Long Island Pizza

Great food every time. Best pizza in williamsport, best cheesecake I ever had. The staff are great and always make me feel at home! The prices are dirt cheap. I have nothing bad to say. Phenomenal place.

Decent pizza. Not my favorite but the person I was with thought it was excellent. Owner is very nice and great service.

Ok where to begin? The food. The bread, the dough… I don’t know what they put in it, what kind of magic fairy dust they sprinkle in but it is, bar none, THE. BEST. I’ve ever had. It’s practically indescribable, it’s so delicious!!! So the sandwiches, the garlic knots, the pizza… BEYOND DELICIOUS!!! Fresh ingredients. Always! Then they have these salads! The chicken salad is my absolute favorite. Fresh mozzarella, sweet oranges, cucumbers, glazed nuts, juicy pieces of chicken breast over a fresh bed of romaine lettuce and I always opt for the mushrooms. They’re warm and have some kind of I don’t know what on them that pulls this salad together to make it a meal fit for a king!!! Honey mustard dressing or not, it’s scrumptious!!! My mouth waters just thinking about that salad as I write this. Then there is Kurt and the crew… They make every effort to get to know each of they’re customers so that they no longer see them as customers but extended family coming in to fill their bellies! And let me tell you something, THEY DO FILL THE BELLIES! The portions are more than enough for the hungriest of man, woman or child! The prices are just right! OH! AND LET ME NOT FORGET… They have SUNSET! ICE! CREAM! And these AMAZING DESERT PIZZAS & WARM SWEET SUCCULENT CINNAMON KNOTS with some kind of make your grandma blush frosting dip stuff!!! FUGGEDDABODIT!!! If you’re looking for a quick bite to eat or a meal, look NO FURTHER!!! This place has you covered!!!

I can’t say I’ve ever been dissatisfied with the pizza here; I’ve had it when friends ordered it, and it was fantastic. This was only my second time actually coming in to the restaurant, however, and I loved it. The owner greeted me as soon as I came in (I’m sure I was the only call-​in at that time but the personal touch is still nice!), and the gentleman at the counter was also friendly and personable. Of course, I’m sure you’re hungry for more details about the food. Toppings are all well and good but I went with a plain pizza, which was fantastic. The cheese was great, not too much, not too little; the sauce was well-​balanced and naturally, the crust was just perfect. Also, garlic knots. Those wonderful little chunks of heaven had just enough garlic so as not to be overpowering but flavourful enough to complement the pizza like a boss. I guarantee you I’ll be back again. Definitely one of the best pizza places in the area.

This is a second generation family run business. Everyone is super nice and the pizza is great. They have a great selection of specialty pizza and did I mention they are all super nice…
I try to stop in whenever I am in the area. Even if it is just for a slice or an order of there knots. they even added sunset ice cream to the mix:)
I have even bought a single roll to take home a make my own sandwich. The rolls are incredible and did I mention how nice they are?
The owner is always there and takes great pride in his shop.
This is a great family pizza joint. Like the ones I remember as a kid.
Can’t wait to be back in town, so I can stop in again!

The owner and staff really make this place amazing. He pays very close attention to detail and is very focused on making a quality product. Treats us like friends every time we are in. Thanks!

I really liked their pizza the first time I had it, so I had high hopes this time.
I ordered a large veggie pizza. I think the menu should be clearer that this is a white pizza. I really wanted a regular pizza with tomato sauce and lots of fresh veggies.
4 stars for the crust, which is delicious, but 2 stars for everything else. The veggies were rubbery and overcooked and this ruined the rest of it :(
I’ll try them again, but definitely not for any pizzas with veggies.

i ordered from here 2 more times after my first try and got more and more disapointed each time. Anything i got from this place that had chicken on it tasted of freezer burn. The wings are disgusting, they are slimy and fatty (worse than dominos wings). The second time i ordered i thought maybe it was just a fluke so i gave them another shot and it was even worse. I will give them credit that they do have awesome subs and pretty much anything that doesnt involve chicken is good.
Sadly i have another dislike in the way they do phone orders, i do appreciate some good customer service but when it is so obviously faked and scripted it just makes it that much worse. I would rather be rushed off the phone than talked to like i am an idiot.

I ordered pizza from here for the first time because of the reviews on here and was disappointed. I ordered a large pizza with extra mushrooms and an order of wings and it came to $ 25. They charged me $ 4 for the mushrooms and the pizza barely had any on it and the crust was definitely not thin like New York pizza. The sauce however was very delicious and the cheese as well. The wings were below my expectations as well. The flavor of the hot sauce on them was great but the wings themselves were mushy. Possibly because they were baked and I’m not a fan of baked wings or maybe they just needs to be baked longer. In the end I was disappointed with the food for the price and will not be ordering again.

I think I’ve found my new local favorite pizza joint! Service was fast and friendly, which was very much appreciated since we were on our way to see a movie, and had just stopped in for a quick bite. The pizza looked and smelled delicious, but my friend had a Stromboli (which he enjoyed), and I had the garlic and cinnamon knots combo (which was fantastic). A great bargain, too– I think we both ate until we were stuffed for less than $ 10, including drinks! Haven’t had the ice cream yet, but it’s come highly recommended. It’s going to be hard to pass this place up!

Pizza was great and prices were amazing reasonable. The place seems to be family run and are very polite and courteous. Family values run deep here in more ways than 1.

Ah, the old hometown has changed over the years. I remember the days when this shopping plaza was anchored by the Izod outlet store. It had lobster embroidered pants years before I discovered Lilly Pulitzer. Truth.
I ended up in Long Island Pizza with a mission in mind. I was in search of Sunset Ice Cream. They deliver, but I’ll cover lunch before dessert. As we walked in, we were greeted with a friendly hello and a pithy patois about the day’s slices. Try the white pizza, it’s not racial, it’s ricotta. Thumbs up for wit and for making me feel welcome. All too often pizza joints are surly… whaddaya want? Not here! Regulars were greeted by name, and they came by all though our visit.
The guy taking my order saw that I was shellshocked by dragging my kids and their cousins out to lunch. Summing up my situation, he offered me the 8 knots, one topping pie, 2 liter deal. Done and done. Way to take the pain out of feeding a bunch of kids.
The pizza featured a fluffy, tender crust and delicious sauce. It was a bit on the cheesy side (star off for that, but you may like tons of cheese). Knots were light, well seasoned but not too heavy on the garlic, and served with the yummo sauce. I’d be back just for those items.
After the meal, we made our way over to the ice cream counter. They were out of some core flavors– cookie dough and one other that nephew asked for, but an alternative was suggested and accepted. Then it was time for the big score. Half gallons of Sunset Ice Cream to bring home. While it wasn’t on their regular list, I was able to grab 3 half gallons of teaberry. Angels wept. Neighbors in Plymouth Meeting rejoiced. Dad had a proper Father’s Day gift. All was well in the world.

Best pizza and meatball subs in town.

While there is a lot of cheese and toppings the dough was not done enough. Also the pizza as a whole was bland. I wouldn’t order this again.

place looks a little ominous from the outside, but walk through that door and you’d think you were on the island. greeted as we walked through the door — most surprising. had a sun gazette daily deal offer — no problem. enjoyed a bohemian pizza — delish! the owner greeted nearly everyone by name — knew what most of them wanted. refreshing escape from the «lip service» you get at most restaurants these days. we will definitely go back to try more items on the menu — coupon or not!

Sauce is delicious. Owner is a very nice guy. always cordial. He sets the ambiance of the place. Definitely recommend for the experience, prices, and pizza!