That Pizza Place

Absolutely love this pizza place! My fiancé and I order pizza and garlic knots from here at least once a week. Pizza is always on point and delivery is quick. Five stars!

Excellent vegan options! Friendly service! Good vibes! I had the vegan chicken roll and vegan chicken bbq slice. Seitan is made in house which is pretty neat! I look forward to going back and trying the rest of the options!

It was really good. Just feel like it could have been a little fresher and hotter when served to me. Definitely one of the best pizzeria’s in the area.

Vegan food without the vegan price.
Never thought I’d have vegan pizza right down the road from my house!
I had a regular cheese slice and the buffalo seitan slice. Only ~$ 7 for both!
The regular slice was great, crust was nice, good amount of cheese, could have used a little more sauce.
Buffalo Seitan slice did not have enough buffalo sauce thus leaving it a bit dry.
I would recommend trying this place and keeping it on your vegan radar because they are new and developing an all vegan menu! Spoke to some nice employees and they were friendly and seemed excited for where the business was heading.
I would return because of location, price, atmosphere and to try their new recipes. Can’t wait until they perfect their menu.

Really good pizza! Extra cheesy too! Perfect ratio of cheese, dough and sauce.
They have weekly specials each night which is good.
Much better than the old pizza place that used to be in the same location.
I just read they have a vegan menu too… Good to know and in sure it’s a great selling menu because who doesn’t love pizza !

For myself the vegan and my fiancé the meat eater, this place was perfect! I got the «chicken» parm hero and my fiancé got the chicken bbq pizza and Sicilian pizza. The sauce is delicious! We loved it. When I asked for a to go container, the guy behind the counter seemed genuinely concerned that I liked my food. We’ll definitely be back!

«That Pizza Place» blows segesta out of the water ! I am so happy that they now exist. The buffalo chicken pizza is the best I’ve ever had. The variety of slices and rolls to pick from each day are always interesting and delicious. I would pick going to That Pizza Place over every other pizza shop in town. Very friendly owner as well.

We ordered delivery and it arrived hot and on time. Pizza and garlic knots were delicious. The vegan pizza was amazing! The staff are very friendly. Some of these negative reviews sound like people just don’t like change. Don’t live your life in fear people!

Love this place! My new go to pizza place. Have my whole family ordering from them. Grandma Sicilian pie is our go to. Love the specialty pies, really changing up the Pizza Game!

I’ve never really had vegan rolls before but I have to say, the vegan chicken roll was pretty frikkin good.
The ambiance of the place is pretty cool too, it felt like they were playing my ipod from my High School days with old hits from Casey to Juvenile
My friend had an vegan eggplant roll that was good too

My new favorite pizza in town. They opened relatively recently so I’m excited to see if their menu will expand. Looking forward to it!

I’m not so sure about this place, i only ordered delivery once. I order a bunch of things and it wasn’t very good. The fried artichoke hearts had no flavor, the buffalo slice was just bad, the mac and cheese bites I’m pretty sure we’re made without cheese. The chicken fingers were ok but they weren’t home made or anything just fried up out of a bag and the only thing I managed to eat was a rice ball, I don’t think I will try them again, there are to many 5 – 6 star pizza places around for this place to survive, good luck

The new owner is very sociable and always willing to explain about the food and the options. He told us that everything on the menu can be changed up to your liking, because everything is made fresh. They do not use frozen chicken and the vegan options are awesome. Staff is very friendly and both the pizza’s and other items taste great. Interior needs some tweaking, but they have not been there too long so I assume that will be done in time.

Living 20 seconds away from this location it is easy, and once was excited to get food from the location when it was Segesta. Ive tried the food here about 5 times now since going under new ownership, and i have to say the pizza is of the lowest standard on long island! You can absolutely tell there is no passion in this pizzaria and its operating strictly for business/​monetary purposes. I usually get chicken slices (bbq, buffalo etc.) and they are extemely dry and lack taste… The chicken itself seems like frozen chicken out of a bag. I always see the new owner in the store however he seems non social and not very welcoming. The décor has been brought to virtually nothing and is very bland. Being in the restaurant industry and managing a restaurant myself. I HIGHLY reccomend making serious changes if this business wants to succeed.

So happy that this place exists! As a vegan it’s not always easy to find good options at non vegan restaurants but they have an entire vegan menu here!
I have tried the vegan chicken roll and vegan buffalo chicken roll and both were excellent. They use housemade seitan that is extremely delicious and so close to tasting like chicken it may even fool some carnivores!
The restaurant plans to expand their vegan offerings so stay tuned for an even bigger vegan menu here in the future!
They charge the same price for vegan or non vegan options of the same item which I really appreciate.
They are open late on the weekends and the staff is really friendly. Definitely a great option in the area and I can’t wait to try more of their vegan menu items.

When this place was segestas the food wasn’t that good and now it’s even worse. I ended up having their pizza which was super thin and the sauce still needs to be perfected. The pepperoni wheels I didn’t even finish all it was is dough and a pepperoni cut in half and placed on top. It was awful and I suggest they go back to the old pepperoni wheels because that was the only thing that kept me going back.

We had ordered two pies and some garlic knots.
To start, everything was cold. Also, the dough was extremely undercooked and dense. With that being said it still wasn’t too bad. It was very cheesy which everyone loved but I wouldn’t chose this pizza again.
It reminded me of pizza from United skates.

GREAT new hot spot right in the heart of Levittown. All of the ingredients are fresh and you can taste the difference. And finally a place in the neighborhood that is open late night on the weekends. Anyone who lives in the area knows there is nowhere to get good food around here after 10pm.
Try the mac & cheese balls, they’re on point!

A great place. Totally fresh taste and a ton of innovations. Nutella pizza? Gotta try it next time. And finally some place to go when you got a hankering for a slice at one am on a Friday or Saturday!
Outstanding!

When I heard there was a new pizza place in town I wanted to give it a try. I was intrigued on Saturday when I saw the sign saying they’re open until 2:00 am. I figured I would give them a try on my way home from work tonight. Knowing this is Sunday I gave a drive by and they looked open. Walking in I saw their hours and realized I was wrong, but they still had some slices and threw two in the oven for me.
While I was waiting I chatted up the owner. He was explaining the menu to me when I realized a guy in there was eating fried Oreos. The fryer was still on so they put me in an order of fried Oreos.
Now we continued our conversation. This is more than your typical pizza place. First off, they stay open late. 2:00 am on Friday and Saturday. In addition to your typical New York pizza products, they have an entire vegan menu I’m looking forward to trying. Vegan cheese, vegan calzones, vegan «chicken» rolls… it goes on.
My two slices and fried Oreos were great, and the guys in there were very friendly. The owner was very welcoming and introduced me to his vegan chef and consultant. (My words not his) I look forward to coming back. Who knows? Maybe I’ll get a rice ball tomorrow. h