I’m from Long Island and our bagels are hands down, the best, but Bagelicious actually compares! Staff is super friendly and the bagels are amazing and to my surprise nicely sized. Can’t tell you how many bagel places I’ve been to in Westchester with small bagels. Love this place and go here almost every morning before work.
Michael N.
Rating des Ortes: 5 New York, NY
Amazing bagels. Best you can get in all of Westchester. If you’re looking for breakfast I recommend the sausage egg and cheese on everything bagel. Cream cheese spreads are also delicious
Matt E.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Jackson, WY
Love this place!
Jon O.
Rating des Ortes: 3 Pleasantville, NY
Ok when this place was Sunshine Bagel it had the same problem. An awesome and huge bagel! But the staff is completely incompetent. If you ask for anything more than a bagel with cream cheese or a bagel with butter, you will either go through a tremendous amount of brain cell loss or you will be there until its time for dinner. I ordered a bacon, egg, and cheese on a plain bagel and the lady tried grabbing a sesame bagel. Then it took her about 10 minutes to make it. My friend ordered a bagel with«extra cream cheese» and they gave him a bagel with vegetable cream cheese and tried to charged him twice as much. If you want a good bagel from this place you might be best off to get a plain bagel and put the cream cheese on yourself at home.