy, really gooey, and a dash of overhyped. In the age of Unilocal and the interwebz, this place isn’t even a secret anymore, but it’s cute that they wanna play to my inner child and pretend like I’m one of the few in on the «secret». I’d be hard pressed to stand in line around 7 pm again when there’s a 30 minute wait. I did however try it again at 4 AM, and 4 AM me loved it.
If you don’t mind patting down your pizza like you’re the TSA or if you just want to taste the hype for yourself, then by all means try it! I just prefer my pizza not oozing with oil. Like others have said, $ 6 is affordable for Vegas, but it’s pretty ridiculous elsewhere. If you’re tryna be cost effective, order a whole white pie for $ 28 to share with friends (or if you eat it all by yourself, I commend you). Just know that it’ll be an additional 20 minutes until you have that piping hot gooey pie in your hands.

I hadn’t been back to Secret Pizza since 2012 according to Swarm! I had to «re-​find» my way. Hallway of album covers next to Jaleo in Cosmo? Actually pretty easy!
A pin ball table, several bar stools and mostly standing space fill the room (though not much). Super nice guys work there. Happy to chat it up. I brought an unopened Mexican Coke from the Coca Cola factory nearby and they uncapped it for me.
The pizza is pretty thin crust. I love it that way. Toppings don’t weigh it down. Just good pizza!

We were wandering around the Cosmopolitan and looked up restaurants on Unilocal.Secret Pizza popped up. Yea! A scavenger hunt of sorts.
We found it on the 3^rd floor down a long hallway. I believe there are maybe 7 seats and 3 video games in this small place. We were able to stand at a counter. We must have arrived at a slow time because there wasn’t a line and fresh slices were coming out of the oven.
The pizza. I’m not a huge fan of cheesy pizza. But I do appreciate a good New York style. I had a meat lovers slice and a slice with salami and banana peppers. Both were excellent. The sauce wasn’t bland but not overpowering either.
I definitely enjoyed my slices and the uniqueness of Secret Pizza. Also loved the menu — «no ranch» — which is a makes me laugh. I know ranch dressing is quite controversial.

I’ve been dying to try this place out since I saw my friend check in at this not so secret secret pizza parlor! It is LITERALLY a hole in the wall
though, there’s no giant sign to direct you there. There’s an alley way inside the cosmopolitan that leads you to the little pizza store. Luckily the line wasn’t too ridiculous. They have a variety of pizza to choose from and you can make your own too. My friends and I each got two slices, one white each thanks to my friend’s recommendation and one pepperoni, one sausage and peperoncino, and another sausage one.
The slices were huge, like Costco pizza slices, definitely filling enough, 2 each killed us. 1.5 each would of satisfied us just fine. The white pizza was great. It was a variety of cheeses I believe and normally I hate crumbly cheese like feta but whatever was on that pizza was delicious. It was a bit oily but what good pizza isn’t. We came here for lunch but it’s opened super late which is great for late night Vegas munchies! I used to always go to earls but now I know the Vegas secret ! I’ll be back for more secret pizza!
Note: there isn’t much sitting space since it’s a small store. Usually it’s a grab and go, we took our pizza and ate on the couches outside!

Secret pizza is right, so freaking hidden. Basically third floor on the east side of hotel. Pfffft.
Saw a lot of clubbers hitting up this joint when we popped in for a midnight chow. Basically, get in line, order pizza by the slice or pie at the counter and find a seat anywhere in the world as their actual dining area is tiny. There are plenty lounge seats n random tables you can settle at.
Love that they have the oregano shaker. I snatched it to take outside with me, haha. My favorites are the combo pizza and the mushroom n sausage. Great flavors. The others: sausage n peppercini n the sausage n pepperoni were good also. I like the kind of sausage they use… Mmmm.
I don’t normally like excessive cheesiness in pizza so the combo was perfecto. Gotta have at least 2 slices per person. I don’t get it when I see someone waiting in line n getting just ONE slice. Diet much, cuz I see it in their faces after they put it away that they should’ve gotten another slice. Tsk tsk. Live n never learn.

Yummy pizza that will satisfy you after a night of clubbing, drinking, or if you’re looking for a snack.
This is located upstairs in the Cosmo on the right side of where you’d enter for their club/​pool parties. There isn’t a name, but instead a long hall with pictures that you walk down in.
Luckily every time I’ve come here there wasn’t a line. You pick your slice, they warm it up, and you pay. Easy concept and quick bit to eat. Will run you about $ 5-​$ 6 depending on what kind of slice you get.
Good crunchy texture but a bit oily. Guess that’s what your napkin is for!

Did anyone order me a plain cheese?!
Is there anything better than pizza at 1am after a night on the town? Or pizza for lunch? Or pizza anytime really? I say no.
This pizza place hits the spot every time. There is always a wide variety of choices including pepperoni, sausage and peppers, veggie and yes plain cheese. It comes by the slice or the whole pie and served up fresh and hot.
This New York style pie is a thinner dough and a crunchy crust and comes with any tasty topping you want.
I love this place. It’s a Vegas strip staple. Look for the hallway next to the elevator on the third floor next to Jaleo.

Having missed this place during my last visit, my mind was incepted with the idea of coming here later in the night… fast forward to 2am and my buddies and I are waiting in line for our post party meal of cheese, meats, and GREASE! Tucked next to Jaleo on the 2^nd floor of the Cosmo, it’s really not that hard to find, unless, I guess if you are super drunk. But there was a pretty decent line for this Secret pizza place, reminds me of the lines at the jumbo slice places back here in DC after a night of partying, but no one really minded the wait with the main prizes on their mind and taste buds.
The pizza itself? I thought it was great, I mean I blinked and it was gone. Maybe it was the fact that I was starving and had a few drinks, but I remember it having a distinct taste, nice and soft, not too soft or floppy, freshly baked dough and crusts and a good helping of toppings on each slice. I got two slices; one white pizza with cheese and ricotta cheese and a second slice with mushroom and pepperoni and they sure did the job.
Prices were standard for Vegas ($ 5-​$ 6 a slice I think).
All in all, Secret Pizza lived up to my hype, I would definitely come back here when I am back in the area and recommend it to any pizza lover, especially for later in the night.

White slice with tomato. Do it now! $ 6/​slice may be a bit much, but I’ve been officially converted. The pepperoni is fine but the signature white pie is actually worth the hype: garlicky, cheesy, just a little bit gooey, and those tomatoes just make it extra special. Service is friendly, spot is bare-​bones but in a good way, snag a stool if you see one available!
Note: Some people take the «secret» part a little too literally– it’s not on any maps or even the Cosmopolitan website. Go to the 3^rd floor with all the other restaurants, and find the hallway between Blue Ribbon Sushi and Jaleo.

Sorry not sorry! 3.5 stars in my book.
I don’t get what the hype is all about!!! Maybe people love it cuz they are drunk and just think it’s so good but me I wasn’t drunk and I had this place twice during my stay at the Cosmopolitian and both times it was good but it wasn’t thay greatttt that people make it seem. Yes the pizza is thin and the cheese sauce is good but that’s really all. It’s good but not the best. The guys working here are super nice and $ 5.00−5.50 for one freaken slice of pizza is really not worth it.
I wouldn’t rush back I think there are plenty of other options for pizza on the strip. I do like that it does have a cool hidden secret look to it when entering but other than that nothing to rave about.

Bonne adresse de pizza, de belles part a manger sur place ou de grandes pizza à emporter.
L’endroit se trouve au 2ème étage du cosmopolitan (3ème niveau !) au fond d’un couloir avec des affiches, pas facile à trouver mais il suffit de demander, il n’y a pas de pancartes et il n’apparaît sur aucun plan.
On y va pour les pizzas, pas pour le lieu.

Love this Place.
Always worth a Trip.

Very nice Pizza, try to find it! ;-)

Aaaaah voilà une adresse qu’elle est bonne sur le Strip de Las Vegas ! Une pizzeria comme à New York (en tout cas dans mon esprit) qui vous sert d’énormes parts de pizza que vous mangez debout dans un coin ou perché sur une chaise haute. Vous regardez les pizzas, vous choisissez la part qui vous plait parmi ⁵⁄₆ sélections, tout bêtement.
L’endroit n’a rien de très excitant mais c’est justement ça qui fait son charme ! Parts de pizza énormes à 5 dollars (ok, un peu cher, mais c’est le Strip) et délicieuses ! Staff serviable et souriant en prime.
En plus l’endroit est faussement secret, situé au bout d’un couloir au milieu du Cosmopolitan, ce qui veut dire que si vous avez de la chance, les hordes de touristes enivrés du Strip n’arriveront pas jusque là, yeah !