Michael’s Pizzeria

This restaurant no longer exists. it was sold last year and it has a new name. the pizza is still good and the price is still affordable, though not quite as low on their specials as it was when it was called Michaels.
Still more of a no frills pizza place.

Cute little place, everyone there is so nice. Everything I’ve ordered there has been fresh and delicious! The chicken cutlet sandwich, rigatoni alla vodka, raviolis, grandma and Sicilian pie, all delicious. Great pizza place!

Used to be an amazing pizza place. The pizza is horribly greasy now. The last time I had their meatball slice, I got food poisoning and threw up.

wow i have never seen pizza look this bad, well i have but i will get to that in another review. the pizza is just terribel i dont know why my friend loves coming here

I ordered 2 regular slices and a pepperoni and found a roach like bug in my slice!!! I sent someone to try and return it and the guy didn’t even give the money back! The bug was cooked into the slice and it was clearly noticeable so how could they not be more careful. So grossed out by this place and I do not recommend this place to anyone!

Michael’s Pizzeria is great! They serve fresh good food daily. There isn’t an overflow of people most days (I typically grab lunch there). So, if you’re worried about the midday work crowd, fear not!
Their pricing is decent. Most pizza places charge $ 2.50 or more per regular slice. And their special topping slices are only $ 3.50.
Taste: Everything I’ve tried there is amazing and I’ve had no complaints by my taste buds nor by bowel movements! ;) The things I’ve tasted and loved:
regular pizza, greek salad, taco pizza, christina, zippoli (spelling??), minestrone soup, chicken noodle soup, chicken tortellini soup, spinach pizza.
I also love my pizza very hot! and, they don’t mind keeping it in the oven a little extra. Some places, I’ve had to give my slice back b/​c I found it to be too cool to eat, and they gave me odd looks… but here, there’s no strangeness about that.
— — — — — — — — — — — — — –
Aside from all of my remarkable marketing skills, I do feel the need to be extra honest and point out the negatives as well:
Once, I noticed a baby roach on one of the trays, and I pointed it out to the staff — they removed the tray, and I’m not sure what happened to the calzones on it, but I would recommend — if you’re going to order a slice or roll of anything left out in the open, check the tray before ordering.
My most recent time there, someone accidentally knocked either the pepper or oregano sprinkler jar on the floor as they left, and someone else, picked it up and brushed the edges w/​his hand… as far as I’m concerned, that jar top is no longer clean, and anything that comes out of it will become more dirty as well. No one took the effort to wipe it w/​a wet towelette or something!
If you’re a little bit paranoid like that, I would definitely recommend the soups. They’re always extremely hot and tasty! :) I absolutely love their chicken tortellini! The pint is $ 4.50 and the quart is $ 8.00. You save fifty cents, but it’s worth it — you’ll have extra the next day/​night! Or you can share it w/​someone!
Lastly, a regular customer came in once, and he said he wanted THAT slice. They cut him the next slice in the round of slices, and the man wasn’t happy and continued to point and demand for the slice he wanted. It was a stupid nothing quarrel, but don’t be too choosy around them, they find it to be ridiculous. I think it’s no biggy… but whatever!
They have dessert too, but the menus on the wall don’t advertise it, so if you’re interested — ask!
They accept credit cards — but only w/​a minimum purchase of $ 10.
There’s outdoor seating too — but not really … more like one small round table outside w/​two chairs on either end. Good luck grabbing that on nice days!
— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — -
I hope my remarks have helped, and happy eats! :)

Sicilian pie was very tasty. Delivery fast, cooked to order.

. I had a large pie and garlic knots. The crust was light and fluffy, as was the garlic knots. Was not sure about place before giving it a try. I will be back for the Sunday $ 7.99 large pie every Sunday.