Pie Five Pizza

I really wanted to like this place, however, it falls in to one of those yuppie-​urban-​hipster place. The menu looks promising and pizza ready in 5 minutes sounded great. The pizza crust somehow managed to become burnt and the Caesar salad had rotten lettuce in it. Maybe just bad luck or just the location. I think Little Caesar’s or Poppa Johns may have been better.

All I can say is Yummy!!! Got a vege pizza, no cheese and that keeps it nice and healthy!!!

Ok I’ve been here twice now. It’s a little pricey but I do like it.
First time I got spicy sauce. Call me a whimp, but it’s pretty spicy.
Cashier went AWOL on me first time, but ended up comping me a drink because I had to wait while he finished smoking. Good thing for that drink because of that sauce.
Be sure to join their eClub because I’ve gotten good savings from it so far. Hence, my return visit.
I like being able to have them add whatever toppings I want and you’re right there to guide them as they do it. You say light sauce to Pizza Hut and still have 90 tons dripping off the sides.
I will be back, that’s for sure. Even though $ 7.99 seems a bit much for a personal size pizza, but it’s yummy.

My boys loved the pizza but the service was horrible. We had a group of 9 and the lady prepping the pizza was not helpful since it was new for all. The manager started putting up chairs before closed and it made us feel rushed.

The price and the service was fast and friendly you get fresh toppings. Good price for the pizza and you can bundle it for $ 9.99

The layout at the 119^th location sucks. The lunchtime line stretched all the way to the door, by the tables, by the soda machine and by the napkins, meaning we had someone’s butt in our faces and a continual cold breeze from the front door all during the meal. The «fast-​food» pizza and salads are fine. Iced tea excellent. Pizza, salad and drink for $ 10 and change. One co-​worker who really likes it said they have online coupons and an in-​store rewards setup.

Great Pizza! Great price!!! Join the rewards program to earn free pizza!. What a great new way to order pizza!

This place is gross. The pizza makers are so messes. Also they don’t change their gloves after making one customers pizza. It’s so unsanitary for someone to touch all the meats then get into veggies. Especially when the customers sees it. Just ew.

Quick cheap pizza! You get what you pay for basically. For some reason this pizza comes out cooked in regards to the crust but also cold. I have gone 3 times and each time the pizza comes out just barely warm. Again people will rate anything a 4 or 5 on here.

I love this place! For 6.99 you can order a pizza from the menu or make your own. It is made before your eyes & then you are asked how it looks. You can then add more toppings if you want. Baked in the oven and then you have choices of basil, cilantro, pesto sauce, sundried tomato sauce and some «magic dust» to finish it off. I recommend the Althenian pizza but I haven’t eaten a pie I didn’t like

When we walked in we were the only customers there. We ordered our pizza came out quick and the staff was great. I ordered the buffalo chicken pizza and really liked it. By the time we were done eating there was a long line of people waiting. It looked like they had a hard time keeping up with cleaning off the tables and taking care of the customers in the line but overall I would recommend this place to anyone.

New locations always have a few hiccups. It takes time for the staff at the new location to learn how to run the business like they do at the old location, if they do it at all.
It’s still a good price for a good pizza, but I’m finding the expansion to be not as good as the original.

Ohmygoodness what a fun place! I’m amazed that pizza can cook in 5 minutes, but it did! And it was pretty tasty! Of course I think I’d like even bad pizza, because it’s pizza!
This place is new-​ish, so the staff is super friendly. Hope they keep it up when the novelty wears off.
We will definitely be back– it’s a good value. $ 10 for a pizza, drink, and salad or dessert. The pizzas easily serve 2, if you’re not absolutely ravenous.
My only complaint is that several empty tables needed to be bussed. It’s always disconcerting to be sitting and trying to enjoy a meal while there are dirty tables within eyesight.

Ok… There must’ve been a soft grand opening because I didn’t know they were open. I’ve always frequented the one on 135^th & Metcalf and have been EXTREMELY satisfied.
The set up at this establishment is odd and extremely inconvenient. You enter the front door and straight into a cattle stall line. You can’t see what’s in front of you because of other patrons in line and a wall. Look to the left, you see customers eating and exiting the building. Look to the right, and your nose hits the wall. WHO the heck DESIGNED THIS PLACE?
You can’t see the food, you can’t see the preparers, you can’t see anything. Eventually as the line mooooves, you get a side view of the person wanting to take your order. You STILL can’t see any of the toppings (unless your 6 feet tall) because you’re practically standing side by side with the worker asking which crust you want and what toppings. If you’re unfamiliar with the process you’re like a fish out of water.
After floundering like a fish out of water (having your pie created & placed in the oven), you’re shoulder to shoulder with strangers waiting for your pie to cook as the line crawls to the register. Very slow and **Tooooo close for comfort**
You watch as workers are creating pizza masterpieces and side salads with «communion cracker» crusts and delicious desserts line up (x5) to be paid for… but the space is sooooooooooo tight, all you can do is be patient and wait your turn. You eventually make it to the register to pay.
The Food is so fresh and so yummy, but I’ll pass on this location. THIS PLACE IS TOO SMALL AND AWKWARD. My favorite is on 135^th & Metcalf… Onward to the newest on Johnson Drive.
I ended up dumping my communion cracker salad bowl. It was as thin as a cracker and as dark as toast. The others I’ve had were true salad bread bowls.

This is like the Chipotle of pizza!
You can customize your own personal pizza or pick one of their pre-​configured topping combinations and have it cooked in under 5 minutes with no extra charge for toppings.
My favorites are the Jack Stack BBQ Pulled Pork and the Pesto Chicken Alfredo from their menu. I add jalapeño’s to the Jack Stack and Artichoke hearts on the Pesto Chicken Alfredo pizza.
Amazing value and probably best pizza I’ve had outside of gourmet pizza joints like Minsky’s.

I liked the custom-​built pizzas ($ 6.99), outdoor seating, nice dining area, Coke freestyle machine, e-​club, and background music.
Plenty of fresh topping choices were available, and there was no upcharge for extra toppings. My pizza was ready in five minutes, so it was a good, quick meal.
I found the service on opening day to be friendly, and helpful.