Fresh Catch Seafood Grill

Enjoyed the food and service. Had the fish n chips which was very good and the conch appetizer which was very tasty. Good place to eat.

In Hutchinson Island for a family wedding & visited Fresh Catch thanks to the Unilocal rating & reviews.
Not disappointed by our dinner. Arrived shortly before 8 pm on a Sun. (closing was at 9pm)
Sat outside, nice breeze & fans kept the air moving.
Service was fine. Drinks, served promptly; iced tea & margarita — mom said it was stong on tequila :-)
Ordered Panko chicken (I don’t eat seafood). Very pleased — 3, tender pieces. Glad I was able to substitute standard sides (waffle fries & coleslaw) w/​veggies & potatoes (even though I asked for rice)
Mom ordered shrimp dish. She enjoyed it. Liked the coleslaw — vinegar based.
Would recommend based on our visit.

We live ⁴⁄₁₀ mile away and that’s good and bad. The good: Food, atmosphere, service, surroundings, hours are all excellent. The bad: Every time we go for a walk… we want to walk to Fresh Catch! Without doubt, we have been introduced to some of the most delicious meals we’ve tasted. The fish is indeed very fresh. They take great pride in that. Their non-​seafood items are just as excellent. They fix a wonderful chicken piccata! Appetizers, salads, desserts, everything is very tasty. The service? Couldn’t be better! The entertainment on Thursday, Friday, and Saturday, too!

Been here a few times with my fiancé, he gets the steak and i get the salmon it always comes out so good plus the service is excellent!

What a fantastic experience we all had at FRESH CATCH Seafood Grill, Stuart, Florida!!! Eric was amazing, he totally changed my mind on oysters!!! Exceptional in his genuine attitude to explaining seafood, oyster’s what to look for and how he himself enjoys them. I’M CONVERTED! Outstanding service, interest and engaging in his love for the seafood that’s served at FRESH CATCH Seafood Grill!!! If you want to enjoy passion in life, that is represented in food served and an engaging, interested person that enjoys what people experience, eat at FRESH CATCH Seafood Grill. I’ll always stop here and embrace passionate people in business!!!

What a disappointment. This place came highly recommended! I’m not sure if we arrived too early, there were staffing issues at the restaurant, or we simply were not appreciated, but the six of us left shaking our heads over the confused display we witnessed. It was early afternoon and the place was nearly empty so nobody seemed rushed, but the host never brought us a high chair for the baby as he said he would, the waiter had to be asked twice to bring straws for our drinks, the baby’s food arrived last after we all fed her from our plates, and the chef burned the salmon but served it anyway! We all left hungry. With so many excellent restaurants in the area, these generous and hungry diners will take our friends to another restaurant next time! By the way, the restaurant is gorgeous to see! The look of the place raised our expectations even more. I’m guessing that if you don’t want customers at 3:45, you probably shouldn’t open until later, though. Please, tell me that this was an anomaly, please?

First rate meal. Period
Great service complemented delicious fresh catch which was tile fish .
Prepared confidently with just the right amount of herb butter. Melted
Can’t wait to return

Late lunch. Shrimp and Maui tacos really hit the spot. Ice cold beers. Service very friendly but kinda on the slow side. Pretty sure it was the kitchen. Probably gonna be heading back soon to try other items on their menu.

Had the crab cake and spinach salad. The crab cake was a bit dry but tasty. The salad was delicious. Service was very attentive. The place was a bit loud. I would still return if I am in the area again.

The plusses they give a generous pour on the wine. Our server was nice. But we waited a very long time. We did get some soup to try because the wait was so long. For 4 people it was about 100.00. It was no where near worth the price. I did not think the fish burrito would be cold inside. That seemed odd. Especially since there server said they are known for there burritos. But the fish did taste fresh. I liked the atmosphere. The folks in the var seemed like they were having fun.

Went for happy hour. Had Mahi tacos and they were fantastic. Staff was friendly service was great. Did I mention the tacos were awesome!

Stopped in for lunch and both my wife and I enjoyed a wonderful lunch. Fresh seafood and wonderful attentive service. Will definitely be back.

Great Food, Always great service! This place is a gem!

Awesome!!! Great ambiance that attracts a good crowd. I had the Seafood Pot which was fantastic. If you like clams, oysters and shrimp in a garlic and tomato sauce this is it. My wife had the fried shrimp and it was not greasy nor heavily battered and was delicious.
Our waiter Paul was amazing!
They have a lovely patio area and musicians on the weekend. I really recommend a visit. We will return very soon.

Great oysters and great service. Reasonably priced, although the grilled snapper came out a bit too dry :/

Very happy each of the 5 times Ive dined there. They had Golden Tilefish on special and had it pan seared Cooked perfectly, and Id love to have it again!
The grilled Mahi is a favorite of mine as well Its always nice when a restaurant lets the quality of their produce do the talking and the Mahi is no exception These people know fish.
Lively bar area and occasional live music is nice too
Id go back anytime

Great lobster special and you can’t beat their $ 5 sheikh — fish tacos. Place is hopping as the bar is a great place to eat. Fresh oyster are good as well.
Ronn just Ronn
The home in the wall food guy

Food = good /​ambience = a little dark
I did not have to make reservations to go to this restaurant — please note — I visited this restaurant during the week so I do not feel a reservation was needed. I am not sure reservations are even taken.
Service: Great. I did not have to ask for refills. The waitress knew the menu and communicated her suggestions very clearly.
Food: not bad, tasted very well.
Price: not bad, the amount of food that you receive to the amount of you food you get is on par with what you would expect.
Desert: did not try.
Not a bad place to grab a bite, I just thought the restaurant was a little dark.

I have been to many restaurants in Stuart and have to say this one is one of my favorites! Elaine had been our server a few times and is great! Boomer the bartender is awesome and energetic, fun atmosphere, consistent service, staff is always engaging and helpful.

There aren’t a lot of casual, local eateries for a sit-​down dinner in the Stuart area, but we were definitely A-​OK with our visit to Fresh Catch, so if you’re in the mood for non-​chain eating, with plenty of seafood, in a casual ambiance with reasonable prices, Fresh Catch is sure to hit the spot.
I dined out on their nice, relaxing outdoor patio with a group of 12, and while we weren’t a rowdy group, we were a hungry and thirsty group, and our waitress did a great job juggling our requests for beverage refills, extra sauces, etc., all while retaining her sense of humor.
I was pleasantly surprised with the mojito, although it was a bit heavy on the soda water. The beer drinkers in the group were happy with the beer selections on draught and bottled, so no complaints there. In typical fashion for this group, we ordered just about one of every appetizer item on the menu. I don’t recall anything particularly outstanding; both the conch fritters and hush puppies were so fried that it was hard to tell the difference between them. The Wahoo Fish Dip was pretty good, however.
There’s a huge selection of food on the dinner menu, definitely suitable for any palate. I was impressed at how much serious non-​seafood items were available, while still dedicating sections of the menu to the sea-​faring items. Although I was tempted to go for fish tacos or a shrimp burrito, I opted for the fresh catch of the day to keep it local and to see if Fresh Catch could live up to their name! Turns out the catch, hogfish or black grouper I believe, was a fish I had never had before, so I had it grilled, and the waitress was nice enough to give me a double portion of steamed veggies as opposed to mashed potatoes and veggies.
One of my dining companions raved and raved over their Seafood Pot, and everyone seemed to enjoy their entrees.
The most memorable aspect about my visit to Fresh Catch was their homemade habanero-​based hot sauce that isn’t on their menu, but was brought to me with a wink (and a warning) when I asked for hot sauce. Clearly they didn’t know I am the Spice Fiend, and while the sauce was tasty and packed some heat, it didn’t necessitate the warning that came with it :-)