Sushi Metsuyan

Horrifyingly bad service, mediocre food, and ridiculous prices. I’d rather skip the meal and give my money to charity. DO NOT RECOMMEND.

Awful dining experience from start to finish. Four of us sat for dinner — we ordered two appetizers to share and they brought everything out at the same time with our main dishes. The «seared tuna» was completely cooked through and tasted terrible.
And then we went to pay using our $ 50 gift card — and they said they couldn’t find the gift card in the system. Clearly a trend considering the review below that said the exact same thing! It is outrageous that there is no record in the store to check gift card purchases if you are using a system that is clearly faulty and does not process gift cards appropriately. someone paid good money to get us that gift!

Dis honest company refuses to honor gift certificate my wife had gotten as a gift. Claimed could not find in system the number. Although gift card has no expropriation date.

This is my favorite local lunch spot for three reasons. 1) It’s got generous and inexpensive lunch specials, 2) It’s small but cozy– you can have a business lunch and not be surrounded by screaming kids, and 3) The food is consistently good and always tastes the way it’s supposed to.
The worst aspect here is the service; there have been some truly awful waiters in the past, however recently they’ve improved. I’m not a huge sushi fan, and I ike that the menu has lots of non sushi options.

Friendly service and great food. I recommend the fries with the spicy mayo sauce. I’m also a huge fan of the asparagus rolls.

This place has really gone downhill in the past years sad to say it but I think that their reign in Teaneck is over.

Love this place! As far as I’m concerned it is the one place in Teaneck where I can eat and feel good afterwards. The food is always fresh and delicious. It’s the only place worth visiting in Teaneck!

Came here on A Sunday for my husband’s birthday. We sat for 2 hours and didn’t receive our full order. We were not given our cups for soy sauce nor refills on drinks. I have been here in the past and I am extremely disappointed in the service. The food that we got was «okay» but I am disappointed that we never received our full order. It was even challenging to track down the waitress for our check. I recommend if you want to eat here get it to go as they give priority to phone orders.

Gross! How can you screw up sushi? Well, dont waste your time and money here! Bad service and no where to sit.

I’m a huge sushi fan, as well as a sushi snob, and I don’t eat kosher unless the company I’m with dictates it. I had a business lunch here a few weeks ago. Service was good and mostly attentive, and the construction of the rolls was good. I ordered 2 rolls, and the fish itself was fresh enough and I enjoyed it, but it was just kind of ”meh.” It’s not a bad place by any means, and definitely a step above some other neighborhood places, but it’s nothing to rave about. I wouldn’t necessarily return unless I had to eat kosher.

Their fish definitely doesn’t taste fresh !!! I have had much better kosher sushi. The lady waitress at the counter is very rude too. Definitely a pass on this place

The best kosher sushi — hands down. Feet down, even. Peanut crunch roll is really creative and the mainstays are all executed flawlessly. The specials are real nice, too. For a while you really had to check your take-​out orders because they’d consistently screw it up — but that doesn’t happen anymore. The staff is real nice, eating in is a pleasure, but definitely call ahead to reserve since there really are not so many tables.

Worst management ever. Lousy service in Teaneck AND Monsey. Ruined my son’s Bar Mitzvah dinner: we pre-​ordered 35 meals and STILL waited 2 hours for our food. The guests had to leave before dinner was even served! Disgraceful treatment of customers. Dishonorable owner; lies to his clientele. When my son’s father complained about our disgraceful treatment at the Bar Mitzvah dinner, the owner didn’t even apologize! He gave some BS excuse about the number of choices we offered our guests. How is that any different than if we’d just ordered right off the menu?! There was NO reason for how we were treated. It was unprofessional and embarrassing. To «make it up to us,» the owner promised my 2 children and me a complimentary meal.
That was tonight. After we ordered, he told his staff to offer us a credit of $ 100. I’ve already paid this guy $ 1800 cash! I’ve got his offer of a complimentary meal in writing. If you know what’s good for you, avoid Sushi Metsuyan at all costs. Go find a GOOD restaurant where they appreciate their customers.
The Torah says to treat people how you want to be treated. I guess the owner wants to be treated as horribly as he treated me and my family.

The Grilled asparagus sushi was the best asparagus sushi I’ve had… ever. Grilled? Who would of thunk? We also ordered the bagel sushi with tofu cream cheese (cool for the lactose intolerant) I normally order a Philadelphia roll.(yum) So it was a nice change. The lady next to us had ordered the fish on top of noodles– Looked good I think it was a lunch thing, we came back for dinner and order what I thought was it. It ended up being Salmon with noodles and vegis it was ok.(something I may be able to make) The sushi we had at lunch was really good and I am comparing it to non-​kosher sushi/​Japanese places.

There’s one thing to keep in mind here — Don’t come for the ambiance. It is small, and the tables are close together. The sushi is expensive, and sometimes the service is, well, Israeli… (You know what I mean by this)
However, the sushi is good, and this restaurant does grace us with good kosher sushi in Teaneck! Any other restaurant providing kosher sushi merely has sushi as part of the greater whole. Sushi doesn’t really belong in pizza places, but this is a rant for another review!
They offer lunch specials, which are actually pretty good deals. They also do take out, and are relatively prompt. Despite the few complaints above, somehow we keep coming back again and again! They must be doing something right!

small place /​small tables
the service is good
the food is ok — the good thing is: this is a kosher sushi place — no need to think what you can or what you can not eat.