Renae Witt, DPM

The worst experience I’ve ever encountered… steer clear… she’s in it for the money. looked like she was high on Ambien.

By recommendation of my husband’s General doctor, I went with my husband to Dr. Witt’s office. We were seen quickly and Dr. Witt was nice, friendly and seemed to be very knowledgeable. X-​rays were recommended (had to go elsewhere for these). My husband had an ingrown toenail on his big toe that was inflamed and very painful. He had the exact same situation on his other big toe 10 years earlier and had it repaired by a different doctor. At that time he felt nothing during the procedure, the toe is still doing well, and it was a good experience all around so my husband had great hope in Dr. Witt providing the same experience. During the procedure to remove the ingrown nail, Dr. Witt made fun of my husband for being a «baby» about the pain he was experiencing. By his request, twice, she administered more local pain medication and upon cutting a section of his nail off, he was still in a lot of pain. She looked at me several times during the procedure and rolled her eyes, then remarked how ‘the children she treats don’t complain as much as he does’. By the end of the procedure my husband had endured a lot of pain. Here it is only 3 years later and the same toe is inflamed again, and a new nail is now growing straight up out of his toenail bed. The $ 100 charged to each of us for a tiny 10 ml bottle of fungus remover did not pan out to remove the fungus problem. She charged my husband over $ 500 for this procedure even though he had insurance. I just had the same procedure done last year and it cost me less than $ 100 through the same insurance company. Friendly and a license to practice medicine does not count for a lousy bedside manner, lack of compassion or skill in handling a client who is obviously in pain and suffering, not having a professional manner or taking care of the situation properly. Thankful for knowing about Unilocal now, wish we had read the reviews back in 2013 first.

due to an error on the part of either myself or the scheduling service, I wound up in the wrong location, an old one they had long since left. I called and they were still waiting for me. Helped me get the quickest route to their current location and still saw me almost an hour after stated closing time.
Had nasty, fungus ridden ingrown nail removed. Felt nothing whatsoever. Would I go back again? No, I wont need to. Highly recommend

DO NOT GO HERE!!! She is in this business to make money without properly diagnosing people. Please review all the posts on Unilocal before considering seeing this lady. My experience was exactly the same as the rest of people who posted. She was more concerned about my insurance then my injury. Sounds like she examines everybody and insist you purchase a full boot without x-​Rays. I trusted her so of course and paid for the tall boot, which cost me $ 250.00. The exam $ 200.00, that’s without x-​Ray. She faxed in requests to 2 different pharmacies without my authorization. I Shared my concerns with the pharmacy and the imaging company who did make x-​Ray and they told me that I was not the first person to have doubts about Dr. Witt. I am currently disputing the charges with my credit card company and filing a complaint with the BBB.

Ill give her 1 star for being a practitioner and that’s it! I went to see this lady in May 2014 when I tore my Achilles. I basically just picked someone out of desperation and made a mistake. Every bad review you see in her profile is accurate. I wont go in to great detail other than the fact she only cared about meeting my deductible and forced her product (boot) on to me and charged me a ridiculous fee of $ 350. She wrote the wrong prescription and sent me on my way. She spent 10 minutes with me and billed $ 500 on the spot. I tried to return the boot to her because i did select another Dr. I fought the charges and i still ended up paying $ 500 for 10 minutes of service. Modern day crook. Dont believe anything this lady represents, I was terified after reading other reviews after I has already seen her and saw the same mistakes! Run!

This was the most negative experience I have ever encountered. My daughter broke her foot in 3 places. Dr. Witt discussed insurance and cost with me before she ever looked at my daughter’s foot. For the record, I have dual coverage and work in the medical insurance industry, so I understand insurance. She ended up charging me up front for a boot (which was a bad call on her part and after two second opinions we ended up in a cast) and charging my insurance for services never provided and also billing for dates of service we never went to see her. When my insurance paid for the boot, it was a struggle to get my $ 300 back from her. She also had a different diagnosis than 2 of the orthopedic surgeons we received 2^nd opinions from.
The only positve comment was that we did not have to wait and she agreed to us fairly quickly.

Dr Renae Witt is no ordinary practitioner, there’s a reason she does what she does, she loves it and is great. She has a real feel for medicine the study the practice, some of her patients may have similar issues and others something she hasn’t worked with before but she never says no or buys time, she goes right in to cure and help and put that smile on a face. I have a ton of respect for Dr Witt

Dr. Witt is absolutely one of the most ridiculous people I have ever met. I smelled her fakeness the moment I met her. She was way more concerned with the billing then my injury and acted like she was doing me a favor. She tried to put me in a full boot for a broken toe and when I declined and asked for a smaller shoe, she made a comment that I had «saved myself $ 300 since that is the difference in cost between small and large boot»…I mean, really? With a broken toe, pain, and uncertainty about recovery/work…the cost was not the first thing on my mind! Hobbling around in a full boot would have been ridiculous – these are designed for ankles/​etc, not a toe fracture.
SHADY! I happen have great insurance and understand my coverages and she (not her staff) proceeded to argue with me about the deductible. I ended up paying out of pocket anyway to be agreeable and of course my insurance paid the full amount directly to her. I am STILL TRYING to get my money back, and she’s an in-​network provider of my insurance! She wants me to give her «some time» to get into the office to cut a check from her personal account and also said that I have to come to her office to sign a waiver — what kind of monkey business is she running??? This is what the insurance industry refers to as «double-​dipping» and it is illegal! The ONLY reason I went here was because the urgent care recommended her and I switched doctors as soon as I could! DO NOT GO HERE, save yourself the headache! There are honest doctors out there that will take care of you, your injury, and your pocketbook much better!

Stay away from her.
She charged my insurance company a lot of money, for a «diagnostic test, x-​rays, and consultation.» The «diagnostic test» was about a minute of her explaining that my skin was dry, and that I should buy a $ 30 bottle of lotion from her (a generic brand that is also available at Amazon for half the price); the consultation was a re-​statement of the diagnostic test; the «x-​rays» were NOTHING — she just said «You need an x-​ray – schedule one at the front desk on your way out.»
When I called the front desk after I got my bill to tell her I’m not letting my insurance company pay for a non-​existent x-​ray and diagnostic test, she never returned my call. I called about 3 different days. Eventually, my insurance company paid for it all, just like she knew they would. Freakin’ con-​artist.