Shrewsbury Pizzaria

Awesome salad with grilled chicken.
A very friendly owner, and as a bonus they make their own pita bread.
I have also had their steak & cheese subs and their chicken kabob subs, both were very good.
I have no idea how their pizza is as of yet.

Been going to shrewsbury pizza since I was 16. Always have ordered the meatball sub. Date night place to go. Pete has always made great food! The last was not equal to the past, the sub was tasteless. I assume that Pete has sold the business.
My date of 48 years will miss our meatball sub and grape soda night – just a GREAT memory now!
Thanks Pete for all the good times.

the two stars are for the service. wish I could give them a star for food but alas.,

No bad if you don’t mind paying for garbage on a plate. First time I ordered delivery. The driver drove into the driveway, turned around and left to the next house, then back up the street before finally finding us at the first house he stopped at. Ordered 2 Gyros and fries, asked for ketchup but didn’t get any. Gyros were absolutely disgusting! Not bad if you love more onions than everything else. They were both burnt, tomatoes were old and soggy, skimmpy on the sauce. Had to use a fork as they are not traditional Gyros but on a half of syrian bread that fall apart when trying to eat as a sandwich. The fries were the bottom of the pan fries. So burnt there was not even potatoe in the middle, all broken pieces. I will never order this garbage again! No one seems to have any pride in their businesses anymore.

The pizza is here is average. The dough is pre-​made and in a refrigerated pan that is pulled out to order. The dough is already sauced when coming out of the refrigerator, so all that needs to be added is the cheese and toppings. For me, this causes the pizza to loose a little flavor.
I also had the chicken fingers and fries, which are both frozen products. The owner’s brother took a fry out of the frier basket that had my food in it, and ate it. That seemed a bit unhygienic, as he was not wearing gloves.
Overall, the food is ok and the prep time is good.

My boyfriend and I were driving through the area and needed a quick bite. Shrewsbury Pizzaria was conveniently roadside — has a small parking lot to the side, but we were able to pull up and get a spot right out front by the curb.
Food prep was quick — we got our orders within about 10 minutes — but the ingredients were quality. He got the meatball sub, and I got the Philly cheese steak.
The meatballs were good, but was one-​note in terms of flavor. I think the red sauce could’ve used more spices and salt. (And I’m usually one to think things are too salty. Not this time!)
The cheese steak ended up being the star of the meal with loads of peppers, onions, and mushrooms. It had a sauce that I couldn’t quite place, but it made the sandwich a real standout.
We both ordered small sandwiches, but they were packed with meat. At the end of the meal, we were stuffed but both had leftovers.
All in all, we’d stop here again, but would pass on the meatball sub in favor of something with more flavor.

Really awesome pizza I would highly recommend the buffalo chicken pizza. The service was great although we were the only ones there at the time but I think they would have still been speedy and they were very helpful as well

First time customer. My husband and brother-​in-​law are fried chicken fans. We got a flyer in the mail recently from Shrewsbury Pizzeria and they advertised Broaster Chicken as deliciously moist and fresh southern fried chicken and boy did they deliver! We will be back for sure! We got the 12 piece which comes with a huge amount of steak fries. Hot, fresh and delicious!!! A must try for sure. On a side note, the people working there were incredibly friendly. So happy we tried it!

My favorite pizza place ever, small and local with awful parking. However it is the pizza of my childhood and the only place I’ve ever gone that puts enough cheese on the pizza and then some!

This is the best pizza in Shrewsbury! The kids love it. They have a special on Mondays and Tuesdays — 2 large cheese for about $ 13.

Local pizza joint getting pies ready in 10 min for $ 12.50. Nothing flashy but delivered a quality pizza for a reasonable price from old town Shrewsbury. Worth the trip and will get another visit.

Average pizza here at best, but certainly not bad. Decent value. You will do okay with just about anything on the menu. Freindly folks at this place.

The pizza here is pretty good overall. Decent crust, the sauce is not too sweet, and the amount and quality of the toppings is solid. The best bet, however, are the sandwiches. These things are HUGE! I usually get the Italian sub, which has tons of meat and cheese, so thick you can hardly get your mouth around it. And its only 6 bucks. Great deal!