Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt

I used to love this place but it has become run down and dirty. Flavor selection is not the greatest. Wish they would build a TCBY self serve frozen yogurt in New Braunfels.

Thanks for closing 5 – 10 minutes early so my wife and I couldn’t enjoy some of orange leafs great yogurt

As far as Orange Leaf goes, it’s as expected. The low review comes from their choice of flavors. If you like the vanilla, chocolate, and cheesecake, you will beer OK going here. If you are looking for any of the cake flavors or cookies and cream — you’ll be lucky to be able to get it once a year. The last four times I’ve been, no cakes (wedding, birthday, red velvet, corner pieces, etc.) or cookies and cream. And the last time I was there, the cookies and cream was in a dispenser that was not working. I realize there’s a lot of flavors, but there’s also a lot of cake flavors too. From now on, we will drive across town and go to the one off of Hwy 46… where they always have cake!

While I do love Orange Leaf, this is my least favorite location. The best one in my opinion is at the Rim in San Antonio. This location has weird parking, is hard to find, and utilizes the old orange leaf logo on their signage which is super hard to decipher from up close let alone the freeway. Their employees insist on serving up the samples for you which is something I have never experienced at any of their other locations. If they are busy it makes it a huge inconvenience. Their fruit toppings here are sometimes canned… gross. Other locations have strictly fresh fruit. All in all, don’t judge orange leaf by this location.

Love this place! It’s always super clean and the chick that is normally there goes along with my husband’s cheesy jokes. They are also open until 10pm which is awesome for the area.
Regarding the thing about not having sample cups out for people to just take, I think that it may be a health code violation and to get around it they have an employee administer your sample. I know that the New Braunfels health department is very strict and on top of things.
Regarding the parking, they have a back door that remains open during business hours so just park in the lot and open the door. Otherwise you can go around to the front door and enjoy the calming water features.
I love their flavors. Sometimes the swirled combos are a little weird but you can always get them separate.
The only topping I wish they had was peanut butter sauce. Their toppings are always fresh and the staff make sure to keep the topping area very clean.

My favorites are pomegranate, and the combination of chocolate and coconut.

Love the yogurt but the price is a bit high. The place is always clean, and the counter people are very nice.

I loved the yogurt here. I did think it was a little pricey and I would have prefered the option of choosing a smaller cup to put it in. They only have one size cup which I guess works to their benefit in hoping you over-​indulge. I craved the little juice balls they had as a topping for days after eating this yogurt. It was great. The parking is awkward as one reviewer said, but truthfully, that whole shopping center is awkward. I am sure the Orange Leaf people thought they would pull business from the sandwich shop (which will be another review) and the movie theater by picking this location. All in all — I enjoyed the experience and will go back again.

As a Fro-​yo addict (check my list) I’m going to do this shop a service and provide some tips on how they can remain in business past the next 12 – 18 months. As it currently stands I don’t see them making it longer than that, and i think there is enough potential to make a go of it.
Here’s what I would consider changing:
— Overly sweet. This yogurt is over the top too sweet, I felt sick after eating it. Usually I feel better after eating fro-​yo. Additionally, there are no nutritional details on the yogurt which is suspect — I hope there isn’t HFCS being used as a sweetener, but I fear there might be.
— Flavors are way, way off. Pistachio tasted like white chocolate (and it was white), the oreo tasted like a very sweet and carmely dulce de leche, the red velvet was just like eating sugar cane. I honestly thought someone had moved all the flavor signs from April 1 as a joke. The peanut butter and chocolate were ok, but all the other flavors were not close to what they were labeled.
— Pricing — .45 an ounce, really? Most places are .39 in Austin and are putting out better product.
— Samples — just give me a tiny cup or two, no need to have the worker fill them for me.
— The logo is not easy to read from I-​35 — I can’t make out the Orange Leaf logo. You are the only fro-​yo stand between Austin and San Antonio that I have seen — make it clear to recognize at 75 mph.
— Location — The location of this shop makes no sense. When you find the shop and park near it, you park in the back of the shop and enter from the rear while the front faces an empty field. It’s not super close to the theater or big box stores either. If this were my store it would be between the Target and Best Buy as they have the most traffic and presence. The location is irritating when there are better spots still vacant.
I think this place has potential and I don’t mean to sound harsh. You could do all but the move with some small tweaking but right now the flavors and the sweetener is so off that I wouldn’t return unless those were adjusted.

Finally found a great Frozen Yogurt opens in New Braunfels.
Absolutely great Yogurt & Awesome flavor selections. This place is as good as pink berry or yogurtland, Can’t wait to go again…