Krispy Pizzeria

Krispy Pizza reminds me of at time long ago when you could stop on any corner in Brooklyn and get a great slice of pizza round or square. Just a great neighborhood slice joint. Very friendly owners that you can bs with while you wait for a great old school slice. Nothing fancy but always consistently good. Great go to spot when you want to feel like a kid again.

Krispy is a Brooklyn staple so to find out they had one on Staten Island was amazing! I live in tottenville and will drive 15 minutes to Krispy and 15 minutes back just for their vodka slices. The best vodka pizza on the island and the best part would be the sesame seeds on the crust. Nothing short of amazing

Tasty pizza!
Just like the one in Brooklyn location.
Just be aware, the seating area is so small and I think there is only 4 tables there.

The food here is really good… The reason I’m giving 2 stars is because I’m tired of receiving the wrong dish. I can’t be more clear when ordering my food, I repeat myself multiple times because of the previous mix ups, and yet they still screw up my order. They need to get a young girl or something answering phones because these older guys can’t keep up, or hear… Its a shame too because like i said, the food is good.
John Sancimino, the time and date of my order was about 2 – 3 hours before i wrote this review. I’m sorry to write such a review on Unilocal,as i am never one to bitch and complain or throw anyone under the bus but I was just so angry and fed up. The fact that i do indeed like the food and love the vodka sauce, made it even harder to say anything negative about the your place. The food is great… Just need to work on the staff.

I am finally done with Krispy Pizza. I have been a loyal supporter for quite some time now. I order delivery from them usually every other week and pick up a number of times too.
My boyfriend orders the same dish every time, chicken parm with vodka sauce on both the chicken and pasta. The first time they got the order wrong, I called them to see if they could send us a replacement dish, as my boyfriend does not eat regular tomato sauce. They rudely responded that we did not specify vodka sauce, when I explained that we did, they said we did not specify on the chicken. I explained yet again that I did and he said «well next time you have to clarify better.» I’m not quite sure how saying «can I have chicken parm with vodka sauce on both the pasta and the chicken» was not clear, but ok. They continued to mess up our order a number of times afterwards but I was so annoyed that they insinuated it was our fault that I never called back after.
Tonight I ordered the same dish again, the same dish I order every time. My boyfriend placed the order and I heard him say his order and specify he wanted vodka sauce on both the pasta and the chicken, and say that he had to specify because they always get our order wrong. When the food was delivered, he opened up the container and it was shrimp parm, not chicken.
I am tired of spending $ 15 each dish to get food that we don’t like and didn’t order. On the plus side, the food is usually pretty good, but don’t ever order delivery from them. There are enough pizzerias in this area that I can order from that won’t mess up my order every time. I definitely will never order from them again.

Worst pizza experience ever! I read other reviews and was very excited to try Krispy Pizza. Having grown up in Brooklyn I try new pizza whenever I get the chance. Friends even call me a pizza snob which is a badge I wear with pride!
Unfortunately I never got the chance to taste Krispy Pizza! I walked up and there was an older man sitting outside the door in a chair. He looked like he worked there since he was wearing all white. I smiled at him and he just ignored me. I went inside where I just found a younger guy mopping floors. He also ignored me until I asked him for help. It seemed as if they had closed early but forgot to lock the door? He took off his gloves and washed his hands as if he was going to help me. He headed out the door to get the old man who originally ignored me and was outside with his shoes off scratching his feet. He obviously had no interest in helping me since he knew I was there and never got up. At that point between his attitude and the fact that he was scratching his feet, I was disgusted and walked out.
I will never return to Krispy pizza!
Hi John, I am not sure at this time when I was there. If you can see the date I posted the original review that is the date. I posted shortly after leaving.
Thank you for your response. Judy

Really good pizza for a local joint. We love the white pie (light mozzarella, heavy on the ricotta)! Nice to have Zepolis on weekends too. Ordered a Krispy special hero yesterday (basically an italian) very good, but too much salad and lacking meat… I’ll just let them know next time, I’m sure they’ll do it better.
We order about once a week!

Fresh pizza every day. They are constantly making new pies. White slice is the best I’ve had in a very long time. Vodka slice and the polermo square are amazing. The old man (john) is usually the only one making the pizzas. I love the fact that they deliver pretty far (as I live no where near the restaurant). Grilled chicken cesar salad could use less dressing but the food is definitely above par and the prices are good. The workers are very friendly and down to earth. They make it their business to remember your name if you are a repeat customer, if not they have a good idea of what you want from your past orders. Fridays are usually very busy there so you have to be patient when ordering for delivery. They really get swamped with orders so I decided to drop in for pickup (mistake). I’d rather have the food delivered than stand around waiting on line for my food. That tells you how good their food is for a pizzeria. You will not be disappointed.

I order from here at least twice a week. Best vodka slice I’ve ever had. I always order there Krispy chicken salad as well it’s just amazing! There delivery service could definitely use some help. I would rather pick the food up then have it delivered due to the fact they are never on time.

First come coming here and had high expectations being that i heard good things about this pizzeria coming from brooklyn — ordered 4 slices — their original, white slice, grandma and vodka with my thoughts in what i like the best in order
white — well if you’re a fan of pizza, you should know what this slice is
vodka — compared to J&Ps, the vodka sauce is more pronounced here but the fresh mozz is more pronounced than J&Ps. what was interesting was that they have sesame seeds on their outer crust…
grandma — first time having a grandma slice actually since not all places serve gma slices. it’s a thinner version of a sicilian with the crust being very crunchy
Original — figured you can’t messed up pizza so we decided to give it a shot
Here on SI, you have supposedly 2 giants: Denino’s and Joe & Pat’s (which is practically almost down the block from this place)
If you’re a fan of thin crust like J&P’s then you’re not going to like the crust here. The crust here at Krispy’s is similar to Village Maria II which is down the block toward the Gannon Avenues, though it’s more similar to Village Maria in my opinion.
Denino’s crust isn’t as gummy but i actually like that gumminess which is present in Village Maria II
however if we’re to compare apples to apples, we’re going to have to be a bit more finer in detail because i feel it’s unfair to compare Krispy to Denino’s/J&P’s because the latter places are more restaurant-​like whereas places like Krispy is more premade take out style being that they already have premade pizza pies ready to be reheated.
so with that said, I still prefer Village Maria II down the block as they have more varieties (dat calamar!!) but the prices here for each of the slices as of this review is no more than $ 3 with some being 25 to 50 cents less but regardless, it’s not a bad place.
unfortunately it’s located where it’s harder for people to find…
$ 10 minimum credit card charge fyi

Great food! Amazingly fresh and great seasoning! Taste so fresh and great! Credits to the chef! Thanks for being on the island, we’ll surely order again!

Pretty, Pretty, Pretty Good,
You must trythe Palermo Square Slice and their White Slices. Man are they good.

Got 2 slices here a while back and they were quite good. Cheesy and with a nice crust. I shall return.