Milton’s Pizza

Best pizza in the area. I used to live in NYC and this is the New York style pizza I’d grown to love. We’ve only had the pizza on take out but it’s great even when we make the 25 minute drive back home. Don’t bother with the other pizza joints in the area unless you prefer generic, under inspired pizza.

Great pizza, thick crust and fresh toppings! Very nice and accommodating owner. Convenient location right off 64.

This treasure was a Unilocal find. We truly enjoyed this family owned and operated restaurant. Their ingredients are fresh, their service was fantastic, and the food was awesome.
Be prepared if you are passing through Quinton as we were — there is VERY LIMITED seating. It is mostly take out or delivery. However — they made plenty of room for the three of us to enjoy our dinner.
This is an easy find right off of 64 — if you’re in the area, you should check it out!

Super nice guy. Cares about his product. Got a slice of the meat lovers IT WAS AWESOME

First, I want to to know how someone who gives a Wendy’s a 5 star rating, can then follow up by giving this place just 3 stars.
Anyway, this place is pizza. Delicious, no nonsense pizza. Every time I’m on 64, I have to stop here and get a medium cheese. It’s New York style with great flavor.
Additionally, Milton (the owner) is great! He’s always welcoming and a humble family man. If you stop here, you won’t regret it!

Awesome family owned pizzeria. Easy access from the highway with quick service. Two small tables and a picnic table outside provided an option to eat in or carry out. Unfortunately my husband ate too much pizza and broke the table. True story! Pizza and Stromboli’s were delicious. I love it when I walk into a pizzeria and the owner is also the chef. It’s even better when the food is great. Extremely friendly family!

Stopped because of the good reviews on Unilocal.We ordered pizza which was very bland and not much taste at all. Just really had no favor what so ever. Also ordered BBQ wings which were good. More than likely will not come back.

Walk in for pizza stay for the conversation! I visited Milton’s on my way to VA Beach, I travel back and forth frequently and decided to stop for some pizza. I didn’t have high expectations but I was sold the moment I walked into the restaurant. I ordered a medium cheese pizza and before I got finish my order Milton started getting to work rolling and tossing the dough, adding the toppings and getting my pizza into the oven. As he prepared my meal he started telling me about his family and how he build the business with hard work and how he really loves what he does. He told me about his background, adversity that he’s overcome and by the time the pizza was ready I felt like I knew Milton. It took me back to the grassroots of small businesses and what it really means to our community! The pizza was phenomenal! It was the closest new York style pizza I’ve had in Virginia. You can taste the fresh herbs and the crunchy crust. This is now a must stop on my way to VA Beach during the weekends. I highly recommend giving Milton’s a try!

Heading up to DC from Norfolk, pizza was yummy and kids ate it all! Quick and easy right off the freeway. Thanks Milton!

Great Authentic pizza. Although Milton isn’t Italian, he learned the art of making pizza in Italy and speaks fluent Italian. The Sicilian Pizza and Calimari are fantastic. Mangia Bene!

Stopped by this place on a cross country trip. We were starving and this was the first pizza place we came to. It was one of those places that just looks like it will either end very badly or be shockingly well. We ordered two large NY style pizzas. First, our pizzas were ready in 10 minutes. Second the guy behind the counter cut our toddlers pizza into bite size pieces. Without being asked. Finally, the pizza was actually really good. I’d stop here again! ;)

We thought the sub sandwich was very tasty, it could have used a little more spices but the bread was really crunchy

Headed home from Great Wolf and stopped to gas up. Saw the pizza place and decided to grab a slice with the kids. Really good NY style, fresh and tasty. Just what we needed. Nice family that owns the place. Will stop again.

Stopped in here on a road trip. Great pizza, made from scratch! Good ingredients and good service. Don’t let the location fool you. This place makes some great pizza!

Great pizza — big size, great ingredients! We ordered a stuffed pizza, which came with mushrooms, even though they weren’t listed on the menu. I’m allergic to mushrooms. they were super apologetic and offered us a refund or a Gift Certificate for our next visit… we took the GC — we’ll be back!
BTW, they deliver!

My car broke down on the interstate and I got towed to a place near Milton’s, ended up stopping in to grab dinner. I got the large meat lover’s pizza and was blown away. Best NY style pizza I’ve had in a really long time.