Pie Five Pizza Co

What a great concept! I wish I had come up with it. Loved that each person in our family could create their own pizza. Taste was fantastic and price very reasonable! We will return.

I had the 5 star and my husband had the bbq chicken on artisan crust. Both were really good. Great value and It’s fun to add or make your own combo… I added spinach and jalapeños for fun. The crust is perfect … Thin and crunchy and not burned like the last 2 times I’ve been to Spin pizza! Love the concept and will be back as the salads look awesome too!

This place is delicious! I love that you can pick everything that you want on your pizza and it’s done by the end of checkout. Not only do I love the fast and friendly environment, but the pizza is absolutely delicious!

Make-​your-​own pizza, comes out quick, and it has been consistently good when I have visited. I like the thin crust, which is crispy with just the right amount of bite. Toppings have always been very, very fresh. Service is quick, friendly, and the dining area is usually neatly picked up unless you’ve come in just at the end of a mealtime rush.
They’ve got one of those space-​age Coke machines with nine million flavors. The Guy has a totally unreasonable love for lime Coke, so, a big plus.
We really enjoy this place for a quick, casual meal.

Excellent pizza for a good price. Very very fast, excellent place to go for a quick lunch or dinner. A huge variety of crusts, sauces and toppings!

We love Pie Five. My husband said it’s great to be able to go out for pizza with the kids and not have to get cheese pizza, we can finally all get what we want! If you haven’t been here, it’s like a Chipotle for pizza (not original, I know) where you pick your own crust, sauce, and toppings. All pizzas and individual size. They also have a gluten free crust and for my GF friends they are VERY careful about cross contamination, changing gloves between crusts and using separate surfaces etc. The prices are fairly reasonable and my kids flip out over the fancy Coke machine with a million flavors (it’s the little things).

You want fast, cheap and great? Sorry. You only get two, This is fast and cheap. Great? Nope. Its good, but not great pizza. We had the thick crust. That was probably our poor choice. The ingredient do seem fresh. However, it seemed rather skimpy as to quantity.
You certainly can make your own choices. That’s a good thing.
We had the chocolate chip cookie pie. I should have skipped it. It was doughy and the chocolate drizzle was slightly bitter.
My take. If you want a quick, cheap pizza, its a go. If you’re looking for a loaded traditional pizza experience, look somewhere else.

This pizza is amazing! I Cannot review their service, as a coworker picked it up and brought it back to us, but the food is a good as it looks. We got their lunch special and it cheap and delicious. All six of us ordered something different, and where some places probably wouldn’t have gotten something correct, there was not a single thing wrong with our order! I ordered the personal size margarita, the toppings were fresh, and the thin crust was perfectly crispy! YUM, I cannot wait to come back, and actually experience the full service and food!

Quick (like five mins), cheap ($ 6.99), good (bc you get to pick your own toppings), & even the thin crust is good & crispy! I’ll be back with the family!

Have been a regular visitor here for almost a year. Yes, it’s Chipotle, but pizza… but the ingredients are great, the combination s you can build are practically endless and you get your pizza in just a few minutes.
12 inch pizza for 7 bucks, in and out in a few minutes and the staff is awesome. Friendly, helpful and once you’ve been there a few times, they will remember you.
The owners have other locations throughout the city and I can’t recommend them highly enough.

This place was introduced to me by a family member. I’m not a big pizza fan, however this place took me by surprise. You can build your own any topping and different types of crust. All the ingredients are really fresh. I am also a big supporter of customer service and they were the friendliest staff I have ran into in a while. That alone will bring me back. The atmosphere was cool hip and young. I would bring my parents to my grandparents. A must try place at least once! Thumbs up Pie Five Pizza Co!

Since my office moved recently, I’ve driven by this location every day. I’ve heard a few people say it was good, so wanted to check it out.
My wife and I went in at about 1:00pm on Saturday. There were about 8 people in front of us in line, so I was expecting a 15 to 20 minute wait. I figured it would take some time to get all of those pizzas through the oven. However, we were through the line and had our pizzas in about 10 minutes. I wish we had to wait longer…
My wife and I both had the Five Star. She subtracted the olives. I subtracted the bell peppers, but added spinach. The taste of the sauce, toppings, and crust was okay. However, they were lukewarm at best. The cheese was barely melted and the crust in the middle would have been doughy if it had been thicker. When we were in line, I noticed the slicer was reaching into the oven to pull out the next pizza instead of letting it reach the finishing tray. I suspect the time of the oven would have been good to fully cook (reheat?) the pizza if he had not prematurely pulled it. I timed one of the subsequent pizza cook times with my phone and from the time it was placed in at one end until the time the slicer took it out was exactly 2 minutes. Granted, the crowd had slowed by that point, so I suspect our pizzas were closer to 1:45 or 1:50 at most.
While I realize they probably had just finished the lunch rush, the dining area was filthy. Several empty tables were littered with crust, cheese, and sauce. The floor was likewise littered with waste. We were there for about 30 minutes total and I didn’t see any sort of cleaning take place.
While the concept is good (fast food pizza made to order), the execution was lacking. I think I’ll stick with a traditional chain. I’d rather wait a few more minutes and have a hot pizza and a clean table to eat at.

Ate lunch there yesterday, GREAT food! Staff VERY friendly! Very clean environment. Food was VERY FRESH and looked great, wanted one of EVERYTHING, but will have to keep going back to experience it more and more,
Great looking management team. Very professional, attentive and courteous.
Will recommend it to all my friends in the area.

A great pie for the money.
Please don’t mistake this as a four star Italian restaurant. It is pizza in five minutes. It’s essentially a lunch counter.
But it’s a good one. Large selection of toppings and it is made right in front of you. Good crust makes the lunch fun and fast!

My pizza is perfect every time! The crust, sauce, and topping choices are very good, and the five minute bake time is convenient. The service is friendly, and the restaurant is clean and fairly new. The e-​club offers some good deals, and you can get a 20% customer survey discount.

This was our first time trying Pie Five. I was pleasantly surprised and impressed. We are gluten free and are always looking for a solid gf crust. You pay $ 2 more per pizza but given that it is a full sized crust, I’m okay with that. The pizza maker immediately put on a new pair of gloves and unwrapped the gluten free crust. As she put the pizzas in the over, she called «gluten free.»
I ordered a Margherita with pepperoni, and my partner ordered the Five Star. The person who took out our pizzas used designated GF utensils to both pull it out and to cut it. GF pizzas automatically go in a box even if you are dining in. I asked for a metal pizza pan because they are washed and I’m not sensitive.
The crust was really quite good. It had a nice texture without being too dry or too chewy. They have lots of toppings including different sauces and different crusts. The pizzas are priced at only $ 6.99 and that kind of flat rate pricing is pretty nice. I think they were a little stingy with the basil though. Overall we would go back and it will move into our pizza rotation.
Ps, they have great brewed iced tea. The ginger peach is nice to mix into the black. Both are unsweetened and there is a pot of sweetened black.

Pie Five has been described as the Chipotle of Pizza. Fresh ingredients, efficient service, and a highly customizable pizza make this eatery stand out among its brethren of both pizzerias and fast food. Orders offer the voice between a pre-​designed pizza or a make-​your-​own recipe. Whether you prefer thick crust or thin crust, the cooks have your choice ready to go. There are sauce selections to your taste. And there are ample selections of toppings; I love that there are three kind of olives (kalamata, green, or black). Alas, my one complaint is that among the plethora of ingredients, there are no anchovies. After your pizza has baked (which takes an extraordinarily short amount of time) add magic dust (a blend of italian spices, parmesan and Romano) and a sprinkling of fresh basil.
For those who wish to keep of a pretense of healthy eating, another option is a salad, served in an edible pizza crust bowl.
Kids pizzas with a single topping provide an economical option for little diners. (My young twins split a kids pizza with kalamata olives and are very happy toddlers for it!)
One may purchase drinks at the cashier, with choice of bottled drinks (Honest Tea, beers, wine, Dasani water) or a fountain soda pop (Coca-​Cola products, hooray!).
Pie Five is a great choice for a quick meal, either carryout or dine in. Orders are done at location, which provides for a quick line (no telephone or online orders cutting in front of those who are in queue) and a fresh meal. The ambient music is not obnoxious. The restrooms are clean (one stall each) and the tables quite adequate for enjoying a quick meal. I heartily recommend Pie Five for an efficient and delicious pizza meal.

Pie Five Pizza is the love child of Chipotle and Papa Johns. Its a build-​it as you see it personal pan pizza place. Choose your crust style, then your sauce, cheese, meats & vegetables. Then they bake it for 5 minutes (hence the five in the name). Finally its ready to eat!
Pros: Decent pizza made quickly and they have beer! Any style of pizza all under $ 7, Gluten-​free options
Cons: My pizza could have been slightly warmer. Staff needs to pay more attention to wiping down tables as people leave.
All-​in-​all decent affordable pizza. We will be back!

Ok, I was very pleasantly surprised by Pie Five. My wife talked it up, and I’m a pizza snob, but I really enjoyed my first visit here.
It was lunch on a weekend and quiet. Staff was fine — not the friendliest, not the rudest. They just got the job done, no problem.
My wife had a BBQ Chicken pizza on pan crust, and I had a custom pizza with spicy marinara (surprisingly spicy), ham, bacon, pineapple and black olives on thin crust. The pizzas came out quickly and were both really tasty. The crusts were both good. Price was quite fair @ $ 7 for the personal pizza (and there is a currently special with a Unilocal check in that got us a $ 5 pizza instead of $ 7).
Would certainly return, no doubt!

What can I say, I may be addicted to unlimited combinations of pizza toppings… Pie Five is now one of our family go-​to places, and I highly recommend them. The price is reasonable, the people are fun and helpful, the crust is tasty, an the toppings are as variable and delicious as you choose.
The first time I came in, I was struck by how closely it resembled a Chipolte in décor. Perhaps that is by design. The menu is a little high up on the wall to really read it well while you make your way through a walled off line on the right. That really doesn’t matter, because when you get to the counter, you can easily see all the ingredients. I’m not interested in eating someone else’s pizza creation, so for me the menu is useless.
Once you get to the counter, you choose a crust (or salad, because you can put many of the same toppings on a bed of lettuce as well). I personally prefer the pan crust, but I have tried both. It is the same dough, and is tasty either way, however, only the pan can hold all the toppings I want.
Every time I have come, I have had different combinations. I started with a fairly generic pepperoni, green peppers, and some veggies and just got crazier every time I came in after that. I’m had all meats, I’ve had randomly chosen toppings, so far I haven’t had a bad pizza!
The portion size is sort of up to you and how much you want on the pie, but I typically can eat half, and save half for lunch the next day. As you make your way past the salad section and past the really super yummy looking deserts (I haven’t tired them), you get to the checkout at about the time your pie is done cooking. They can add some basil, pesto, parmesan, and pepper, if you want. The price is very reasonable, for the quantity of food. I mean it’s really reasonable.
The only criticism I have of this place is that I can’t eat here every night. I mean you can’t just have pizza for every meal, can you? I guess, I would also like to have real silverware, instead of plastic, when eating in. I suppose that saves on washing, and protects the pans from being damaged by metal on metal. But it would be easier to eat the big slices I tend to make for myself.
In summary, this place is one of my all time favorites. The variety that you choose for yourself makes it one that can be revisited frequently without ever having the same meal. I highly recommend Pie Five.